Running out of fresh ways to spark discussion in your options trading community? Hypothetical scenarios inspire creative thinking and invite all members to join the conversation. Use these ready-made templates to get your audience sharing ideas, strategies, and what-ifs.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenario posts tap into the curiosity and imagination of community members. By presenting open-ended questions, they lower the barrier for participation, since there are no right or wrong answers. This format encourages both beginners and experienced traders to share their perspectives without fear of judgment.
The playful or speculative nature of hypothetical scenarios also helps members think beyond their usual habits, consider alternative strategies, and learn from each other. These conversations foster a sense of camaraderie while keeping the group atmosphere lively and engaging.
If you could only trade one options strategy for a year, which would you pick and why?
💡 Example: "If you could only trade one options strategy for a year, which would you pick and why?"
Imagine the market opens 10 percent higher tomorrow. What would you do with your current positions?
💡 Example: "Imagine the market opens 10 percent higher tomorrow. What would you do with your current positions?"
What if options expiration was suddenly moved to Mondays? How would your approach change?
💡 Example: "What if options expiration was suddenly moved to Mondays? How would your approach change?"
Suppose you can only use puts for a month. How would you generate income?
💡 Example: "Suppose you can only use puts for a month. How would you generate income?"
If you woke up and all your options positions were gone, what would you trade first and why?
💡 Example: "If you woke up and all your options positions were gone, what would you trade first and why?"
Would you rather always trade high IV or low IV environments? Why?
💡 Example: "Would you rather always trade high IV or low IV environments? Why?"
Imagine you have unlimited buying power but can only make three trades this month. What would they be?
💡 Example: "Imagine you have unlimited buying power but can only make three trades this month. What would they be?"
If options could only be traded on Fridays, how would your weekly routine change?
💡 Example: "If options could only be traded on Fridays, how would your weekly routine change?"
What if you were given $1,000 to trade options but could not use stocks you know? What would you pick?
💡 Example: "What if you were given $1,000 to trade options but could not use stocks you know? What would you pick?"
Suppose all commissions went to zero for a week. How would your trading change?
💡 Example: "Suppose all commissions went to zero for a week. How would your trading change?"
If you could teach a beginner one options lesson using a story, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could teach a beginner one options lesson using a story, what would it be?"
Imagine the VIX hits 100 overnight. What would you do first?
💡 Example: "Imagine the VIX hits 100 overnight. What would you do first?"
What would you do if your favorite options platform suddenly shut down?
💡 Example: "What would you do if your favorite options platform suddenly shut down?"
Suppose you could only sell covered calls for a year. Would you take the challenge?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could only sell covered calls for a year. Would you take the challenge?"
If you had to explain Greeks to a 10-year-old, how would you do it?
💡 Example: "If you had to explain Greeks to a 10-year-old, how would you do it?"
What if you accidentally sold a naked put on a stock that doubled overnight?
💡 Example: "What if you accidentally sold a naked put on a stock that doubled overnight?"
Imagine earnings season is banned for one year. How would this change your trades?
💡 Example: "Imagine earnings season is banned for one year. How would this change your trades?"
Suppose every trade you make is visible to the whole community. Would you change your approach?
💡 Example: "Suppose every trade you make is visible to the whole community. Would you change your approach?"
If you could invent a new options contract feature, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could invent a new options contract feature, what would it be?"
What if the market started opening at night? Would you trade differently?
💡 Example: "What if the market started opening at night? Would you trade differently?"
Suppose you get one free do-over on a past options trade. Which would you pick?
💡 Example: "Suppose you get one free do-over on a past options trade. Which would you pick?"
If you had to follow only one options trader for signals, who would it be and why?
💡 Example: "If you had to follow only one options trader for signals, who would it be and why?"
Imagine you can only trade options on ETFs for the next quarter. How would your strategy shift?
💡 Example: "Imagine you can only trade options on ETFs for the next quarter. How would your strategy shift?"
What would you do if the options chain UI disappeared and you had to call your broker to trade?
💡 Example: "What would you do if the options chain UI disappeared and you had to call your broker to trade?"
Suppose theta decay suddenly doubled overnight. How would you adapt?
💡 Example: "Suppose theta decay suddenly doubled overnight. How would you adapt?"
If you could ban one type of options order, which would it be and why?
💡 Example: "If you could ban one type of options order, which would it be and why?"
Imagine every options trade required a 24-hour cooling-off period. How would you handle it?
💡 Example: "Imagine every options trade required a 24-hour cooling-off period. How would you handle it?"
If you could only use one options Greek for analysis, which would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you could only use one options Greek for analysis, which would you pick?"
Suppose the market is closed for two weeks. How would you prepare your options portfolio?
💡 Example: "Suppose the market is closed for two weeks. How would you prepare your options portfolio?"
Imagine you can only open new trades after 3 PM each day. What changes?
💡 Example: "Imagine you can only open new trades after 3 PM each day. What changes?"
What would you do if you accidentally sized a trade 10 times larger than planned?
💡 Example: "What would you do if you accidentally sized a trade 10 times larger than planned?"
If you could only trade options with a $500 account, what would your strategy be?
💡 Example: "If you could only trade options with a $500 account, what would your strategy be?"
Suppose volatility disappears for a month. What would you do with your trades?
💡 Example: "Suppose volatility disappears for a month. What would you do with your trades?"
Imagine you must take the opposite side of your last options trade. How would you manage it?
💡 Example: "Imagine you must take the opposite side of your last options trade. How would you manage it?"
If you could automate one part of your options trading, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could automate one part of your options trading, what would it be?"
What would you do if you had to trade options with no charts for a week?
💡 Example: "What would you do if you had to trade options with no charts for a week?"
Suppose all your options expire ITM for a month. How would you change your approach?
💡 Example: "Suppose all your options expire ITM for a month. How would you change your approach?"
Imagine options on cryptocurrencies become available tomorrow. What would you trade first?
💡 Example: "Imagine options on cryptocurrencies become available tomorrow. What would you trade first?"
If you could only use one options platform for life, which would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "If you could only use one options platform for life, which would you choose and why?"
What would you do if your internet went out during a major market event?
💡 Example: "What would you do if your internet went out during a major market event?"
Suppose you can only use market orders for a month. How would you adapt?
💡 Example: "Suppose you can only use market orders for a month. How would you adapt?"
If you could eliminate assignment risk forever, how would your trading change?
💡 Example: "If you could eliminate assignment risk forever, how would your trading change?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste a scenario into your community post or chat. Add a personal touch or tweak details to fit current trends or your audience's trading level. Encourage responses by tagging members or following up with your own answer. Rotate different types of scenarios to keep things fresh and appeal to everyone from lurkers to top contributors.
Since these templates work across all platforms, adjust your posting style to fit the channel. Use bold or emoji to highlight the scenario in chat apps, or create a poll version on platforms that support it. For forums, start a new thread to allow deeper discussion. Always monitor replies and encourage follow-up questions to keep engagement high.
When creating hypothetical questions around advanced strategies such as iron condors or calendar spreads, ensure you present realistic market conditions (e.g., IV spikes, earnings season) and ask members to weigh trade-offs, such as risk/reward and adjustments. For example: 'If implied volatility unexpectedly drops after opening an iron condor, how would you adjust your position?' This invites experienced members to share nuanced insights and helps less experienced traders learn practical management techniques.
To encourage discussion about assignment risk, structure scenarios that highlight situations like ITM short puts near expiration or dividend risk with covered calls. For instance, ask: 'If your short put is ITM on expiration Friday and the underlying stock is volatile, would you roll, close, or accept assignment?' These focused hypotheticals help members explore decision-making under pressure, share experiences, and discuss best practices for risk mitigation.
Pose scenarios where a spread, such as a vertical or credit spread, is moving against the trader—perhaps due to an unexpected news event or earnings miss. Ask members: 'If your bull put spread is breaching the short strike two weeks before expiration, what adjustment strategies would you consider: rolling, adding contracts, or closing?' This approach encourages practical, options-specific problem-solving and comparison of adjustment techniques.
Absolutely! Draft scenarios like: 'The VIX suddenly spikes and everyone in your group chat is opening short strangles. How do you decide whether to join in or stay on the sidelines?' These questions prompt members to discuss emotional discipline, risk limits, and personal trading rules specific to volatile options markets, which are crucial aspects of successful options trading.
Create scenarios that showcase unique considerations for each—such as settlement types, tax treatment, and liquidity. For example: 'You’re considering a weekly iron fly on SPX vs. AAPL. What unique risks or benefits do you need to account for with each underlying?' This encourages members to share insights on product-specific nuances, helping the community deepen its understanding of different options instruments.
Design questions around changing Greek exposures in dynamic market situations. For instance: 'Your short straddle has high negative gamma ahead of a major earnings announcement. How would you manage the position if the underlying moves sharply?' This prompts members to analyze how the Greeks influence risk and reward, encouraging deeper learning about options pricing and position management.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks