Having trouble sparking fresh conversations and creative thinking in your nonprofit community? Hypothetical scenarios open the door to playful, insightful engagement that goes beyond routine updates. Use these ready-to-go prompts to inspire connection and out-of-the-box participation.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios encourage members to think creatively, step outside their daily roles, and imagine new solutions. This type of content lowers the barrier to participation, as there are no wrong answers and everyone can share their perspective. By inviting imagination, you foster a more inclusive, open environment where members feel valued for their ideas, not just their expertise.
Scenarios also give members a chance to reveal their values, motivations, and personal experiences in a safe and playful way. This deepens relationships and helps members see each other as collaborators and problem-solvers. Ultimately, 'what if' questions drive engagement by making the community a space for both fun and meaningful reflection.
If your nonprofit suddenly received unlimited funding for one day, what would you do first?
💡 Example: "If we got unlimited funds for a day, I would launch a mobile clinic in every rural area."
Imagine you could partner with any famous person for your cause. Who would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "I would choose Malala, because her story aligns with our mission."
What if your community had to run your nonprofit for a week? What new ideas do you think would emerge?
💡 Example: "I think we would try more digital outreach and creative event formats."
Suppose you could instantly solve one challenge in your nonprofit work. Which would it be?
💡 Example: "I would fix volunteer burnout so we can sustain our programs."
If you could have any superpower to help your cause, what would it be?
💡 Example: "I would choose the power to inspire instant empathy in everyone."
Imagine your nonprofit's logo came to life. What would it say to the world?
💡 Example: "Our logo would say 'Everyone deserves a safe home.'"
What if you had to explain your cause to a child using only three words?
💡 Example: "Hope, support, change."
Suppose your nonprofit could make one global policy instantly. What would you change?
💡 Example: "I would make education free for all children."
If every volunteer could get one magical tool, what would it be and why?
💡 Example: "A time-turner so we could fit in more activities."
Imagine your nonprofit is featured in a movie. What is the title?
💡 Example: "A Bridge to Hope."
What if you swapped roles with a beneficiary for a day? What would you hope to learn?
💡 Example: "I would like to understand their daily challenges firsthand."
Suppose your cause could solve one environmental issue overnight. Which would you pick?
💡 Example: "I would choose to eliminate plastic pollution."
If you could host your next event anywhere in the world, where would it be?
💡 Example: "I would love to host it in the Sydney Opera House."
Imagine your nonprofit could speak any language instantly. Which community would you reach out to?
💡 Example: "We would reach out to rural communities in India."
What if you had to run your nonprofit using only digital tools for a month?
💡 Example: "It would be tough but could help us reach more people online."
Suppose you could invite any historical figure to your next board meeting. Who would it be?
💡 Example: "I would invite Nelson Mandela for his wisdom."
If your nonprofit could only focus on one project this year, which would you choose?
💡 Example: "I would focus on the youth mentorship program."
Imagine you could grant every staff member one wish for their work. What would it be?
💡 Example: "I would grant them all more time to recharge."
What if your nonprofit had to create a new mascot? What would it look like?
💡 Example: "A friendly, energetic fox representing resourcefulness."
Suppose you could add one skill to your team overnight. What would it be?
💡 Example: "Grant writing expertise."
If you had to explain your mission using a song title, what would it be?
💡 Example: "Lean On Me."
Imagine your nonprofit is given a billboard in Times Square for a day. What message would you display?
💡 Example: "Every Child Deserves a Future."
What if every donor could see the direct impact of their gift instantly?
💡 Example: "I think it would inspire even more generosity."
Suppose you had to run a fundraiser without using social media. How would you do it?
💡 Example: "I would organize community events and use local press."
If you could teleport one team member anywhere for a site visit, who and where?
💡 Example: "Our project manager to our rural clinic."
Imagine your nonprofit could host an event with unlimited guests. What would you plan?
💡 Example: "A global conference on ending hunger."
What if your organization could only use one social platform for a year?
💡 Example: "We would focus on Facebook for its community features."
Suppose you could instantly master any skill to help your nonprofit. What would you choose?
💡 Example: "I would master public speaking to advocate better."
If your nonprofit could create a new holiday, what would it celebrate?
💡 Example: "Global Kindness Day."
Imagine you could send a message to your younger self about nonprofit work. What would you say?
💡 Example: "Stay patient, small actions add up."
What if every grant application was just one question? What would you ask?
💡 Example: "How will this project change lives?"
Suppose you could swap missions with another nonprofit for a week. Which would you pick?
💡 Example: "I would swap with a wildlife conservation group."
If your nonprofit could offer one service for free to everyone, what would it be?
💡 Example: "Free mental health counseling."
Imagine you could solve one big misconception about your cause. What would you correct?
💡 Example: "That ending poverty is impossible."
What if you had to recruit new volunteers using only three words?
💡 Example: "Make a difference."
Suppose your nonprofit could invent a new technology. What problem would it solve?
💡 Example: "Tech to clean oceans automatically."
If your nonprofit had to start over today, what would you do differently?
💡 Example: "Invest more in community partnerships early."
Imagine you could write a letter to your biggest supporter. What would you say?
💡 Example: "Thank you for believing in us and making change possible."
What if every nonprofit leader had to take a week off for creative thinking?
💡 Example: "I think organizations would discover fresh approaches."
Suppose your cause could inspire a new emoji. What would it look like?
💡 Example: "A helping hand holding a heart."
If you could change one thing about how the world views nonprofits, what would it be?
💡 Example: "That nonprofits are innovative and impactful."
To use these templates, simply copy and post the scenario in your community forum, group, or social channel. Encourage members to share their thoughts, brainstorm together, or even vote on the most creative responses. Use them as icebreakers, event openers, or weekly discussion starters to keep conversations lively and inclusive. Mix serious and lighthearted scenarios to appeal to a variety of member interests.
These hypothetical scenario templates work across all platforms. For forums or Slack, use as regular discussion threads or chat prompts. On Facebook or LinkedIn, post as engaging questions in your group. For Instagram or Twitter, use as captions or polls. Adapt the length and format to fit each platform's style and character limits.
Hypothetical scenario posts are ideal for prompting dialogue around real ethical challenges such as donor confidentiality, resource allocation, or conflicts of interest between organizational mission and funding sources. Frame scenarios around situations like 'A donor requests recognition that goes against your nonprofit's inclusivity values—what do you do?' This encourages members to share perspectives rooted in nonprofit ethics and policy.
Create posts that mirror common nonprofit fundraising hurdles, such as responding to a sudden drop in grant funding, managing donor fatigue, or pivoting due to an unexpected crisis. For example, 'Your annual gala is canceled last minute—how do you quickly mobilize alternative funding using digital channels?' Such scenarios invite creative, industry-specific solutions from your community.
Design scenarios around topics like volunteer burnout, retention, or managing generational differences among volunteers. For instance, you might post: 'You notice a decline in volunteer engagement during off-peak months—what initiatives could re-energize your volunteer base?' These prompt members to share actionable strategies based on nonprofit sector realities.
Yes, you can adapt templates to explore scenarios where nonprofit leaders must navigate competing interests, like reconciling a board's funding restrictions with feedback from program beneficiaries. Example: 'The board wants to cut a program that's beloved by your community—how do you facilitate a solution-focused dialogue?' This brings out nuanced, nonprofit-specific leadership strategies.
Develop scenarios around crises such as negative press coverage, sudden funding shortfalls, or natural disasters affecting service delivery. For instance: 'A local news outlet publishes a critical piece about your nonprofit's impact—how do you respond to donors and the public?' These posts let members practice nonprofit-ready communication skills and response planning.
Pose situations that require members to consider regulatory and reporting obligations, such as: 'A major grant requires new metrics your team struggles to measure—how do you ensure accurate reporting and compliance?' This sparks conversation around best practices for nonprofit data management, reporting, and adherence to funder requirements.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks