Struggling to spark engagement in your music community? This or That prompts make participation easy and fun, encouraging members to share quick opinions without pressure. Explore our collection of playful, music-inspired questions to get your group talking instantly.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That content taps into the human love for choices and friendly debates. By offering two simple options, members can respond with minimal effort or hesitation, lowering the barrier to participation. This approach draws in both casual lurkers and active posters, making everyone feel comfortable sharing their voice.
Music is deeply personal, but these prompts keep things light and non-judgmental. Instead of asking for complex analysis, you invite instant reactions. These questions often spark follow-up conversations, as members compare reasons and discover shared tastes, building rapport and a sense of community.
Vinyl or streaming - which do you prefer for listening?
💡 Example: "Vinyl or streaming - which do you prefer for listening?"
Classical or jazz - which would you play to relax?
💡 Example: "Classical or jazz - which would you play to relax?"
Live concert or music festival - which is your vibe?
💡 Example: "Live concert or music festival - which is your vibe?"
Guitar solo or drum solo - which gets you hyped?
💡 Example: "Guitar solo or drum solo - which gets you hyped?"
Lyrics or melody - what matters more to you?
💡 Example: "Lyrics or melody - what matters more to you?"
Morning playlist or night playlist - when do you listen more?
💡 Example: "Morning playlist or night playlist - when do you listen more?"
Pop or rock - which is your go-to genre?
💡 Example: "Pop or rock - which is your go-to genre?"
Headphones or speakers - how do you enjoy music?
💡 Example: "Headphones or speakers - how do you enjoy music?"
Album or singles - do you prefer full projects or just hits?
💡 Example: "Album or singles - do you prefer full projects or just hits?"
Oldies or new releases - what do you listen to more?
💡 Example: "Oldies or new releases - what do you listen to more?"
Singing or playing an instrument - which would you rather do?
💡 Example: "Singing or playing an instrument - which would you rather do?"
Summer jams or winter ballads - which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Summer jams or winter ballads - which do you prefer?"
Front row or back row at a show - where do you stand?
💡 Example: "Front row or back row at a show - where do you stand?"
Spotify or Apple Music - which is your main app?
💡 Example: "Spotify or Apple Music - which is your main app?"
Cover songs or originals - what do you enjoy more?
💡 Example: "Cover songs or originals - what do you enjoy more?"
Upbeat or chill - what is your playlist mood today?
💡 Example: "Upbeat or chill - what is your playlist mood today?"
90s hits or 2000s bangers - which era wins for you?
💡 Example: "90s hits or 2000s bangers - which era wins for you?"
Solo artist or band - who do you listen to more?
💡 Example: "Solo artist or band - who do you listen to more?"
Music videos or live sessions - which do you watch more?
💡 Example: "Music videos or live sessions - which do you watch more?"
Major key or minor key - which sound pulls you in?
💡 Example: "Major key or minor key - which sound pulls you in?"
Festival crowd or intimate gig - what is your dream show?
💡 Example: "Festival crowd or intimate gig - what is your dream show?"
Listening alone or with friends - which do you enjoy more?
💡 Example: "Listening alone or with friends - which do you enjoy more?"
Sing along or just listen - what do you do?
💡 Example: "Sing along or just listen - what do you do?"
Bass or treble - which do you crank up?
💡 Example: "Bass or treble - which do you crank up?"
Music in the car or at home - where do you listen most?
💡 Example: "Music in the car or at home - where do you listen most?"
Discovering new artists or replaying favorites - what is your habit?
💡 Example: "Discovering new artists or replaying favorites - what is your habit?"
Dance music or chill beats - what is your top pick?
💡 Example: "Dance music or chill beats - what is your top pick?"
Old-school hip-hop or modern rap - which do you play?
💡 Example: "Old-school hip-hop or modern rap - which do you play?"
Streaming playlists or radio stations - how do you find music?
💡 Example: "Streaming playlists or radio stations - how do you find music?"
Movie soundtracks or video game music - what is your jam?
💡 Example: "Movie soundtracks or video game music - what is your jam?"
Slow ballads or fast anthems - what gets you more emotional?
💡 Example: "Slow ballads or fast anthems - what gets you more emotional?"
Learn a new instrument or master your favorite - what would you do?
💡 Example: "Learn a new instrument or master your favorite - what would you do?"
Acoustic version or original - which do you pick?
💡 Example: "Acoustic version or original - which do you pick?"
Streaming new releases or revisiting classics - what is your mood?
💡 Example: "Streaming new releases or revisiting classics - what is your mood?"
Open mic night or karaoke - what would you try?
💡 Example: "Open mic night or karaoke - what would you try?"
Soundtrack to your life - upbeat or mellow?
💡 Example: "Soundtrack to your life - upbeat or mellow?"
Attending concerts in person or watching live streams - which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Attending concerts in person or watching live streams - which do you prefer?"
Festival food or festival merch - what are you grabbing first?
💡 Example: "Festival food or festival merch - what are you grabbing first?"
Singing in the shower or singing in the car - where are you louder?
💡 Example: "Singing in the shower or singing in the car - where are you louder?"
Chill out with lo-fi or hype up with EDM - what is your mood today?
💡 Example: "Chill out with lo-fi or hype up with EDM - what is your mood today?"
Would you rather write a song or perform on stage?
💡 Example: "Would you rather write a song or perform on stage?"
Do you prefer upbeat pop or soulful RnB? Tell us why.
💡 Example: "Do you prefer upbeat pop or soulful RnB? Tell us why."
To use these templates, simply select a prompt that fits your community's mood or theme for the day. Post it with a short intro, and encourage members to reply with their pick and maybe a reason. These work great as standalone posts or as icebreakers in comment threads. Rotate topics often to keep things fresh and include everyone, from die-hard fans to casual listeners.
These This or That templates are designed for all platforms. On forums and Facebook Groups, post as a question and pin or bump for visibility. On Instagram Stories or TikTok, use the poll or question sticker to drive quick taps. On Discord or Slack, use threads or channels for responses. Always follow up with reactions or replies to keep conversation flowing.
When crafting 'This or That' prompts, consider pairing options that represent both groups, such as 'Guitar solo vs. Vocal riff' or 'Acoustic arrangement vs. A cappella rendition.' Use terminology familiar to each subgroup and alternate between instrumental-focused and vocalist-focused posts to ensure inclusivity and broaden engagement.
'This or That' prompts can highlight production choices like 'Analog synth vs. Digital synth,' 'Live drums vs. Drum machine,' or 'Home studio vs. Professional studio.' These choices foster discussion among producers, engineers, and artists about preferred workflows, gear, and sound aesthetics, tapping into niche interests within the music community.
Frame prompts to encourage lighthearted preferences rather than definitive judgments, such as 'Which do you vibe with today: Jazz improvisation or Classical composition?' Remind members that all tastes are valid, and moderate posts actively to redirect any negative discourse into constructive musical discussion. Including a disclaimer about respecting all genres can help maintain a positive environment.
Yes, you can design posts like '60s Motown vs. 80s Synthpop' or 'Abbey Road vs. Thriller' to spark nostalgia and educational conversations. Provide brief context or a fun fact with each option to inspire informed choices and encourage members to share their own memories or discoveries related to the featured era or album.
For creator-focused groups, use prompts like 'Improvised solo vs. Composed solo' or 'Writing lyrics first vs. Composing melody first.' For appreciation-based communities, focus on listening experiences, such as 'Studio version vs. Live performance' or 'Vinyl vs. Streaming.' Tailoring your wording to your audience's primary engagement with music will make posts more relevant and interactive.
Incorporate diverse prompts such as 'K-Pop vs. Afrobeat,' 'Carnatic vocals vs. Flamenco guitar,' or 'Samba rhythms vs. Celtic melodies.' Rotate options to represent different continents and cultures, and occasionally invite the community to suggest their own cross-cultural 'This or That' pairs to increase global relevance and participation.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks