Having trouble sparking lively conversations in your skincare community? Would You Rather questions are a playful way to get members thinking creatively about skincare routines and preferences. Use these ready-made templates to encourage fun, imaginative discussions that everyone will want to join.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions tap into the psychology of choice, making members pause to compare, reflect, and share their personal opinions. By presenting two intriguing skincare scenarios, you invite everyone to weigh in, no matter their expertise or confidence level. This format lowers barriers to participation and gives even quiet members an easy way to engage.
The playful, imaginative nature of these questions means discussions stay lighthearted and fun while still offering valuable insights into member preferences. When members explain their reasoning, it sparks even more conversation and helps build a sense of community around shared skincare interests.
Would you rather never use moisturizer again or never use sunscreen again? Tell us why!
💡 Example: "I would rather never use moisturizer again because sunscreen is a must for me!"
Would you rather have glowing skin forever but always have to use sheet masks, or clear skin forever but never use masks?
💡 Example: "Clear skin forever but no masks for me!"
Would you rather only use cleansers or only use serums in your routine?
💡 Example: "I would choose serums, because I love the extra benefits."
Would you rather try a mystery skincare product each month or stick to your trusted favorites forever?
💡 Example: "Mystery products! I love experimenting."
Would you rather have a 10-step skincare routine or keep it to only 2 steps?
💡 Example: "2 steps for sure, I like to keep it easy."
Would you rather only use fragrance-free products or only use naturally scented ones?
💡 Example: "Fragrance-free is best for my sensitive skin."
Would you rather always have to double cleanse or never be able to double cleanse again?
💡 Example: "Always double cleanse! My skin feels best that way."
Would you rather use only drugstore skincare or only luxury brands for life?
💡 Example: "Drugstore brands! There are so many good finds."
Would you rather never exfoliate again or never use face masks again?
💡 Example: "Never use face masks again, I need exfoliation!"
Would you rather wake up with perfect skin every day or have any skincare product you want for free?
💡 Example: "Perfect skin, hands down!"
Would you rather get expert facials monthly or have a never-ending supply of your favorite serum?
💡 Example: "Never-ending serum sounds amazing."
Would you rather use only one product for your skin or switch products every week?
💡 Example: "Switching products would be fun for me."
Would you rather have amazing skin but never try new products, or always test new launches with mixed results?
💡 Example: "Amazing skin forever, even without new products."
Would you rather use a cold roller every morning or a jade roller every night?
💡 Example: "Jade roller at night, so relaxing."
Would you rather never use toner again or never use moisturizer again?
💡 Example: "I could skip toner, but not moisturizer!"
Would you rather have SPF in every skincare product or never have to reapply sunscreen?
💡 Example: "Never having to reapply would be a dream."
Would you rather get a pro skin analysis or a full set of your favorite skincare for free?
💡 Example: "Full set of my favorites please."
Would you rather only use K-beauty products or only French pharmacy skincare?
💡 Example: "K-beauty all the way!"
Would you rather never get a pimple again or never experience dry skin again?
💡 Example: "No more pimples for me!"
Would you rather have your skincare routine done for you every day or get unlimited advice from a top dermatologist?
💡 Example: "Advice from a derm would be so helpful."
Would you rather use only products with three or fewer ingredients, or only products with ten or more?
💡 Example: "Three or fewer, I like simple formulas."
Would you rather always have to do your skincare routine in less than five minutes or take at least thirty minutes each time?
💡 Example: "Five minutes or less for me!"
Would you rather have a personal skincare fridge or a personal skincare assistant?
💡 Example: "Skincare assistant, please!"
Would you rather do a skincare routine with friends or relax and do it solo?
💡 Example: "Solo time is my self-care moment."
Would you rather have baby-smooth skin but always look a bit shiny, or matte skin but always feel a little dry?
💡 Example: "A little shine is fine if my skin is smooth."
Would you rather try only new launches for a year or stick with your current routine forever?
💡 Example: "I would love to try all the new stuff!"
Would you rather have endless supply of your favorite moisturizer or your favorite cleanser?
💡 Example: "Moisturizer for me!"
Would you rather only use skincare you make yourself or only what others recommend?
💡 Example: "I'll trust the community's recommendations."
Would you rather use only facial oils or only gels forever?
💡 Example: "Facial oils work best for me."
Would you rather skip your morning routine or your night routine for a week?
💡 Example: "I'd skip my morning routine."
Would you rather use only products in jars or only in pumps?
💡 Example: "Pumps for sure, much easier to use."
Would you rather win a year of professional facials or a custom skincare routine from an expert?
💡 Example: "Custom routine sounds perfect."
Would you rather have products that work instantly but smell bad, or take a month to work but smell amazing?
💡 Example: "I'll take instant results, even with a bad smell!"
Would you rather always have to apply skincare with your hands or only use tools?
💡 Example: "Hands are more convenient for me."
Would you rather have perfect skin in winter or in summer?
💡 Example: "Summer is when I need perfect skin the most."
Would you rather use only cruelty-free products or only vegan products?
💡 Example: "Cruelty-free is my priority."
Would you rather invest in skincare or makeup if you could only choose one?
💡 Example: "Skincare always comes first for me."
Would you rather have dewy skin all year or matte skin all year?
💡 Example: "Dewy skin is my favorite look."
Would you rather use a product that smells like coffee or one that smells like citrus?
💡 Example: "Citrus scents are so refreshing."
Would you rather have your favorite brand sponsor your skincare for life or launch your own skincare line?
💡 Example: "Launching my own line would be amazing!"
Choose a template that fits your community vibe and current topics. Post it as a stand-alone thread, story, or in your chat, inviting members to vote or explain their choice. Encourage replies by tagging members or following up with your own answer. Rotate question types and frequency to keep engagement fresh and avoid repetition.
On all platforms, use engaging visuals or emojis to make your Would You Rather questions stand out. Pin or highlight posts for more visibility. Use polls where available, but always invite comments for richer discussion.
To engage your community with ingredient-focused Would You Rather posts, select popular actives that are often compared in skincare routines. For example, contrasting 'retinol vs. vitamin C' taps into conversations about anti-aging versus brightening. Provide educational context in the post captions to spark informed discussions and help members share their experiences with these ingredients.
Use Would You Rather questions to safely open conversations about debated practices like double cleansing. Frame the post neutrally and invite members to share personal results or trusted research. This method encourages respectful exchange of opinions and real-world skincare experiences, while keeping the focus on learning rather than arguing.
Tailor your questions to acknowledge skin type diversity. For example, ask: 'Would you rather use a gel moisturizer (great for oily skin) or a cream moisturizer (ideal for dry skin)?' Including brief skin type guidance in the question helps members relate to the topic and fosters more inclusive discussions.
Absolutely! Use these templates to spark conversation about adapting routines for different climates and seasons. Asking members if they prefer heavier or lighter formulas during specific times of year generates practical tips and helps the community share what works for their skin in changing conditions.
When discussing advanced treatments, briefly explain each option in your post and encourage members to share results, concerns, or questions. Remind the community to consult professionals for personalized advice. This approach educates newer skincare enthusiasts without alienating them or promoting unsafe DIY attempts.
Frame questions that acknowledge real struggles, e.g., 'Would you rather instantly clear up acne or permanently fade hyperpigmentation?' Pair the question with a prompt for members to share their coping strategies, favorite products, or emotional experiences. This deepens conversations beyond product preferences and fosters genuine peer support.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks