Frustrated with sparking real conversations in your writing community? Unpopular Opinion prompts are your secret weapon for igniting meaningful debate, drawing out quieter voices, and creating a space where every perspective matters.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Unpopular Opinion content taps into the natural curiosity and passion of writers by encouraging them to share perspectives that are often overlooked. When community members see a safe space to discuss controversial or unconventional ideas, they are more likely to participate and engage in thoughtful exchange. This not only drives higher activity but also attracts a diverse range of viewpoints, enriching the discussion and community experience.
Psychologically, inviting dissent and counterpoint satisfies our desire for both validation and challenge. Writers, in particular, thrive on exploring nuance and defending their creative choices. Unpopular Opinion posts harness this by making it clear that every voice is valued, as long as the conversation remains respectful and constructive.
Unpopular opinion: Writing daily is overrated. What do you think?
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Writing daily is overrated. What do you think?"
I think first drafts should be messy on purpose. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "I think first drafts should be messy on purpose. Agree or disagree?"
Hot take: Plot is less important than character. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "Hot take: Plot is less important than character. Thoughts?"
Unpopular opinion: Writer's block is a myth. Do you agree?
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Writer's block is a myth. Do you agree?"
I believe adverbs are unfairly criticized in writing. What's your view?
💡 Example: "I believe adverbs are unfairly criticized in writing. What's your view?"
Does anyone else think show, don't tell is overused advice?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else think show, don't tell is overused advice?"
I prefer writing by hand over typing. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I prefer writing by hand over typing. Anyone else?"
Unpopular opinion: Outlining can stifle creativity. Agree or not?
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Outlining can stifle creativity. Agree or not?"
I think writing groups do more harm than good. Change my mind.
💡 Example: "I think writing groups do more harm than good. Change my mind."
Is reading widely really necessary to be a good writer?
💡 Example: "Is reading widely really necessary to be a good writer?"
I think using big words can actually weaken prose. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "I think using big words can actually weaken prose. Thoughts?"
Unpopular opinion: Writing to market is not selling out.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Writing to market is not selling out."
I believe dialogue tags other than said add flavor. Do you agree?
💡 Example: "I believe dialogue tags other than said add flavor. Do you agree?"
Unpopular opinion: Most writing rules are made to be broken.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Most writing rules are made to be broken."
I actually enjoy editing more than drafting. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I actually enjoy editing more than drafting. Anyone else?"
Hot take: Overplanning kills stories. What do you think?
💡 Example: "Hot take: Overplanning kills stories. What do you think?"
I think writing fanfiction is a great way to improve craft.
💡 Example: "I think writing fanfiction is a great way to improve craft."
Unpopular opinion: Writing for social media is real writing.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Writing for social media is real writing."
I think prologues are underappreciated. Do you use them?
💡 Example: "I think prologues are underappreciated. Do you use them?"
Does anyone else dislike writing prompts?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else dislike writing prompts?"
Hot take: Writing sprints are not effective for everyone.
💡 Example: "Hot take: Writing sprints are not effective for everyone."
I find writing advice more confusing than helpful. Share your experience.
💡 Example: "I find writing advice more confusing than helpful. Share your experience."
Unpopular opinion: Not every story needs a theme.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Not every story needs a theme."
I think writing in silence is overrated. Who prefers background noise?
💡 Example: "I think writing in silence is overrated. Who prefers background noise?"
Hot take: Writing awards don't reflect true talent.
💡 Example: "Hot take: Writing awards don't reflect true talent."
Unpopular opinion: You can be a great writer without reading classics.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: You can be a great writer without reading classics."
I believe writing for money is just as valid as writing for art.
💡 Example: "I believe writing for money is just as valid as writing for art."
Does anyone else dislike writing synopses?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else dislike writing synopses?"
Unpopular opinion: Flash fiction is harder than novels.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Flash fiction is harder than novels."
I think writing under pressure brings out my best work. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I think writing under pressure brings out my best work. Anyone else?"
Unpopular opinion: Beta readers are not always helpful.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Beta readers are not always helpful."
I believe self-publishing is as respectable as traditional publishing.
💡 Example: "I believe self-publishing is as respectable as traditional publishing."
Hot take: Writing in multiple genres is better than specializing.
💡 Example: "Hot take: Writing in multiple genres is better than specializing."
I think writing with AI tools is still creative. What do you think?
💡 Example: "I think writing with AI tools is still creative. What do you think?"
Unpopular opinion: Writing contests are mostly luck.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Writing contests are mostly luck."
I believe writing every day is not realistic for most people.
💡 Example: "I believe writing every day is not realistic for most people."
Does anyone else think rejection letters can be motivating?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else think rejection letters can be motivating?"
Hot take: Description-heavy prose slows down good stories.
💡 Example: "Hot take: Description-heavy prose slows down good stories."
Unpopular opinion: Writing endings is easier than starting a story.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Writing endings is easier than starting a story."
I think writing in first person limits storytelling. Agree?
💡 Example: "I think writing in first person limits storytelling. Agree?"
Unpopular opinion: You don't have to write what you know.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: You don't have to write what you know."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste the prompt into your community platform. Adjust the specifics to fit current discussions or seasonal themes. After posting, actively encourage members to explain their thinking and remind everyone to remain respectful. Be ready to moderate closely if debates become heated, and consider following up with summary posts that highlight valuable insights shared.
For all platforms, schedule Unpopular Opinion posts during peak activity times for maximum visibility. Use polls or threaded replies if available to organize responses. Pin or highlight the post for a period to encourage ongoing participation. Always monitor closely for tone and intervene early if discussions become disrespectful.
Unpopular Opinion posts are a great way to open discussions on divisive topics like the use of passive voice or 'show, don't tell.' Frame your prompt around a bold statement, such as 'Adverbs strengthen prose' or 'Passive voice is unfairly maligned.' Encourage members to share specific examples from their own writing or published works, and remind them to critique the technique, not the writer. This approach fosters healthy debate and deeper understanding of nuanced writing concepts.
When Unpopular Opinion posts revolve around topics like plotting (outlining) versus pantsing (writing by the seat of your pants), discussions can get passionate. Set clear guidelines before posting, encouraging respectful disagreement and evidence-based opinions. As a moderator, actively monitor threads, stepping in to de-escalate if arguments become personal. Highlight insightful contributions and invite users to share how each method has affected their writing process, keeping the focus on shared learning.
Absolutely! Challenging genre conventions is highly engaging for writers. Posts questioning the necessity of a happily-ever-after in romance, or the value of invented languages in fantasy, can spark lively, constructive debates. These prompts encourage writers to reflect on genre expectations, their own creative choices, and how conventions evolve. Be sure to ask for examples and personal experiences to deepen the discussion.
When crafting Unpopular Opinion posts about writing tools, focus the prompt on how specific features impact the writing process, rather than on the brands themselves. For example, post statements like 'Outlining in Scrivener is overrated' or 'Google Docs isn't suitable for novel drafts.' Encourage members to discuss workflow, collaboration, and productivity rather than loyalty to a brand. Remind participants to share their workflow tips and specific frustrations or benefits.
Yes, challenging widespread writing advice—such as 'write every day' or 'avoid clichés at all costs'—is a perfect use of Unpopular Opinion posts. To make these posts accessible, frame the conversation around the diversity of writing routines and growth stages. Encourage members to share alternative strategies and personal journeys. Affirm that everyone's writing process is valid, and actively invite newer writers to share their perspective.
Sensitive industry topics—such as attitudes toward self-publishing versus traditional publishing—can provoke strong emotions. Before posting, remind members to engage respectfully and avoid gatekeeping. Moderate closely to prevent dismissive or derogatory responses. Encourage members to share experiences, discuss industry trends, and cite resources. Use these posts as opportunities to educate and broaden understanding of the publishing landscape.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks