42 Hypothetical Scenario Posts That Work for Shopify Communities

Running out of ways to spark creative conversations in your Shopify community? Hypothetical scenario templates are your secret weapon for getting members to imagine, brainstorm, and share in new ways. Explore these ready-to-use prompts to drive playful, open-ended engagement.

Shopify 42 Templates

Generate Unlimited Templates with AI

Get personalized templates for your community in seconds

Start Free Trial →

Why This Works

Hypothetical scenarios encourage members to think beyond their daily routines and imagine new possibilities. This taps into intrinsic motivation and curiosity, making participation feel fun and low-pressure. By asking 'what if' questions, you lower barriers to entry, as there are no wrong answers and everyone can contribute without fear of judgment.

For Shopify communities, these scenarios can help members envision growth, overcome challenges, and consider creative solutions for their stores. They foster a collaborative learning environment, where members share ideas, learn from each other's perspectives, and build stronger connections. This kind of imaginative engagement keeps your community active, supportive, and innovative.

42 Ready-to-Use Templates

1

If you could add any feature to your Shopify store overnight, what would it be and why?

💡 Example: "If you could add any feature to your Shopify store overnight, what would it be and why? Share your dream upgrade!"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #innovation #shopify #imagination
2

Imagine Shopify gives you a $10,000 grant to improve your store. How do you spend it?

💡 Example: "Imagine Shopify gives you a $10,000 grant to improve your store. How do you spend it? Let us know your plan!"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #budget #strategy #growth
3

What would you do if your store suddenly went viral overnight?

💡 Example: "What would you do if your store suddenly went viral overnight? How would you handle the rush?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #growth #challenge #planning
4

If you could collaborate with any brand on Shopify, which would you choose and why?

💡 Example: "If you could collaborate with any brand on Shopify, which would you choose and why? Dream big!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #collaboration #networking #brand
5

Suppose Shopify offered free access to one premium app forever. Which would you pick?

💡 Example: "Suppose Shopify offered free access to one premium app forever. Which would you pick and how would it help?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #apps #wishlist #shopify
6

If you had to run your Shopify business using only your phone for a month, how would you adapt?

💡 Example: "If you had to run your Shopify business using only your phone for a month, what changes would you make?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #mobile #challenge #adaptation
7

Imagine your best-selling product is suddenly discontinued. What is your backup plan?

💡 Example: "Imagine your best-selling product is suddenly discontinued. How would you pivot?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #resilience #product #planning
8

If you could automate any one task in Shopify, which would it be?

💡 Example: "If you could automate any one task in Shopify, which would it be? I would automate order fulfillment!"

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #automation #efficiency
9

Suppose you wake up and your store has doubled its traffic. What is the first thing you check?

💡 Example: "Suppose you wake up and your store has doubled its traffic. What is the first thing you check and why?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #traffic #analytics #reaction
10

What would you do if your Shopify store was featured on national TV?

💡 Example: "What would you do if your Shopify store was featured on national TV? How would you prepare?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #publicity #growth #media
11

Imagine all shipping becomes free for a week. How would you promote your store?

💡 Example: "Imagine all shipping becomes free for a week. What would you do to get the word out?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #shipping #promotion #marketing
12

If you could hire any expert for your Shopify store, what skill would you look for?

💡 Example: "If you could hire any expert for your Shopify store, what skill would you look for? I would hire a marketing guru."

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #team #skills #hiring
13

Suppose a competitor copies your entire store. How do you stand out?

💡 Example: "Suppose a competitor copies your entire store. How do you stand out? Share your ideas!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #competition #differentiation #strategy
14

If you could change one thing about Shopify's admin dashboard, what would it be?

💡 Example: "If you could change one thing about Shopify's admin dashboard, what would it be? I wish for better analytics."

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #feedback #shopify #features
15

Imagine your Shopify store could talk. What advice would it give you?

💡 Example: "Imagine your Shopify store could talk. What advice would it give you? Let us know!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #fun #imagination #store
16

If all your customers left reviews, what would you hope they say?

💡 Example: "If all your customers left reviews, what would you hope they say? Share your wish!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #reviews #customer #feedback
17

Suppose you can only sell one product for the next year. Which do you choose and why?

💡 Example: "Suppose you can only sell one product for the next year. Which do you pick?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #focus #products #decision
18

If Shopify magically handled all your taxes, what would you do with the extra time?

💡 Example: "If Shopify magically handled all your taxes, what would you do with the extra time? I would build new products."

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #time #automation #taxes
19

Imagine a celebrity endorses your store. Who would you want and what product would they promote?

💡 Example: "Imagine a celebrity endorses your store. Who would you want and what would they promote?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #celebrities #marketing #dream
20

If you could only use Shopify themes or custom code, which would you pick and why?

💡 Example: "If you could only use Shopify themes or custom code, which would you pick and why? I love themes for simplicity."

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #themes #customization #development
21

Suppose Black Friday sales are canceled. How would you make up for the lost revenue?

💡 Example: "Suppose Black Friday sales are canceled. How would you make up for the lost revenue?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #sales #strategy #holidays
22

If you could give one piece of advice to new Shopify store owners, what would it be?

💡 Example: "If you could give one piece of advice to new Shopify store owners, what would it be? Share your wisdom!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Top #advice #community #beginners
23

Imagine your Shopify store's homepage is replaced with a meme for a day. What meme would you pick?

💡 Example: "Imagine your Shopify store's homepage is replaced with a meme for a day. What meme would you choose?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #fun #homepage #meme
24

Suppose Shopify adds a new social platform integration. Which platform would you want?

💡 Example: "Suppose Shopify adds a new social platform integration. Which platform would you want? TikTok integration would be awesome."

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #social #integration #wish
25

If your store mascot could come to life, what would they be like?

💡 Example: "If your store mascot could come to life, what would they be like? Describe their personality!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #imagination #branding #fun
26

Imagine you have to relaunch your Shopify store in a new country. Where would you go and why?

💡 Example: "Imagine you have to relaunch your Shopify store in a new country. Where would you go and why?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #expansion #international #strategy
27

Suppose your store's color scheme is switched randomly. How do you react?

💡 Example: "Suppose your store's color scheme is switched randomly. How do you react? I'd roll with it for a day!"

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #branding #design #fun
28

If Shopify could predict your next best-selling product, would you trust its advice?

💡 Example: "If Shopify could predict your next best-selling product, would you trust its advice? I think I would!"

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #AI #products #trust
29

Imagine you are invited to speak at a Shopify conference. What would your main topic be?

💡 Example: "Imagine you are invited to speak at a Shopify conference. What topic would you choose?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #public speaking #expertise #community
30

Suppose your Shopify store runs itself for a week. What surprises do you expect when you return?

💡 Example: "Suppose your Shopify store runs itself for a week. What surprises do you expect when you return?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #automation #fun #imagination
31

If you could only use three apps on your Shopify store, which ones would you keep?

💡 Example: "If you could only use three apps on your Shopify store, which ones would you keep and why?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #apps #must-have #tools
32

Imagine Shopify launches a virtual reality shopping experience. How would your store adapt?

💡 Example: "Imagine Shopify launches a virtual reality shopping experience. How would your store adapt?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #VR #future #adaptation
33

Suppose you must rebrand your Shopify store with a new name. What do you pick?

💡 Example: "Suppose you must rebrand your Shopify store with a new name. What do you pick?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #branding #naming #imagination
34

If Shopify offered you a free mentor for a month, what would you want to learn?

💡 Example: "If Shopify offered you a free mentor for a month, what would you want to learn?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #mentorship #learning #growth
35

Imagine your Shopify store is turned into a board game. What is the main objective?

💡 Example: "Imagine your Shopify store is turned into a board game. What is the main objective?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #fun #games #imagination
36

If you had to describe your Shopify store in one emoji, which would you pick?

💡 Example: "If you had to describe your Shopify store in one emoji, which would you pick? I would use the rocket emoji."

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #branding #emoji #fun
37

Suppose Shopify adds a new AI-powered assistant. What tasks would you want it to do?

💡 Example: "Suppose Shopify adds a new AI-powered assistant. What tasks would you want it to do?"

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #AI #automation #wishlist
38

Imagine your customers could vote on your next product. What would you put up for a vote?

💡 Example: "Imagine your customers could vote on your next product. What would you put up for a vote?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #customer #products #engagement
39

If you woke up and Shopify had merged with another e-commerce giant, what is your reaction?

💡 Example: "If you woke up and Shopify had merged with another e-commerce giant, what is your reaction? Who would you want it to merge with?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #industry #reaction #speculation
40

Suppose your store can only use black and white images for a month. How do you make it pop?

💡 Example: "Suppose your store can only use black and white images for a month. How do you make it pop? Share your creative ideas!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #design #photos #challenge
41

If you could time travel to your first Shopify sale, what would you do differently?

💡 Example: "If you could time travel to your first Shopify sale, what would you do differently? Share your insights!"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Top #reflection #learning #growth
42

Imagine Shopify creates a movie about your store. What is the title and genre?

💡 Example: "Imagine Shopify creates a movie about your store. What would the title and genre be?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #fun #storytelling #imagination

How to Use These Templates

Choose a template from the list and post it as a new discussion in your community or social channel. Encourage diverse responses by tagging a few members or offering a small reward for creative answers. Mix up serious and playful scenarios to maintain variety. Follow up with comments or polls based on the most popular replies to deepen the conversation.

Best Practices

  • Keep scenarios simple and focused on one idea.
  • Encourage all responses by emphasizing there are no right or wrong answers.
  • Rotate between fun and business-related scenarios for balance.
  • Follow up on creative responses to show appreciation.
  • Avoid sensitive or potentially controversial topics.

All Platforms Tips

On all platforms, use visuals or emojis to draw attention to your post. Pin the scenario for a day to maximize responses. Consider using polls or replies to highlight standout answers. Adapt the wording to fit the tone of your group, whether it is formal or casual.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are hypothetical scenario templates?

They are creative prompts that pose 'what if' questions, encouraging members to imagine and share ideas.

How can these templates boost engagement in my Shopify community?

They make it fun and easy for members to participate, lower pressure to be perfect, and spark fresh, creative conversations.

How often should I use hypothetical scenarios?

Once or twice a week is effective. Mix them in with other content to keep discussions lively and varied.

Can I use these scenarios on any platform?

Yes, these templates are designed for all platforms, including forums, Facebook groups, Slack, and Discord.

What is the best way to encourage responses to these posts?

Tag a few members, offer small rewards, or follow up with polls or comments to highlight creative responses.

Are these templates suitable for both new and experienced Shopify users?

Absolutely. The scenarios are open-ended and accessible, making them ideal for all experience levels.

Can I edit the templates to suit my community's voice?

Yes, feel free to adjust wording or tone to better fit your unique audience and brand style.

Want these customized for your Shopify community?
Generate unlimited templates with AI - tailored to your brand voice
Try Free →
✓ Copied to clipboard!