Finding it hard to spark fresh conversations in your music production community? Hypothetical scenarios are a proven way to inspire creativity, invite playful debate, and get even shy members to join in. These ready-to-use templates give you everything you need to ignite imagination and drive engagement.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios tap into the natural curiosity and creativity of music producers, inviting members to imagine new possibilities without fear of being wrong. By asking what-if questions, you create a low-pressure environment where all ideas are welcome, whether they are serious, funny, or totally outlandish. This encourages members of all involvement levels to participate, since there is no single correct answer and every response adds value.
Additionally, scenario prompts help members think outside of their usual workflow or style, fostering creative growth and cross-pollination of ideas. These open-ended questions not only boost engagement but also build a sense of community as members bond over shared dreams, dilemmas, and imaginative thinking.
What if you could collaborate with any artist, living or dead, on a single track? Who would you pick and why?
💡 Example: "I would team up with Prince for his funky grooves! What about you?"
Imagine your studio gear all vanished overnight except one piece. Which do you save and how would you adapt?
💡 Example: "I would save my laptop and find creative ways to work with just software!"
If you could master any music production skill instantly, which would you choose?
💡 Example: "Mixing vocals perfectly! Anyone else?"
Suppose you had to produce an album using only sounds recorded in your kitchen. How would you make it work?
💡 Example: "I'd use pots and pans as percussion. How about you?"
What if you woke up tomorrow and all music genres were banned except one? Which would you hope survived?
💡 Example: "I hope electronic stays! Which genre could you not live without?"
Imagine you are hired to score the soundtrack for your favorite movie. What musical style would you use?
💡 Example: "I would use synthwave for Blade Runner. How would you approach it?"
If you could invent one new plugin or piece of gear, what would it do?
💡 Example: "A plugin that turns humming into MIDI. What would you create?"
Suppose you had to produce a chart-topping song in just 2 hours. What is your strategy?
💡 Example: "I would start with a catchy hook. Who else has a plan?"
What if you could swap DAWs with another member for a week? Which DAW would you want to try?
💡 Example: "I would try Logic Pro. Anyone want to switch with me?"
Imagine you could only use vocal samples for your next track. How would you approach the arrangement?
💡 Example: "I would layer harmonies and chop up phrases. How would you do it?"
If aliens landed and asked you to represent Earth with one of your tracks, which would you choose?
💡 Example: "My ambient piece 'Starlight.' What would you pick?"
Suppose you could only use analog gear for a year. How would it change your process?
💡 Example: "I would spend more time on sound design."
What if you could turn any household object into an instrument? What would you choose and how would you use it?
💡 Example: "I would use a blender as a bass synth. Any other ideas?"
Imagine you could travel back to any decade to produce music. Where would you go and why?
💡 Example: "I would go to the 80s for the synths! What about you?"
If you had to create a hit song using only free plugins, what would be your go-to tools?
💡 Example: "I would use Vital and TDR Nova. What are your picks?"
Suppose you could only use one chord progression for your next five tracks. Which would you pick?
💡 Example: "I would choose I-V-vi-IV."
What if every track you made had to include an unexpected sound effect? What would you choose?
💡 Example: "Duck quack in every song."
Imagine you are only allowed three plugins for all your mixes. Which do you pick?
💡 Example: "EQ, compressor, and reverb. What are your essentials?"
If you could release a track under any famous producer's name, whose would you pick?
💡 Example: "Deadmau5 for the recognition."
Suppose you had to produce a song for a video game. What genre or vibe would you choose?
💡 Example: "Chiptune for a retro game. What about you?"
What if you could only use samples you recorded yourself for a year? How would you start building your library?
💡 Example: "I would start with outdoor sounds. Any other ideas?"
Imagine you had to create a remix of any classic song. Which would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "I would remix Billie Jean for its iconic groove. What is your pick?"
If you could erase one mixing mistake from your past, what would it be?
💡 Example: "Over-compressing vocals on my debut EP."
Suppose you could host a masterclass with any legendary producer. Who would you invite?
💡 Example: "Quincy Jones! Who would you pick?"
What if your DAW suddenly doubled in speed overnight? How would that change your creative process?
💡 Example: "I would get more ideas down before losing inspiration."
Imagine you could swap your studio location with anyone in the world. Where would you go?
💡 Example: "Tokyo for the city energy! What about you?"
If you could bring one extinct instrument back into modern music, what would it be?
💡 Example: "The glass harmonica! Any other suggestions?"
Suppose you had to teach music production to a total beginner using only three lessons. What would you cover?
💡 Example: "I would teach rhythm, synth basics, and mixing. What would you pick?"
What if you could only produce music in major keys for a year? How would you keep your sound interesting?
💡 Example: "I would use unique rhythms and textures."
Imagine you had unlimited budget for your next project. What would you invest in first?
💡 Example: "A world-class mixing desk! How about you?"
If you could instantly learn any instrument for your productions, which would you pick?
💡 Example: "Saxophone! Anyone else?"
Suppose you had to produce a soundtrack for a silent film. What modern twist would you add?
💡 Example: "I would add electronic beats. What would you do?"
What if you could only mix in mono for a year? How would it affect your approach?
💡 Example: "I'd focus on frequency balance."
Imagine you could choose one piece of studio advice to pass on to all new producers. What would it be?
💡 Example: "Finish tracks, not just loops! What is your tip?"
If you could only listen to your own music for a month, how would you feel?
💡 Example: "I would get bored quickly."
Suppose you could swap lives with a famous producer for one week. Who would you pick?
💡 Example: "Rick Rubin for his creative process. Who would you choose?"
What if you could host a festival with any lineup? Who are your headliners?
💡 Example: "Daft Punk, Aphex Twin, and Bjork! What is your dream lineup?"
Imagine you could only use percussion from found objects. What would you use for your beats?
💡 Example: "Water bottles and keys for shakers! What about you?"
If you could remix the theme song of any TV show, which would you pick?
💡 Example: "Stranger Things as a lo-fi track. What would you remix?"
Suppose you had to produce a song in a genre you have never tried before. Which would you choose?
💡 Example: "Bluegrass! Anyone else up for the challenge?"
What if your favorite plugin suddenly stopped working? How would you adapt?
💡 Example: "I would look for a creative workaround."
Imagine you could only use a smartphone to produce your next track. What app would you use?
💡 Example: "GarageBand app! Anyone tried it?"
Post these hypothetical scenarios as regular conversation starters or during themed engagement days. Encourage members to reply in the thread, share their unique perspectives, or even riff off each other's answers. For even more interaction, ask members to tag a friend or vote on their favorite ideas. Rotate between serious, technical, and playful scenarios to keep things fresh and appeal to a range of personalities.
These templates are optimized for use across all platforms. On forums and Facebook groups, post as standalone threads and encourage discussion. On Discord or Slack, use as channel prompts or icebreakers. For Instagram or Twitter, pair with a relevant image or poll to boost visibility. On any platform, follow up with shoutouts to thoughtful replies to keep momentum going.
To encourage lively discussions, pose scenarios that pit analog and digital methods against each other, such as 'If you could only record your next album using vintage hardware or the latest plugins, which would you choose and why?' This taps into strong opinions within the production community and invites members to share their unique approaches, gear preferences, and workflow philosophies.
Frame scenarios around legendary producer matchups, asking members to imagine the resulting sound, workflow challenges, or genre crossovers. For example, 'If Quincy Jones and Rick Rubin co-produced a modern hip-hop album, what techniques from each producer would dominate the project?' This allows for deep dives into production styles, signature sounds, and industry history.
Use imaginative and playful scenarios, such as 'Imagine your favorite DAW suddenly lost its top three features—how would you adapt your workflow?' This encourages thoughtful reflection on tool dependencies and adaptability without directly inciting a 'DAW wars' debate, keeping the discussion constructive and friendly.
Create inclusive prompts like 'If you could only use three pieces of gear (hardware or software) to produce a chart-topping track, what would you pick and why?' This invites participants with varying setups and budgets to contribute, fostering a sense of shared challenge regardless of experience level.
Pose scenarios such as 'If you had to mix a track for a genre you’ve never worked with before and could only use stock plugins, what would your strategy be?' This engages members in sharing technical knowledge, creative problem-solving, and personal experiences with mixing and mastering under constraints relevant to real-world production.
Introduce scenarios with educational intent, like 'You’ve built your track around a killer sample, but the clearance falls through just before release—what’s your backup plan?' This sparks conversation about legal challenges in music production, encourages members to share resources, and helps educate the community on best practices for sample use and copyright compliance.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks