Finding it hard to get your stock trading community talking? This or That prompts are the perfect icebreaker, making it easy for everyone to jump in. Use these templates to spark fun, fast engagement and connect your members with zero stress.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That questions work because they lower the barrier to participation. With only two simple options, members do not feel pressured to craft long or complex answers. This format is playful, easy to answer on the go, and quickly generates replies that build momentum.
In stock trading communities, these prompts give members a chance to share preferences and opinions without debating strategy or performance. The lighthearted tone encourages even quieter members to join in, creating a more active and connected group. Over time, this builds trust and camaraderie, making your community feel more like home.
Day trading or swing trading - which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Day trading or swing trading - which do you prefer? I like the quick pace of day trading!"
Stocks or ETFs - what is your go-to?
💡 Example: "Stocks or ETFs - what is your go-to? I stick with ETFs for diversification."
Buying the dip or riding the trend - which strategy do you lean toward?
💡 Example: "Buying the dip or riding the trend - which strategy do you lean toward? I love catching the dip."
Morning trading sessions or afternoon trades - when are you most active?
💡 Example: "Morning trading sessions or afternoon trades - when are you most active? Mornings for me."
Blue chip stocks or penny stocks - which excites you more?
💡 Example: "Blue chip stocks or penny stocks - which excites you more? Penny stocks are thrilling!"
Manual trading or automated trading - what is your preference?
💡 Example: "Manual trading or automated trading - what is your preference? I like to be hands-on."
Fundamental analysis or technical analysis - which do you trust more?
💡 Example: "Fundamental analysis or technical analysis - which do you trust more? Technicals all the way."
Short-term gains or long-term growth - what is your investing style?
💡 Example: "Short-term gains or long-term growth - what is your investing style? I focus on long-term growth."
Limit orders or market orders - which do you use more often?
💡 Example: "Limit orders or market orders - which do you use more often? Limit orders for precision."
Bull markets or bear markets - which one tests your skills more?
💡 Example: "Bull markets or bear markets - which one tests your skills more? Bear markets are tough."
Watching charts or reading news - what is your primary source for trade ideas?
💡 Example: "Watching charts or reading news - what is your primary source for trade ideas? Charts for me."
Apple or Tesla - which stock would you pick for your portfolio?
💡 Example: "Apple or Tesla - which stock would you pick for your portfolio? Tesla all day."
Paper trading or jumping right in - how did you start?
💡 Example: "Paper trading or jumping right in - how did you start? I paper traded first."
Trading solo or with a group - what is your style?
💡 Example: "Trading solo or with a group - what is your style? I prefer solo."
Pre-market or after-hours trading - which do you like better?
💡 Example: "Pre-market or after-hours trading - which do you like better? After-hours for me."
Tech stocks or healthcare stocks - which sector interests you more?
💡 Example: "Tech stocks or healthcare stocks - which sector interests you more? Tech all the way."
Setting stop losses or letting profits run - which is harder for you?
💡 Example: "Setting stop losses or letting profits run - which is harder for you? Letting profits run!"
Trading from your phone or computer - what is your go-to device?
💡 Example: "Trading from your phone or computer - what is your go-to device? I use my computer."
Dividends or capital gains - what motivates you more?
💡 Example: "Dividends or capital gains - what motivates you more? Capital gains for me."
Researching before market open or after close - when do you prep?
💡 Example: "Researching before market open or after close - when do you prep? Before open."
Risk taker or risk averse - how would you describe yourself?
💡 Example: "Risk taker or risk averse - how would you describe yourself? I am a bit of both."
Following expert picks or doing your own research - what is your approach?
💡 Example: "Following expert picks or doing your own research - what is your approach? Own research."
Watching YouTube tutorials or reading books - how do you learn about trading?
💡 Example: "Watching YouTube tutorials or reading books - how do you learn about trading? YouTube for me."
Trading US markets or international markets - which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Trading US markets or international markets - which do you prefer? US markets."
Early bird trader or night owl - when are you most active?
💡 Example: "Early bird trader or night owl - when are you most active? Night owl here."
Small wins often or big wins rarely - what feels better?
💡 Example: "Small wins often or big wins rarely - what feels better? Small wins add up!"
Watching candlestick patterns or using indicators - which do you rely on more?
💡 Example: "Watching candlestick patterns or using indicators - which do you rely on more? Indicators!"
Learning from wins or learning from losses - which teaches you more?
💡 Example: "Learning from wins or learning from losses - which teaches you more? Losses for sure."
Following the crowd or going against the grain - which fits you?
💡 Example: "Following the crowd or going against the grain - which fits you? I am a contrarian."
Scaling in or all in at once - how do you enter positions?
💡 Example: "Scaling in or all in at once - how do you enter positions? I scale in."
Trading for fun or trading for profit - what motivates you?
💡 Example: "Trading for fun or trading for profit - what motivates you? Profit motivates me."
Using a watchlist or spontaneous picks - what is your style?
💡 Example: "Using a watchlist or spontaneous picks - what is your style? Watchlist all the way."
Earnings season or IPO launches - which do you look forward to more?
💡 Example: "Earnings season or IPO launches - which do you look forward to more? IPO launches."
Learning by doing or learning by observing - what works for you?
💡 Example: "Learning by doing or learning by observing - what works for you? Doing is best."
Using spreadsheets or trading apps - how do you track your trades?
💡 Example: "Using spreadsheets or trading apps - how do you track your trades? I use apps."
Following your gut or sticking to your plan - what wins in the heat of the moment?
💡 Example: "Following your gut or sticking to your plan - what wins in the heat of the moment? My plan!"
Reacting quickly or waiting patiently - which is your trading superpower?
💡 Example: "Reacting quickly or waiting patiently - which is your trading superpower? Patience is key."
Reading financial reports or using stock screeners - your research tool of choice?
💡 Example: "Reading financial reports or using stock screeners - your research tool of choice? Screeners for me."
Trading with coffee or tea by your side - what is fueling your trades today?
💡 Example: "Trading with coffee or tea by your side - what is fueling your trades today? Coffee all the way."
Big name brokers or smaller platforms - where do you trade?
💡 Example: "Big name brokers or smaller platforms - where do you trade? I use a big broker."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste a prompt into your post or chat. Add a quick intro to set the mood, or just let the question stand on its own. Rotate different templates to keep things fresh, and respond to answers to keep conversations going. Use them during slow periods or as a daily feature to maintain steady engagement.
For all platforms, keep questions concise and mobile-friendly. Use polls if available, or encourage replies in comments or chat. Pin popular prompts and tag active members to draw more participation. Adjust posting times to match your community's peak activity.
Focus on common forks in decision-making that traders encounter, such as choosing between analysis methods, risk levels, or investment vehicles. For maximum engagement, use scenarios like 'day trading vs. swing trading' or 'growth stocks vs. dividend stocks,' so members can share their personal strategies and spark discussions based on their trading experiences.
Absolutely. Segmenting your 'This or That' prompts allows newer traders to discuss accessible topics like 'index funds vs. sector ETFs,' while advanced members can engage with nuanced choices such as 'selling covered calls vs. cash-secured puts.' This targeted approach encourages participation across all expertise levels.
Phrase your prompts as open-ended preferences rather than recommendations, and avoid naming specific securities or urging particular trades. Instead of 'Buy Apple or Tesla?', use 'Blue-chip stocks vs. high-growth tech stocks?' and include a disclaimer reminding members that discussions are for sharing opinions, not offering investment advice.
Use scenarios that highlight contrasting trading environments, such as 'pre-market trading vs. regular session,' or 'reacting to earnings reports before vs. after the bell.' Encourage members to explain their reasoning and share tips about liquidity, volatility, and order execution during these periods to deepen discussion.
Yes, 'This or That' prompts are excellent for introducing complex topics in a relatable way. For example, ask 'Margin trading vs. cash accounts?' or 'Options trading vs. futures trading?' Follow up with brief context or definitions to help demystify the concepts and promote knowledge-sharing without overwhelming less experienced members.
Set clear community guidelines that all perspectives are valid and encourage respectful dialogue. Frame questions to invite sharing of personal experiences rather than arguments—e.g., 'Which approach fits your trading style: buy and hold or active day trading?' Remind members to explain their reasoning and avoid disparaging others’ strategies.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks