Ever feel like your SEO community gets stuck repeating the same best practices? Unpopular opinions can spark lively, thoughtful discussions and help members see new perspectives. Use these templates to challenge assumptions and foster meaningful engagement.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Unpopular opinion posts work because they disrupt the echo chamber effect that can develop in specialized communities like SEO. By encouraging members to share counterintuitive or less-common viewpoints, you invite deeper critical thinking and authentic conversation. This type of content also helps quieter voices feel empowered to contribute, since it signals that all perspectives are welcome.
When managed with respect and openness, unpopular opinion threads can surface valuable insights and foster a culture of healthy debate. They keep the community dynamic and fresh, preventing stagnation and burnout. Members are more likely to participate when they see a safe space for honest, constructive disagreement.
SEO is overrated for most small businesses. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "SEO is overrated for most small businesses. Agree or disagree?"
I think link building is becoming less important each year. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "I think link building is becoming less important each year. Thoughts?"
Keyword density still matters in 2024. Am I alone in this?
💡 Example: "Keyword density still matters in 2024. Am I alone in this?"
Technical SEO is overrated compared to content quality.
💡 Example: "Technical SEO is overrated compared to content quality."
Schema markup is mostly hype for the average website.
💡 Example: "Schema markup is mostly hype for the average website."
Not all websites need a blog. Who agrees?
💡 Example: "Not all websites need a blog. Who agrees?"
I never use keyword research tools. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I never use keyword research tools. Anyone else?"
Local SEO is not worth it unless you have a physical store.
💡 Example: "Local SEO is not worth it unless you have a physical store."
Chasing Google's algorithm updates is a waste of time.
💡 Example: "Chasing Google's algorithm updates is a waste of time."
I think meta descriptions have little SEO value now. Change my mind.
💡 Example: "I think meta descriptions have little SEO value now. Change my mind."
SEO tools are overpriced for what they offer. Agree?
💡 Example: "SEO tools are overpriced for what they offer. Agree?"
I rarely track rankings, only traffic. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I rarely track rankings, only traffic. Anyone else?"
Site speed is talked about too much in SEO circles.
💡 Example: "Site speed is talked about too much in SEO circles."
I still believe exact match domains give a big SEO boost.
💡 Example: "I still believe exact match domains give a big SEO boost."
Guest posting is no longer effective for link building. Do you agree?
💡 Example: "Guest posting is no longer effective for link building. Do you agree?"
Content length does not matter as much as people think.
💡 Example: "Content length does not matter as much as people think."
I think backlinks from directories are underrated.
💡 Example: "I think backlinks from directories are underrated."
Mobile-first indexing is not a real concern for most sites.
💡 Example: "Mobile-first indexing is not a real concern for most sites."
I focus on Bing as much as Google. Does anyone else?
💡 Example: "I focus on Bing as much as Google. Does anyone else?"
SEO can hurt user experience if done poorly. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "SEO can hurt user experience if done poorly. Thoughts?"
AI-generated content is the future of SEO. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "AI-generated content is the future of SEO. Agree or disagree?"
Most SEO case studies are not trustworthy. Who agrees?
💡 Example: "Most SEO case studies are not trustworthy. Who agrees?"
I think voice search optimization is overhyped.
💡 Example: "I think voice search optimization is overhyped."
Paid ads help SEO more than people admit. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "Paid ads help SEO more than people admit. Thoughts?"
I never noindex tag pages and have not seen issues.
💡 Example: "I never noindex tag pages and have not seen issues."
SEO certifications do not matter for real results.
💡 Example: "SEO certifications do not matter for real results."
I still use exact match anchor text and get great results.
💡 Example: "I still use exact match anchor text and get great results."
Most SEO audits are too technical for business owners.
💡 Example: "Most SEO audits are too technical for business owners."
I believe social signals do influence SEO rankings.
💡 Example: "I believe social signals do influence SEO rankings."
SEO for SaaS is very different from ecommerce. Agree?
💡 Example: "SEO for SaaS is very different from ecommerce. Agree?"
I rarely use sitemaps and do not see ranking issues.
💡 Example: "I rarely use sitemaps and do not see ranking issues."
Most SEO tools have too much data and not enough insights.
💡 Example: "Most SEO tools have too much data and not enough insights."
I think HTTPS is not a ranking factor for most niches.
💡 Example: "I think HTTPS is not a ranking factor for most niches."
I do not optimize for featured snippets on purpose.
💡 Example: "I do not optimize for featured snippets on purpose."
SEO conferences are not worth the investment.
💡 Example: "SEO conferences are not worth the investment."
I think most SEO plugins slow sites down.
💡 Example: "I think most SEO plugins slow sites down."
SEO is more about branding than rankings in 2024.
💡 Example: "SEO is more about branding than rankings in 2024."
I never use disavow tools and have not had problems.
💡 Example: "I never use disavow tools and have not had problems."
I think personal branding is now a core SEO strategy.
💡 Example: "I think personal branding is now a core SEO strategy."
I have never seen a real penalty from duplicate content.
💡 Example: "I have never seen a real penalty from duplicate content."
What is your least popular SEO opinion? Share it below.
💡 Example: "What is your least popular SEO opinion? Share it below."
Choose a template that fits your community's current topics or challenges. Personalize it with your own take, or post it as an open question. Remind members to explain their reasoning, and model respectful discussion. Monitor responses closely to ensure civility, and step in early if debates get heated. Rotate these posts regularly to keep discussions lively without overwhelming the feed.
All platforms: Use clear prompts and invite replies with a direct question. Pin or feature the best discussions. Use polls or reactions if available to highlight where opinions diverge. Remind members of community guidelines and encourage reporting of disrespectful behavior.
Focus your prompts on divisive strategies within SEO, such as 'Buying backlinks can be more effective than earning them organically.' Encourage members to share experiences, ethical considerations, and real-world outcomes. Make sure to set guidelines for respectful debate, as these topics can be polarizing in SEO communities.
Create prompts like 'Technical SEO is overrated compared to high-quality content' to encourage members to weigh in based on their results and expertise. Use these discussions to surface nuanced views about prioritizing site speed, crawlability, or schema against content strategies, and ask for specific case studies from members.
Anticipate strong reactions by reminding members to focus on evidence and respectful discussion. Frame prompts such as 'SEMrush's keyword difficulty metric is misleading' and encourage users to share data or experiences. Consider moderating more closely or setting up sub-threads for tool-specific debates.
Absolutely. Use prompts like 'Bounce rate has zero influence on Google rankings' or 'Domain authority is a vanity metric.' These spark rich, SEO-specific discussions and help dispel or reinforce common industry beliefs, backed by research or anecdotal experience.
Frame your prompts with questions that focus on opinions and high-level strategies, such as 'Most algorithm updates don't require immediate action.' Clarify that detailed client data is not expected, but general approaches, anonymized examples, or best practices are welcome.
Target specialized topics with prompts like 'International SEO is overrated for most businesses' or 'Local pack is less valuable than organic rankings.' These spark engagement among members who’ve tackled these areas, encouraging the sharing of hard-earned insights and alternative viewpoints.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks