Running out of ways to spark lively discussion in your public speaking community? Would You Rather questions are a playful and effective tool to energize members, inspire creativity, and break the ice. Use these ready-made prompts to get everyone talking and sharing their unique perspectives.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions tap into our natural curiosity and encourage members to think outside the box. By offering two intriguing options, these prompts invite participants to share their preferences and the reasoning behind them, which often leads to deeper conversations and surprising insights.
This content type works especially well in public speaking communities because it helps members explore different scenarios they may face on stage, consider their personal speaking style, and reflect on their comfort zones. The playful tone lowers barriers to participation, making even shy members more likely to join in. Ultimately, these prompts foster a sense of camaraderie and help members learn from one another's experiences.
Would you rather deliver a speech to 100 strangers or 10 close friends? Share your choice!
💡 Example: "I would rather speak to 100 strangers because it feels less personal."
Would you rather use no notes or only have 2 minutes to prepare your talk?
💡 Example: "No notes! I need a little time to collect my thoughts."
Would you rather give a speech standing or sitting? Tell us why you chose that.
💡 Example: "Standing helps me feel more confident on stage."
Would you rather speak on a stage with bright lights or in a dimly lit room?
💡 Example: "Dimly lit room feels less intimidating to me."
Would you rather present with slides or props? Which helps you more?
💡 Example: "Slides keep me organized, so I choose them!"
Would you rather have a 5-minute speech on a topic you love or a 20-minute speech on a topic you know little about?
💡 Example: "I prefer the 5-minute speech on my favorite topic!"
Would you rather answer tough audience questions or get no questions at all?
💡 Example: "Tough questions help me learn, so I choose those."
Would you rather forget your opening or your closing line? Why?
💡 Example: "I would rather forget the closing. First impressions matter most."
Would you rather give a speech outdoors or in a formal auditorium?
💡 Example: "Outdoors feels more relaxed to me."
Would you rather present to a silent audience or one that reacts loudly?
💡 Example: "I love energy, so a loud audience for me!"
Would you rather use humor in every speech or always stay serious?
💡 Example: "Humor helps me connect, so I choose that."
Would you rather have a speech recorded or only remembered by those present?
💡 Example: "I like the idea of a recording to revisit and improve."
Would you rather get constructive criticism or only positive feedback after your talk?
💡 Example: "Constructive criticism helps me improve."
Would you rather use a microphone that is too loud or too quiet?
💡 Example: "Too quiet is less distracting than too loud."
Would you rather improvise your speech or write it out word for word?
💡 Example: "I like improvising, it feels more natural."
Would you rather speak about a personal story or share research data?
💡 Example: "Personal stories make a bigger impact for me."
Would you rather present with a co-speaker or solo? Why?
💡 Example: "I like sharing the stage with a co-speaker!"
Would you rather address a group of kids or senior citizens?
💡 Example: "Kids are fun, so I pick them."
Would you rather have more time to rehearse or more time for Q and A?
💡 Example: "I would like more Q and A time."
Would you rather deliver a keynote or host a panel discussion?
💡 Example: "Keynote speeches are my favorite."
Would you rather speak first or last at an event? Share your strategy.
💡 Example: "Speaking first helps me set the tone."
Would you rather forget your slides or your water bottle?
💡 Example: "I would rather forget my water bottle."
Would you rather use creative props or engaging stories in your speech?
💡 Example: "I love using stories to connect."
Would you rather face a technical glitch or a disruptive audience?
💡 Example: "Technical glitches are easier to fix than people!"
Would you rather be known as a funny speaker or an inspiring one?
💡 Example: "Inspiring others is my goal."
Would you rather give a speech with no visuals or only visuals and no words?
💡 Example: "No visuals for me, I trust my words."
Would you rather get last-minute topic changes or last-minute venue changes?
💡 Example: "Venue changes are less stressful for me."
Would you rather warm up with tongue twisters or breathing exercises before speaking?
💡 Example: "Tongue twisters are my favorite warm-up."
Would you rather speak at a conference or a community meetup? Why?
💡 Example: "Community meetups are less formal and more fun."
Would you rather lose your place in your notes or have your slides freeze?
💡 Example: "I would rather my slides freeze."
Would you rather have a standing ovation or receive thoughtful written feedback?
💡 Example: "Thoughtful feedback helps me grow."
Would you rather deliver a speech entirely in rhyme or only use questions?
💡 Example: "Speaking in questions would be fun and interactive!"
Would you rather have your speech broadcast live or available on-demand later?
💡 Example: "On-demand speeches reach more people."
Would you rather use hand gestures or facial expressions to connect with your audience?
💡 Example: "Hand gestures keep me animated and engaging."
Would you rather have to fill in for a missing speaker or extend your own talk at the last minute?
💡 Example: "I would rather extend my own talk."
Would you rather speak on a topic you are passionate about or be paid double for a less interesting topic?
💡 Example: "Passion is worth more than money for me."
Would you rather have a noisy background or an unpredictable audience?
💡 Example: "Unpredictable audiences keep me on my toes."
Would you rather be remembered for your storytelling or your knowledge?
💡 Example: "Storytelling makes messages last."
Would you rather use humor to recover from a mistake or just move on?
💡 Example: "Humor helps lighten the mood for everyone."
Would you rather prepare with a group or alone? What works better for you?
💡 Example: "I get more done when I prepare alone."
Would you rather speak about failure or success stories?
💡 Example: "Failure stories are more relatable."
Would you rather use a teleprompter or cue cards?
💡 Example: "Cue cards feel more flexible to me."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste a Would You Rather question into your community platform of choice. Encourage members to not only vote or pick an option, but also share why they chose it. You can schedule these prompts as weekly conversation starters, use them as icebreakers before events, or integrate them into speaker training sessions. For even more engagement, invite members to suggest their own Would You Rather scenarios.
For all platforms, keep questions concise and easy to read. Use polls or emoji reactions if your platform supports them. Pin or highlight Would You Rather posts to maximize visibility. Respond to comments to encourage further sharing. Adapt the frequency of these prompts based on your community's activity level.
Integrate scenarios that reflect real anxieties, such as: 'Would you rather forget your opening line or your closing statement during a keynote?' This not only sparks discussion but also normalizes common challenges, allowing group members to share coping strategies and support.
Both have value, but alternating between impromptu and prepared speech scenarios (e.g., 'Would you rather deliver a 5-minute impromptu speech on an unknown topic or a 20-minute prepared speech on a familiar subject?') helps members reflect on their strengths, weaknesses, and preparation strategies relevant to public speaking.
Absolutely. Questions like 'Would you rather pause in silence or use a filler word when you lose your train of thought?' directly address divisive issues in public speaking, encouraging members to discuss best practices and personal preferences in a non-judgmental format.
Include prompts that compare different formats, like 'Would you rather present to a virtual audience of 200 or an in-person audience of 20?' This acknowledges the range of public speaking experiences and engages members with diverse backgrounds.
Pose dilemmas that require considering the audience, such as 'Would you rather adapt your speech for a corporate board or a group of high school students?' This encourages participants to think critically about tone, language, and content—key aspects of audience analysis in public speaking.
Craft questions that contrast nonverbal elements, for example, 'Would you rather deliver a speech with perfect eye contact but poor vocal variety, or vice versa?' This opens up targeted discussions about the impact of body language, facial expressions, and vocal delivery in effective public speaking.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks