Looking for a quick way to spark engagement in your music production community? This or That prompts make it easy for members to jump into conversation with fun, low-pressure questions. Use these templates to get everyone talking, sharing preferences, and connecting instantly.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That questions work because they lower the barrier for participation. With only two simple options, even shy or busy members can respond quickly, encouraging more voices in the discussion. The playful, informal nature of these prompts makes it easy for people to share opinions without overthinking.
For music production communities, This or That taps into shared interests while celebrating individual tastes. Whether it's gear, genres, or workflow choices, these questions highlight the diversity of your members and spark spontaneous conversations. Over time, regular use of these prompts builds community culture and helps members find common ground.
Analog synths or digital synths? Which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Analog synths or digital synths? Which do you prefer?"
Headphones or studio monitors for mixing?
💡 Example: "Headphones or studio monitors for mixing?"
Do you start a track with drums or melody?
💡 Example: "Do you start a track with drums or melody?"
VST plugins or hardware effects?
💡 Example: "VST plugins or hardware effects?"
Morning sessions or late-night creativity?
💡 Example: "Morning sessions or late-night creativity?"
Ableton Live or FL Studio?
💡 Example: "Ableton Live or FL Studio?"
Loops or one-shots for building beats?
💡 Example: "Loops or one-shots for building beats?"
Do you prefer reverb or delay for space in your mix?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer reverb or delay for space in your mix?"
Electronic or acoustic instruments?
💡 Example: "Electronic or acoustic instruments?"
Produce solo or collaborate with others?
💡 Example: "Produce solo or collaborate with others?"
Mixing or mastering - which do you enjoy more?
💡 Example: "Mixing or mastering - which do you enjoy more?"
Do you write lyrics first or music first?
💡 Example: "Do you write lyrics first or music first?"
Sample packs or original recordings?
💡 Example: "Sample packs or original recordings?"
Hip-hop beats or house grooves?
💡 Example: "Hip-hop beats or house grooves?"
Over-ear or in-ear headphones for producing?
💡 Example: "Over-ear or in-ear headphones for producing?"
Do you prefer to work in silence or with reference tracks?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer to work in silence or with reference tracks?"
Compressors: analog or digital?
💡 Example: "Compressors: analog or digital?"
Big studio setup or compact home studio?
💡 Example: "Big studio setup or compact home studio?"
Work with a template or start from scratch?
💡 Example: "Work with a template or start from scratch?"
Do you export as WAV or MP3 for sharing drafts?
💡 Example: "Do you export as WAV or MP3 for sharing drafts?"
Chill ambient vibes or high-energy bangers?
💡 Example: "Chill ambient vibes or high-energy bangers?"
Manual automation or use LFOs?
💡 Example: "Manual automation or use LFOs?"
Favorite workflow: arrange first or sound design first?
💡 Example: "Favorite workflow: arrange first or sound design first?"
Do you prefer to produce with a mouse or a MIDI controller?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer to produce with a mouse or a MIDI controller?"
Work on one track at a time or multiple projects?
💡 Example: "Work on one track at a time or multiple projects?"
Do you use metronome or tap tempo to set BPM?
💡 Example: "Do you use metronome or tap tempo to set BPM?"
Trap hi-hats or classic rock snares?
💡 Example: "Trap hi-hats or classic rock snares?"
Do you mix as you go or save mixing for the end?
💡 Example: "Do you mix as you go or save mixing for the end?"
Favorite inspiration: nature sounds or city noise?
💡 Example: "Favorite inspiration: nature sounds or city noise?"
Record vocals yourself or hire a vocalist?
💡 Example: "Record vocals yourself or hire a vocalist?"
Do you share works in progress or only finished tracks?
💡 Example: "Do you share works in progress or only finished tracks?"
Favorite DAW view: session or arrangement?
💡 Example: "Favorite DAW view: session or arrangement?"
Mix in headphones or speakers late at night?
💡 Example: "Mix in headphones or speakers late at night?"
Do you prefer to quantize or keep your playing human?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer to quantize or keep your playing human?"
Basslines: synth or live bass?
💡 Example: "Basslines: synth or live bass?"
Produce with coffee or tea by your side?
💡 Example: "Produce with coffee or tea by your side?"
Do you prefer to record in one take or layer parts?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer to record in one take or layer parts?"
Acoustic drums or drum machines?
💡 Example: "Acoustic drums or drum machines?"
Do you back up projects to the cloud or an external drive?
💡 Example: "Do you back up projects to the cloud or an external drive?"
Vocals with effects or clean and natural?
💡 Example: "Vocals with effects or clean and natural?"
Do you prefer to work fast or take your time crafting details?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer to work fast or take your time crafting details?"
Do you focus on melody or rhythm first when writing?
💡 Example: "Do you focus on melody or rhythm first when writing?"
Minimalist mixes or wall of sound?
💡 Example: "Minimalist mixes or wall of sound?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your favorite prompt into your community platform of choice. Post during peak activity times to maximize visibility, and consider tagging or mentioning active members to kickstart replies. Encourage members to elaborate on their choices for deeper conversation. Rotate topics weekly or mix in with other post types for variety.
On all platforms, keep prompts visually clear by using line breaks or emojis to separate options. Schedule posts for times when your community is most active. Pin popular This or That threads for ongoing engagement, and use polls or story features where available to boost participation.
To craft engaging This or That prompts, reference industry favorites and polarizing choices, such as 'Ableton Live vs FL Studio' or 'Analog synths vs VST synths.' Highlighting well-known DAWs, effects plugins, or hardware (e.g., 'Shure SM7B vs Rode NT1' for microphones) sparks debate and draws on members’ hands-on experience.
Balancing both workflow and tools is effective for engagement. Workflow scenarios such as 'mixing in headphones vs monitors' resonate with producers facing space or budget constraints, while creative tool comparisons (e.g., 'sampling vs synthesis') encourage discussions about production style. Rotate between these categories to maintain variety and relevance.
Controversial questions can drive participation but should be framed respectfully. Encourage members to share reasons behind their preferences and consider adding a disclaimer about subjective taste. For example, with 'quantized drums vs humanized grooves,' invite discussion on genre or workflow context to keep the conversation constructive.
Absolutely! This or That is ideal for gauging opinions on new tech trends. When referencing topics like 'AI mastering vs traditional mastering,' briefly explain each option and invite firsthand experiences. This educates less-informed members and prompts thoughtful discussion about innovation in music production.
Yes, target various subgroups by alternating question focus. For beatmakers, ask 'sample packs vs crate digging;' for singer-songwriters, try 'writing lyrics first vs composing music first.' This acknowledges the diverse workflows in your community and boosts engagement across skill sets and musical roles.
Pose scenario-based questions that reflect real producer dilemmas, for example: 'Do you prefer fixing mistakes in the mix or re-recording the part?' This approach sparks practical advice sharing and reveals common pain points, making your community a valuable resource for problem-solving.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks