Running out of ways to get your community talking? Would You Rather posts are a fun, creative solution that spark lively discussions and draw members in. Use these ready-made templates to transform quiet feeds into buzzing hubs of imaginative conversation.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions tap into our natural curiosity and love for comparing options. By presenting two intriguing choices, these prompts invite members to imagine scenarios, reflect on their preferences, and reveal their personalities. This type of content lowers barriers to participation, making it easy for everyone to join in whether they are new or seasoned members.
In a social media marketing community, Would You Rather posts are especially effective because they connect professional interests with playful hypotheticals. They foster connection, highlight industry trends, and allow marketers to share insights or opinions in a low-pressure, engaging way. The result is an increase in both engagement and a sense of community belonging.
Would you rather grow your Instagram followers by 10x overnight or double your engagement rate instantly?
💡 Example: "I'd rather double my engagement rate instantly because engaged followers are more valuable."
Would you rather manage a viral TikTok account or a respected LinkedIn page for a year?
💡 Example: "I would go with TikTok for the creative challenges."
Would you rather create one perfect post per week or post five decent ones each week?
💡 Example: "One perfect post per week would save me time but I like having frequent content."
Would you rather have unlimited budget for ads or unlimited access to influencers?
💡 Example: "Unlimited access to influencers could be more authentic for our brand."
Would you rather brainstorm social campaigns alone or always work with a team?
💡 Example: "I prefer teamwork for more ideas."
Would you rather automate all your posting or write every post manually?
💡 Example: "Automation saves time but manual posts feel more personal."
Would you rather go viral for a meme or for a thought leadership article?
💡 Example: "Thought leadership for sure - I want to be taken seriously."
Would you rather handle a brand crisis on Twitter or Facebook?
💡 Example: "Twitter - it's faster but also more intense."
Would you rather write captions or design graphics all day?
💡 Example: "I enjoy writing captions more than designing."
Would you rather test new features first or wait for proven results?
💡 Example: "I'm a tester - I love trying new features early."
Would you rather have every post scheduled perfectly or be able to respond instantly to every comment?
💡 Example: "I'd choose instant responses for better community building."
Would you rather triple your YouTube subscribers or Facebook group members?
💡 Example: "YouTube subscribers - I focus on video."
Would you rather create a viral hashtag or a trending challenge?
💡 Example: "A trending challenge is more interactive."
Would you rather only use stories or only use reels for your brand?
💡 Example: "Stories for daily updates."
Would you rather work with micro-influencers or a single mega-influencer?
💡 Example: "Micro-influencers feel more authentic."
Would you rather launch a product on Instagram live or Facebook live?
💡 Example: "Instagram live for a younger audience."
Would you rather master SEO for YouTube or Facebook Ads targeting?
💡 Example: "YouTube SEO - videos have a long shelf life."
Would you rather have every post go viral or build a loyal niche audience?
💡 Example: "Loyal niche audience is better for long-term growth."
Would you rather only use videos or only use carousels for content?
💡 Example: "Video is more engaging for my audience."
Would you rather have unlimited creative tools or unlimited analytics data?
💡 Example: "Unlimited analytics for better decision-making."
Would you rather run a month-long Instagram challenge or a 24-hour flash contest?
💡 Example: "Month-long challenge for deeper engagement."
Would you rather schedule posts a month in advance or create them day by day?
💡 Example: "I like planning ahead with monthly schedules."
Would you rather collaborate with a dream brand or your favorite creator?
💡 Example: "Favorite creator - more aligned values."
Would you rather go live with an expert or host an AMA with your community?
💡 Example: "AMA with the community to boost interaction."
Would you rather focus on B2B content or B2C campaigns?
💡 Example: "B2B content is my specialty."
Would you rather analyze data or brainstorm creative campaigns all day?
💡 Example: "I love brainstorming creative ideas."
Would you rather get instant feedback on every post or see your results after a month?
💡 Example: "Instant feedback helps me adapt quickly."
Would you rather manage social for a startup or a global brand?
💡 Example: "Startup - more room for creativity."
Would you rather never use hashtags again or never use emojis again?
💡 Example: "I could live without emojis."
Would you rather have your posts shared by an industry leader or by a celebrity?
💡 Example: "Industry leader for more targeted reach."
Would you rather build an audience on a new platform or double your size on your current one?
💡 Example: "Double my current audience for deeper relationships."
Would you rather have every post feature video or every post feature user-generated content?
💡 Example: "User-generated content builds trust."
Would you rather be known for viral campaigns or for consistent branding?
💡 Example: "Consistent branding is more sustainable."
Would you rather always have trending content or always have evergreen content?
💡 Example: "Evergreen content for the long run."
Would you rather have your content featured on the explore page or top search results?
💡 Example: "Top search results drive more steady traffic."
Would you rather spend your budget on paid ads or influencer partnerships?
💡 Example: "Influencer partnerships feel more authentic."
Would you rather manage a crisis for a brand you love or launch a new campaign for a brand you dislike?
💡 Example: "I'd manage a crisis for a brand I love."
Would you rather receive unlimited creative briefs or unlimited campaign data?
💡 Example: "Unlimited briefs spark more ideas."
Would you rather have to post only in GIFs or only in polls for a week?
💡 Example: "GIFs would make the feed funnier."
Would you rather only use organic reach or only use paid promotions?
💡 Example: "Organic reach builds real loyalty."
Would you rather never schedule posts again or never reply to comments again?
💡 Example: "I'd give up scheduling before I give up community replies."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your preferred question into your community platform. Add a short intro if you wish, or jump right into the prompt. Encourage members to not only pick a side, but also share why they made their choice. Consider using images, polls, or stories to boost visibility. Rotate these questions regularly to keep your discussions fresh and your members looking forward to each new post.
For all platforms, keep Would You Rather posts concise and visually appealing. Use polls where available to make participation easy, and follow up with replies or reactions to keep the conversation going. Adapt the format to fit stories, feeds, or group discussions as needed.
Both approaches can spark engagement, but comparing tools (e.g., Hootsuite vs Buffer) encourages marketers to share real-world experiences, while strategy-based prompts (organic vs paid reach) invite deeper discussions on campaign outcomes. For a professional SMM group, mixing both keeps content fresh and relevant to current industry trends.
Absolutely! Would You Rather questions are excellent for understanding peer preferences in content formats (e.g., Reels vs Carousels, Stories vs Static Posts). This helps identify current trends and pain points among marketers, which can inform both group discussions and your own content planning.
To prevent platform bias, ensure your questions highlight the unique strengths of each platform or feature. Encourage members to share why they prefer one over the other based on campaign goals, audience engagement, or analytics. This fosters a balanced, knowledge-sharing environment.
Yes! Comparing reactions to different platform algorithm changes via Would You Rather posts can stimulate valuable conversation. Marketers can exchange adaptation strategies, identify challenges, and learn from each other’s experiences navigating shifting engagement metrics.
Frame your Would You Rather prompts around workflow scenarios (e.g., 'Would you rather automate reporting with Google Data Studio or manually track in Excel?'). This encourages practical discussion and peer learning, while group rules about direct promotions help maintain focus on unbiased experience sharing.
Yes! Incorporating current trends (e.g., 'Would you rather launch a viral hashtag challenge or partner with a micro-influencer?') makes prompts highly relevant and increases participation. Just ensure the scenarios are tailored to professional marketers, focusing on measurable outcomes and campaign insights.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks