Frustrated with sparking meaningful conversations in your painting community? Unpopular Opinion prompts are a fantastic way to encourage fresh perspectives and deeper engagement. Use these templates to fuel thoughtful debates while keeping the atmosphere friendly and constructive.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Unpopular Opinion posts break the echo chamber by inviting members to share views that challenge the norm. This disrupts passive scrolling and encourages even quiet members to share their thoughts. When managed respectfully, these discussions help members reflect on their own practices, learn from different experiences, and connect with others who see things differently.
Painting is both a technical and highly personal activity, so there is rarely a single 'right' answer. These prompts give space for nuanced debates about tools, styles, and traditions. By validating less-common perspectives, you signal that all voices are welcome, making your community more inclusive and dynamic.
I think oil paints are overrated compared to acrylics. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "I think oil paints are overrated compared to acrylics. Agree or disagree?"
Landscape painting is not as creative as abstract. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "Landscape painting is not as creative as abstract. Thoughts?"
I believe expensive brushes do not make a noticeable difference. What do you think?
💡 Example: "I believe expensive brushes do not make a noticeable difference. What do you think?"
Mixing your own colors is overrated. Premade tubes are just as good.
💡 Example: "Mixing your own colors is overrated. Premade tubes are just as good."
Sketching before painting wastes time. Does anyone else agree?
💡 Example: "Sketching before painting wastes time. Does anyone else agree?"
Watercolor is the hardest painting medium. Change my mind.
💡 Example: "Watercolor is the hardest painting medium. Change my mind."
Realism in painting is boring. Who else prefers expressive styles?
💡 Example: "Realism in painting is boring. Who else prefers expressive styles?"
Varnishing finished paintings is unnecessary. Agree or not?
💡 Example: "Varnishing finished paintings is unnecessary. Agree or not?"
Using reference photos is not cheating. Who is with me?
💡 Example: "Using reference photos is not cheating. Who is with me?"
Painting small canvases is more satisfying than large ones.
💡 Example: "Painting small canvases is more satisfying than large ones."
I do not think gesso matters that much for prepping canvas. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "I do not think gesso matters that much for prepping canvas. Thoughts?"
Digital painting is just as legitimate as traditional painting.
💡 Example: "Digital painting is just as legitimate as traditional painting."
Palette knives beat brushes for texture. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "Palette knives beat brushes for texture. Agree or disagree?"
I find painting from imagination less fun than using references.
💡 Example: "I find painting from imagination less fun than using references."
You do not need expensive paper for watercolor. Who else agrees?
💡 Example: "You do not need expensive paper for watercolor. Who else agrees?"
I prefer using student-grade paints over artist-grade.
💡 Example: "I prefer using student-grade paints over artist-grade."
Impressionism is overrated compared to more modern styles.
💡 Example: "Impressionism is overrated compared to more modern styles."
Priming your canvas twice is overkill. Yes or no?
💡 Example: "Priming your canvas twice is overkill. Yes or no?"
Painting daily does not always improve your skills fast. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "Painting daily does not always improve your skills fast. Thoughts?"
I think painting tutorials can sometimes limit creativity.
💡 Example: "I think painting tutorials can sometimes limit creativity."
Black paint should be avoided in most paintings. Who agrees?
💡 Example: "Black paint should be avoided in most paintings. Who agrees?"
I do not see the point of underpaintings. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I do not see the point of underpaintings. Anyone else?"
Classical painting techniques are not essential for beginners.
💡 Example: "Classical painting techniques are not essential for beginners."
I think painting commissions drain creativity. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "I think painting commissions drain creativity. Agree or disagree?"
Frames distract from the artwork itself. Who feels the same?
💡 Example: "Frames distract from the artwork itself. Who feels the same?"
Not every painting needs a story. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "Not every painting needs a story. Agree or disagree?"
I prefer cheap synthetic brushes over natural hair ones.
💡 Example: "I prefer cheap synthetic brushes over natural hair ones."
Working from life is not always better than photos.
💡 Example: "Working from life is not always better than photos."
Limited color palettes are not more harmonious by default. Agree?
💡 Example: "Limited color palettes are not more harmonious by default. Agree?"
I think painting outdoors is overrated. Who else prefers the studio?
💡 Example: "I think painting outdoors is overrated. Who else prefers the studio?"
Thick paint application is not always better for texture.
💡 Example: "Thick paint application is not always better for texture."
Copying old masters is not essential for growth. Do you agree?
💡 Example: "Copying old masters is not essential for growth. Do you agree?"
Acrylic pouring is not real painting. Hot take?
💡 Example: "Acrylic pouring is not real painting. Hot take?"
I believe that fan brushes are overrated for landscapes.
💡 Example: "I believe that fan brushes are overrated for landscapes."
Using masking tape ruins the spontaneity of watercolor. Agree?
💡 Example: "Using masking tape ruins the spontaneity of watercolor. Agree?"
I think painting challenges create more pressure than growth.
💡 Example: "I think painting challenges create more pressure than growth."
Art school is not necessary for most painters. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "Art school is not necessary for most painters. Thoughts?"
I do not like using glazing techniques in acrylics.
💡 Example: "I do not like using glazing techniques in acrylics."
Painting over old canvases is better than buying new ones. Who agrees?
💡 Example: "Painting over old canvases is better than buying new ones. Who agrees?"
I think painting for fun is more important than selling your work.
💡 Example: "I think painting for fun is more important than selling your work."
Do you think painting competitions hurt creativity?
💡 Example: "Do you think painting competitions hurt creativity?"
I feel like time-lapse videos misrepresent the painting process. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I feel like time-lapse videos misrepresent the painting process. Anyone else?"
Choose a template that fits your community's interests, then personalize it to match recent discussions or trends. Post it with clear instructions encouraging members to explain their reasoning. Pin or feature the thread to maximize visibility. Monitor replies to ensure tone stays respectful, and highlight thoughtful responses to show appreciation for open dialogue.
On all platforms, use simple language and clear calls to action. Consider using polls or reaction buttons where available to widen engagement. Use post pinning or featured threads to keep debates visible. Moderate actively to keep discussions on track.
To encourage constructive discussion, phrase your unpopular opinion as a personal perspective, such as 'Why I find acrylics more versatile than oil paints, even for realism.' Set clear community guidelines about respectful disagreement, and invite members to share specific techniques, drying time preferences, or cleanup experiences. This keeps the conversation focused on painting processes rather than dismissing anyone's preferred medium.
Yes, these nuanced technical choices are great for stimulating engagement because artists often have strong opinions on foundational practices. When posting, give context—ask members about their experiences with or without underpainting or using pre-mixed blacks versus mixing their own darks. This encourages knowledge-sharing and surfaces advanced tips for both beginners and seasoned painters.
Monitor these posts closely and intervene early if you spot exclusionary language. Remind members that both plein air and studio approaches offer unique challenges and learning opportunities—such as color-mixing on location versus controlled lighting. Consider following up with polls or spotlights on artists excelling in both areas to nurture a more inclusive atmosphere.
Balance technical debates with prompts inviting beginners' input, such as 'What's one painting rule you always ignore?' or 'Which color theory advice never worked for you?' Offer explanations for technical terms (like 'fat over lean' or 'alla prima') so newcomers feel welcome to join and learn from the discussion, not just observe.
These foundational debates can generate valuable dialogue if carefully moderated. Clearly outline that all paths to mastery—art school, atelier training, or self-directed practice—have merits and trade-offs, such as feedback access, cost, and curriculum structure. Invite members to share how their chosen path shaped their approach to composition, color mixing, or critique.
Set post guidelines emphasizing that photo references are a common tool in painting, with debates about originality focusing on interpretation versus copying. Encourage members to discuss how they use references—composing new scenes, studying anatomy, or adjusting lighting—rather than policing artistic ethics. Highlight examples where reference use led to innovative results to keep the conversation constructive.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks