Need help with inspire creative conversations in your non-fiction writing community? Hypothetical scenario prompts can spark imagination and participation, turning passive members into active contributors. Use these ready-made templates to encourage thought-provoking, playful discussions that everyone will want to join.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios are powerful tools in community engagement because they invite members to think creatively without the pressure of right or wrong answers. By exploring 'what if' questions, members can share unique perspectives, draw on their life experiences, and connect over shared curiosity. This format naturally lowers barriers to participation, especially for those who may feel hesitant to contribute more factual or expertise-based content.
For non-fiction writers, these prompts offer a fun twist on their usual routines, inviting them to flex their imaginative muscles within real-world frameworks. Scenarios can be tailored to both serious and lighthearted topics, making them accessible and appealing to a broad audience. Ultimately, this approach cultivates an environment of openness and creativity, which is essential for a thriving writing community.
If you could interview any historical figure for your next article, who would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "If you could interview any historical figure for your next article, who would you choose and why?"
Imagine you discover a lost diary from a famous explorer. What would you hope it reveals?
💡 Example: "Imagine you discover a lost diary from a famous explorer. What would you hope it reveals?"
What if you had to write an entire book using only facts found in your local newspaper this week?
💡 Example: "What if you had to write an entire book using only facts found in your local newspaper this week?"
Suppose your most recent article went viral overnight. What opportunities would you pursue next?
💡 Example: "Suppose your most recent article went viral overnight. What opportunities would you pursue next?"
If you could time travel to witness one real event for research, which event would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you could time travel to witness one real event for research, which event would you pick?"
Imagine a world where your favorite non-fiction genre does not exist. How would your writing change?
💡 Example: "Imagine a world where your favorite non-fiction genre does not exist. How would your writing change?"
You are tasked with debunking a widely believed myth. Which myth would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "You are tasked with debunking a widely believed myth. Which myth would you choose and why?"
What if your research led you to a surprising conclusion that challenges common knowledge?
💡 Example: "What if your research led you to a surprising conclusion that challenges common knowledge?"
Suppose you could collaborate with any living journalist. Who would it be and what would you write together?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could collaborate with any living journalist. Who would it be and what would you write together?"
If you had to write a memoir from the perspective of someone else in your life, who would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you had to write a memoir from the perspective of someone else in your life, who would you pick?"
Imagine you find a box of old letters in an attic. How would you use them as inspiration for a non-fiction piece?
💡 Example: "Imagine you find a box of old letters in an attic. How would you use them as inspiration for a non-fiction piece?"
What if you could rewrite one chapter of history based on new evidence? Which chapter would you pick?
💡 Example: "What if you could rewrite one chapter of history based on new evidence? Which chapter would you pick?"
If you were given an unlimited research budget, what topic would you explore in depth?
💡 Example: "If you were given an unlimited research budget, what topic would you explore in depth?"
Suppose you have to write under a pen name for a year. What name would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "Suppose you have to write under a pen name for a year. What name would you choose and why?"
Imagine a future historian writes about your daily life. What details would surprise them?
💡 Example: "Imagine a future historian writes about your daily life. What details would surprise them?"
What if you could spend one week shadowing any expert in your field? Who would you choose?
💡 Example: "What if you could spend one week shadowing any expert in your field? Who would you choose?"
If your favorite book never existed, how would that have changed your writing journey?
💡 Example: "If your favorite book never existed, how would that have changed your writing journey?"
Suppose you are assigned to write a feature on a mysterious event with no sources. How would you tackle it?
💡 Example: "Suppose you are assigned to write a feature on a mysterious event with no sources. How would you tackle it?"
Imagine your next book is adapted into a documentary. Who would narrate it and why?
💡 Example: "Imagine your next book is adapted into a documentary. Who would narrate it and why?"
What if you could ask one question to any living public figure and they must answer honestly?
💡 Example: "What if you could ask one question to any living public figure and they must answer honestly?"
If you could travel anywhere for research, where would you go first?
💡 Example: "If you could travel anywhere for research, where would you go first?"
Imagine you have to write a book from the perspective of an object in your home. Which object would you choose?
💡 Example: "Imagine you have to write a book from the perspective of an object in your home. Which object would you choose?"
What if you could only use interviews or data, but not both, in your next project? Which would you pick?
💡 Example: "What if you could only use interviews or data, but not both, in your next project? Which would you pick?"
Suppose you encounter an unsolved mystery from your hometown. How would you start your investigation?
💡 Example: "Suppose you encounter an unsolved mystery from your hometown. How would you start your investigation?"
If you could have lunch with any non-fiction writer, past or present, who would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could have lunch with any non-fiction writer, past or present, who would it be?"
Imagine you are given access to a secret archive. What story would you hope to uncover?
💡 Example: "Imagine you are given access to a secret archive. What story would you hope to uncover?"
What if your next article had to be written entirely without internet research? How would you approach it?
💡 Example: "What if your next article had to be written entirely without internet research? How would you approach it?"
Suppose you could erase one misconception from public knowledge. Which one would you choose?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could erase one misconception from public knowledge. Which one would you choose?"
If you could revisit and rewrite any of your published pieces, which would it be and why?
💡 Example: "If you could revisit and rewrite any of your published pieces, which would it be and why?"
Imagine a world where only oral storytelling exists. How would you adapt your writing style?
💡 Example: "Imagine a world where only oral storytelling exists. How would you adapt your writing style?"
What if you could swap writing habits with any famous author for a week?
💡 Example: "What if you could swap writing habits with any famous author for a week?"
Suppose you have to write a compelling story using only public records. What kind of story would you tell?
💡 Example: "Suppose you have to write a compelling story using only public records. What kind of story would you tell?"
If you could add a new section to history textbooks worldwide, what would you include?
💡 Example: "If you could add a new section to history textbooks worldwide, what would you include?"
Imagine your writing is featured on the front page of a major newspaper tomorrow. What is the headline?
💡 Example: "Imagine your writing is featured on the front page of a major newspaper tomorrow. What is the headline?"
What if you had to write about a topic you know nothing about? How would you start your research?
💡 Example: "What if you had to write about a topic you know nothing about? How would you start your research?"
Suppose you must write a book in a single month. What would your strategy be?
💡 Example: "Suppose you must write a book in a single month. What would your strategy be?"
If you could share one piece of advice with your younger writing self, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could share one piece of advice with your younger writing self, what would it be?"
Imagine you are writing from a different country with a new culture. How would your perspective change?
💡 Example: "Imagine you are writing from a different country with a new culture. How would your perspective change?"
What if you were required to cite only primary sources for a year?
💡 Example: "What if you were required to cite only primary sources for a year?"
Suppose you could bring one historical figure into the present for an interview. Who would it be?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could bring one historical figure into the present for an interview. Who would it be?"
If you had to write using only analog tools for a month, how would it affect your process?
💡 Example: "If you had to write using only analog tools for a month, how would it affect your process?"
Imagine your latest non-fiction work becomes part of a school curriculum. How would you feel?
💡 Example: "Imagine your latest non-fiction work becomes part of a school curriculum. How would you feel?"
What if you had to write about your least favorite topic for a year? How would you stay motivated?
💡 Example: "What if you had to write about your least favorite topic for a year? How would you stay motivated?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste a scenario into your community platform of choice. Adjust the context or add a follow-up question to fit your group's interests or current discussions. Rotate between serious and playful prompts to appeal to different member personalities. Encourage responses by tagging members or sharing your own answer as an example. Consider using these scenarios as icebreakers, weekly challenges, or discussion starters during live sessions.
On all platforms, format your scenario prompt to stand out, such as using bold or italics for the question. Pin high-engagement threads for visibility. Use polls or comment threads to capture answers. Encourage sharing via replies, videos, or images if your platform supports it. Monitor for respectful, inclusive discussion.
To encourage thoughtful discussion around memoir ethics, present scenarios where writers must decide whether to reveal sensitive information about living relatives or how to balance truth with privacy. For example, ask: 'If your nonfiction manuscript could harm a family member's reputation, would you change names, omit details, or publish as is?' Such prompts spark debate on boundaries, fact-checking, and ethical responsibility specific to memoir writers.
Narrative nonfiction writers are drawn to scenarios that explore alternative interpretations or outcomes of real events. Propose hypotheticals like: 'If you uncovered a primary source contradicting the accepted account of a major event, would you revise your manuscript or stick to the conventional narrative?' This taps into research integrity, revision challenges, and narrative bias—core to narrative nonfiction.
Create scenarios where journalists must choose between pursuing a risky lead or sticking to verified facts. For example: 'If you receive an anonymous tip with no corroboration, do you investigate further, publish with a disclaimer, or disregard it?' Such prompts help members discuss fact-checking, source reliability, and editorial standards unique to investigative nonfiction.
Absolutely. Pose scenarios like: 'If your research uncovers conflicting eyewitness accounts, do you present both, choose the most credible, or offer your interpretation?' This encourages discussion around historiography, bias, and source triangulation—skills crucial to nonfiction historical writing.
Frame scenarios such as: 'Suppose your subject can't recall exact conversations from decades ago. Do you reconstruct dialogue based on research, paraphrase, or exclude it?' This opens up nuanced debate about the boundaries of creative nonfiction, narrative truth, and transparency with readers.
Present situations like: 'If you’re writing an exposé on a public figure and your legal team warns about potential libel, do you self-censor, seek additional verification, or proceed as planned?' Such prompts focus on real-world dilemmas faced by nonfiction writers documenting current events, encouraging discussion about legal risks, editorial decisions, and responsible reporting.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks