Getting honest feedback from your non-fiction writing community can be a challenge. If you want more participation and actionable insights, these plug-and-play Community Feedback templates make it easy to spark conversations and show members their voices matter.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Community Feedback posts give members a direct way to share their thoughts, which increases their sense of ownership and belonging. When writers see that their opinions help shape resources, events, or features, they feel valued and are more likely to stay engaged. Open-ended feedback also brings in diverse perspectives, uncovering blind spots and sparking new ideas.
Psychologically, asking for input demonstrates trust and respect. It moves the relationship from top-down instruction to collaborative growth. This two-way communication is especially important in non-fiction writing communities, where members often have varied backgrounds and expertise. By creating space for all voices, you foster a more vibrant and supportive group.
What resources would you like to see added to our non-fiction writing toolkit?
💡 Example: "What resources would you like to see added to our non-fiction writing toolkit?"
How can we make our weekly critique sessions more helpful for you?
💡 Example: "How can we make our weekly critique sessions more helpful for you?"
Share your favorite non-fiction writing tool and tell us why you love it.
💡 Example: "Share your favorite non-fiction writing tool and tell us why you love it."
What is one topic you wish we covered more in our discussions?
💡 Example: "What is one topic you wish we covered more in our discussions?"
Which recent workshop did you find most useful and why?
💡 Example: "Which recent workshop did you find most useful and why?"
What challenges are you facing in your current writing project?
💡 Example: "What challenges are you facing in your current writing project?"
If you could change one thing about our community, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could change one thing about our community, what would it be?"
How do you prefer to receive feedback on your writing?
💡 Example: "How do you prefer to receive feedback on your writing?"
What is missing from our non-fiction reading list?
💡 Example: "What is missing from our non-fiction reading list?"
Tell us about a non-fiction author who inspires your writing.
💡 Example: "Tell us about a non-fiction author who inspires your writing."
How could we improve our group guidelines for a better experience?
💡 Example: "How could we improve our group guidelines for a better experience?"
What motivates you to keep writing non-fiction?
💡 Example: "What motivates you to keep writing non-fiction?"
Which aspect of your writing do you find hardest to get feedback on?
💡 Example: "Which aspect of your writing do you find hardest to get feedback on?"
What features would you want in a community writing challenge?
💡 Example: "What features would you want in a community writing challenge?"
How often do you want live Q and A sessions?
💡 Example: "How often do you want live Q and A sessions?"
What would make our online meetups more valuable for you?
💡 Example: "What would make our online meetups more valuable for you?"
Share your best tip for staying organized with research.
💡 Example: "Share your best tip for staying organized with research."
What is your biggest roadblock when drafting non-fiction pieces?
💡 Example: "What is your biggest roadblock when drafting non-fiction pieces?"
How can we better support new writers in our community?
💡 Example: "How can we better support new writers in our community?"
Which community event would you like us to bring back?
💡 Example: "Which community event would you like us to bring back?"
Is there a writing skill you want more resources on?
💡 Example: "Is there a writing skill you want more resources on?"
What makes you feel most supported as a non-fiction writer here?
💡 Example: "What makes you feel most supported as a non-fiction writer here?"
How can we improve our monthly writing prompts?
💡 Example: "How can we improve our monthly writing prompts?"
Share a topic you want to explore in upcoming workshops.
💡 Example: "Share a topic you want to explore in upcoming workshops."
What kind of guest speakers would you like to hear from?
💡 Example: "What kind of guest speakers would you like to hear from?"
How comfortable do you feel sharing your work for critique here?
💡 Example: "How comfortable do you feel sharing your work for critique here?"
What would encourage you to participate more in discussions?
💡 Example: "What would encourage you to participate more in discussions?"
How can we make this group feel more inclusive for all writers?
💡 Example: "How can we make this group feel more inclusive for all writers?"
What format do you prefer for community updates?
💡 Example: "What format do you prefer for community updates?"
What would make you recommend this community to another writer?
💡 Example: "What would make you recommend this community to another writer?"
Share one thing that surprised you about non-fiction writing.
💡 Example: "Share one thing that surprised you about non-fiction writing."
How helpful do you find our resource library?
💡 Example: "How helpful do you find our resource library?"
What would you like to see in our next community newsletter?
💡 Example: "What would you like to see in our next community newsletter?"
How can we help you connect with other non-fiction writers here?
💡 Example: "How can we help you connect with other non-fiction writers here?"
What is your favorite way to brainstorm ideas for non-fiction?
💡 Example: "What is your favorite way to brainstorm ideas for non-fiction?"
Is there a platform feature you wish we used more?
💡 Example: "Is there a platform feature you wish we used more?"
What would help you feel more confident sharing your drafts?
💡 Example: "What would help you feel more confident sharing your drafts?"
How do you like to celebrate your non-fiction writing wins?
💡 Example: "How do you like to celebrate your non-fiction writing wins?"
What non-fiction genre do you want to learn more about?
💡 Example: "What non-fiction genre do you want to learn more about?"
What would make our online space easier to navigate?
💡 Example: "What would make our online space easier to navigate?"
Which non-fiction trends are you most curious about this year?
💡 Example: "Which non-fiction trends are you most curious about this year?"
To use these templates, select a prompt that matches your current goal or topic. Post it in your community space and encourage all members to respond, regardless of their experience level. Adjust the template as needed to fit your brand voice or specific situation. After gathering feedback, acknowledge member contributions and, if possible, share how their input will be used to improve the group.
Since these templates are designed for all platforms, focus on clear, concise language that works in posts, emails, or chat. Use tagging or pin features to highlight feedback threads. Encourage replies and reactions to build momentum, and consider using polls for quick takes alongside open prompts.
You can create feedback prompts that ask members to share excerpts or outlines and request community input on whether their writing style or narrative structure aligns more closely with memoir or autobiography conventions. This not only encourages engagement but also prompts nuanced discussions about voice, perspective, and scope—key considerations in non-fiction writing.
Craft feedback requests that focus on evaluating sources and fact-checking methods. Ask members to share a paragraph with citations and invite the community to discuss the clarity of attribution and suggest alternative sources. This helps writers enhance their credibility and adhere to non-fiction standards.
Develop feedback posts that guide members to critique narrative voice using specific prompts, such as 'Does the writer’s voice feel consistent and engaging?' or 'How does the voice support the essay’s purpose?' Encourage responders to highlight strengths as well as suggest improvements, fostering a supportive environment for vulnerable, authentic storytelling.
Use feedback prompts that focus on logical flow, clarity of thesis, and effectiveness of evidence presentation. Invite members to share introductions or outlines for peer review, specifically asking for suggestions on strengthening arguments and identifying logical gaps. This targets challenges unique to persuasive non-fiction writing.
Create dedicated feedback threads where members share book proposals or query letters, and use structured templates that prompt reviewers to assess clarity of concept, target audience identification, and market positioning. This approach helps non-fiction writers refine key industry documents crucial for publication.
Encourage members to tailor their feedback based on the conventions and reader expectations of each non-fiction subgenre. For example, narrative journalism pieces may benefit from critiques on immersive storytelling and ethical sourcing, while self-help manuscripts need feedback on actionable advice and accessibility. Provide example prompts in your feedback posts to model this approach.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks