Struggling to spark conversation in your sports community? Hypothetical scenario posts invite members to imagine, debate, and share their takes on playful or thought-provoking 'what ifs.' Use these templates to fuel creativity and get even the quietest fans talking.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios tap into our natural curiosity and love for playful debate. By inviting members to explore 'what if' situations, you create a safe space for creativity and self-expression, allowing everyone to participate without needing expert knowledge. These prompts also encourage storytelling, nostalgia, and even a bit of friendly rivalry, all of which deepen connections among members.
This content type works especially well in sports communities, where fans enjoy speculating about game-changing moments, legendary athletes, or alternate outcomes. It lowers barriers for participation, since responses are opinion-based, and helps surface hidden expertise and unique perspectives from every level of fan.
If you could add one new rule to your favorite sport, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could add one new rule to basketball, what would it be?"
Imagine your team makes the championship with you as coach. What is your first strategy?
💡 Example: "Imagine your team makes the World Cup with you as coach. What is your first strategy?"
What if you could switch two athletes from different sports for a season? Who would you pick?
💡 Example: "What if you could switch LeBron James and Lionel Messi for a season? Who would you pick?"
If your favorite team could sign any past legend, who would it be and why?
💡 Example: "If your favorite team could sign Michael Jordan, who would it be and why?"
Suppose you could only watch one sport for the next year. Which would you choose?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could only watch one sport for the next year. Which would you choose?"
If you could attend any historic game live, which one would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you could attend any historic game live, which one would you pick?"
Imagine a world where every sport is played in the snow. How does your favorite sport change?
💡 Example: "Imagine a world where every sport is played in the snow. How does football change?"
If your favorite player could master any other sport overnight, which would it be?
💡 Example: "If your favorite player could master any other sport overnight, which would it be?"
What if you could create a dream team with any athletes from history?
💡 Example: "What if you could create a dream team with any athletes from history?"
Suppose your least favorite rule was removed from the game. How would it change?
💡 Example: "Suppose offsides was removed from soccer. How would it change?"
Imagine your city hosts the next big sports event. What would you do as mayor?
💡 Example: "Imagine your city hosts the Olympics. What would you do as mayor?"
If you could replay any game with a different outcome, which would you choose?
💡 Example: "If you could replay the 2016 NBA Finals with a different outcome, which would you choose?"
What if you could invent a new Olympic sport? What would it be?
💡 Example: "What if you could invent a new Olympic sport? What would it be?"
Suppose every game ended in a tie. How would that change your feelings about sports?
💡 Example: "Suppose every football game ended in a tie. How would you feel?"
If you could give any athlete a superpower for one game, who and what would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you could give Serena Williams the power to fly for one match, would you?"
Imagine you are the referee for a big game. What is your toughest call?
💡 Example: "Imagine you are the referee for the World Series. What is your toughest call?"
What if your favorite team switched uniforms with their biggest rivals for a season?
💡 Example: "What if your favorite team switched uniforms with their biggest rivals for a season?"
Suppose every goal or point counted for double. Which game would be most exciting?
💡 Example: "Suppose every goal or point counted for double. Which sport would be most exciting?"
If you could bring back any retired athlete for one more season, who would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could bring back Kobe Bryant for one more season, who would it be?"
Imagine a world where everyone had to play sports left-handed. Who would surprise us?
💡 Example: "Imagine a world where everyone had to play sports left-handed. Who would surprise us?"
What if halftime shows were replaced with fan competitions?
💡 Example: "What if halftime shows were replaced with fan competitions?"
Suppose you could create a new mascot for your team. What would it be?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could create a new mascot for your team. What would it be?"
If every game was played outdoors, which sport would be hardest to adapt?
💡 Example: "If every game was played outdoors, which sport would be hardest to adapt?"
Imagine athletes could only use public transport to get to games. How would this affect play?
💡 Example: "Imagine athletes could only use public transport to get to games. How would this affect play?"
What if every team had to draft at least one fan to play each game?
💡 Example: "What if every team had to draft at least one fan to play each game?"
Suppose your favorite sport was suddenly played without a ball or puck. What changes?
💡 Example: "Suppose your favorite sport was suddenly played without a ball or puck. What changes?"
If you could choose any stadium in the world to visit, where would you go first?
💡 Example: "If you could choose any stadium in the world to visit, where would you go first?"
Imagine every player had to wear costumes for a special game. What theme would you pick?
💡 Example: "Imagine every player had to wear costumes for a special game. What theme would you pick?"
What if there was a four-point shot in basketball? How would teams change their tactics?
💡 Example: "What if there was a four-point shot in basketball? How would teams change their tactics?"
Suppose your favorite game was played underwater. How would it look?
💡 Example: "Suppose your favorite game was played underwater. How would it look?"
If every game had to be played in silence, what would be the hardest part?
💡 Example: "If every game had to be played in silence, what would be the hardest part?"
Imagine you could swap the commentators for any celebrities. Who would you pick?
💡 Example: "Imagine you could swap the commentators for any celebrities. Who would you pick?"
What if every athlete could instantly heal from injuries? How would sports change?
💡 Example: "What if every athlete could instantly heal from injuries? How would sports change?"
Suppose every fan vote counted toward the score. How would games feel?
💡 Example: "Suppose every fan vote counted toward the score. How would games feel?"
If you could merge two sports into a new one, which would you combine?
💡 Example: "If you could merge basketball and soccer into a new one, which would you combine?"
Imagine your favorite athlete had to play their sport backward for one game. What happens?
💡 Example: "Imagine your favorite athlete had to play their sport backward for one game. What happens?"
What if every team had to play with only local players for a season?
💡 Example: "What if every team had to play with only local players for a season?"
Suppose you could give the MVP trophy to any unsung hero. Who would get it?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could give the MVP trophy to any unsung hero. Who would get it?"
If all sports were played at night, which would be the most fun to watch?
💡 Example: "If all sports were played at night, which would be the most fun to watch?"
Imagine your team had to play in a different country every week. How would they do?
💡 Example: "Imagine your team had to play in a different country every week. How would they do?"
What if the fans could pick the starting lineup for one game?
💡 Example: "What if the fans could pick the starting lineup for one game?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste one into your community post or story. Adjust the scenario to fit current events, trending topics, or your community's favorite sports. Encourage members to reply in the comments, share their stories, or even create polls based on the most popular answers. Mix up the tone between playful and thoughtful prompts to keep things fresh and engaging.
On all platforms, use engaging visuals like player photos or action shots to accompany your scenario. Pin or feature the best answers to inspire participation. If available, use polls or story features to let members vote on the most popular responses.
To engage both types of sports fans, alternate your hypothetical scenarios to cover a range of sports contexts. For example, pose situations like 'If you could add one player from any era to your favorite team, who would it be?' for team sports, and 'If you could face any tennis legend in a Grand Slam final, who would you choose and why?' for individual sports. This ensures representation and sparks discussion across your diverse membership.
Frame your hypothetical prompts to focus on learning and strategy rather than blame. For example: 'If you were the VAR official during a critical match moment, how would you handle a close offside call?' Encourage members to explain their reasoning and reference official rules, fostering respectful debate and education rather than heated disputes.
Use scenarios that mirror real high-pressure moments, such as: 'It's the final inning and bases are loaded—you're up to bat. What's your mindset and strategy?' This encourages athletes to share mental preparation techniques, coping strategies, and real experiences, which benefits the wider community by normalizing pressure and teaching resilience.
Yes, referencing well-known moments—such as 'What if Michael Jordan had never returned to the NBA?'—can ignite rich discussions about alternate histories, team dynamics, and player legacies. Provide context and invite members to support their opinions with stats or personal memories, which deepens engagement and sports literacy.
Design scenarios that align with draft strategy and roster management, like: 'If you had the first pick in your fantasy football draft and all players were healthy, who would you choose?' This taps into fantasy-specific knowledge and debates, driving participation among members who are passionate about managing virtual teams.
Set clear community guidelines in advance and encourage members to back their points with stats and respectful analysis rather than personal attacks. You could also turn competitive banter into friendly challenges, such as polls or debates with structured arguments, to channel rivalry into constructive and fun engagement.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks