Need help sparking fresh conversations in your music community? Hypothetical Scenario templates invite members to imagine, create, and share, unlocking new engagement and playful debate. Try these ready-made prompts to inspire creativity and bring your group to life.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios tap into members' natural curiosity and love for imagination. By asking 'what if' questions, you create a safe space for speculation and creativity, which helps even shy members feel comfortable sharing their thoughts. This content type encourages diverse opinions and playful debate, driving richer discussions.
These prompts are especially effective in the music industry because they allow fans, creators, and enthusiasts to explore alternative realities, dream collaborations, and unexpected outcomes. Scenarios can be lighthearted or thought-provoking, making them accessible for all community types and fostering a sense of belonging through shared creativity.
If you could attend any concert in history, which would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "If you could attend any concert in history, which would you choose and why? Example: Queen at Live Aid because of the energy."
Imagine your favorite band swaps genres for a day. What would their new sound be like?
💡 Example: "Imagine your favorite band swaps genres for a day. What would their new sound be like? Example: Metallica playing jazz."
What if you could collaborate with any artist, living or dead? Who would you pick?
💡 Example: "What if you could collaborate with any artist, living or dead? Who would you pick? Example: Collaborating with Prince."
Suppose music could only be played in one instrument from now on. Which would you choose?
💡 Example: "Suppose music could only be played in one instrument from now on. Which would you choose? Example: Piano."
If you woke up as a famous musician for 24 hours, who would it be and what would you do?
💡 Example: "If you woke up as a famous musician for 24 hours, who would it be and what would you do? Example: Taylor Swift, writing new songs."
Imagine a world where music did not exist. How would your life be different?
💡 Example: "Imagine a world where music did not exist. How would your life be different? Example: My days would feel empty and less inspiring."
What if your favorite song was turned into a movie? What would the plot be?
💡 Example: "What if your favorite song was turned into a movie? What would the plot be? Example: 'Bohemian Rhapsody' as a mystery drama."
If every city had its own official theme song, what would your city's be?
💡 Example: "If every city had its own official theme song, what would your city's be? Example: 'Empire State of Mind' for New York."
Imagine you can only listen to one genre for a year. Which genre do you pick?
💡 Example: "Imagine you can only listen to one genre for a year. Which genre do you pick? Example: Indie rock."
What if you could time travel to witness the recording of any album? Which album?
💡 Example: "What if you could time travel to witness the recording of any album? Which album? Example: The Beatles' 'Abbey Road.'"
Suppose all lyrics vanished and only instrumentals remained. Would you still enjoy music?
💡 Example: "Suppose all lyrics vanished and only instrumentals remained. Would you still enjoy music? Example: Yes, I love instrumentals."
If you could invent a new musical instrument, what would it sound like?
💡 Example: "If you could invent a new musical instrument, what would it sound like? Example: A guitar-flute hybrid."
Imagine your life had a soundtrack. Which three songs would be on it?
💡 Example: "Imagine your life had a soundtrack. Which three songs would be on it? Example: 'Happy,' 'Fix You,' 'Here Comes the Sun.'"
What if you were a music producer for a day? Which artist would you work with?
💡 Example: "What if you were a music producer for a day? Which artist would you work with? Example: Billie Eilish."
Suppose every song you hear becomes stuck in your head forever. Which song would you pick?
💡 Example: "Suppose every song you hear becomes stuck in your head forever. Which song would you pick? Example: 'Imagine.'"
If you could remix any classic hit, which would you choose and how would you change it?
💡 Example: "If you could remix any classic hit, which would you choose and how would you change it? Example: Add EDM beats to 'Respect.'"
Imagine you could bring back one retired artist for a world tour. Who gets the comeback?
💡 Example: "Imagine you could bring back one retired artist for a world tour. Who gets the comeback? Example: Daft Punk."
What if all music videos were made in animation style? Which song would look coolest?
💡 Example: "What if all music videos were made in animation style? Which song would look coolest? Example: 'Bad Guy.'"
Suppose you can swap the lead singer of any band with another. Which swap would you make?
💡 Example: "Suppose you can swap the lead singer of any band with another. Which swap would you make? Example: Adele with Foo Fighters."
If you could erase one song from history, which would it be and why?
💡 Example: "If you could erase one song from history, which would it be and why? Example: 'Baby Shark' because it is too catchy."
Imagine a festival where you create the perfect lineup. Who are your headliners?
💡 Example: "Imagine a festival where you create the perfect lineup. Who are your headliners? Example: BTS, Beyonce, The Killers."
What if every time you entered a room, a song played as your theme? Which song?
💡 Example: "What if every time you entered a room, a song played as your theme? Which song? Example: 'Eye of the Tiger.'"
Suppose music streaming was banned and only vinyls remained. How would you listen?
💡 Example: "Suppose music streaming was banned and only vinyls remained. How would you listen? Example: Buy a vintage turntable."
If you could give any musician superpowers, who and what powers would you choose?
💡 Example: "If you could give any musician superpowers, who and what powers would you choose? Example: Lizzo with teleportation."
Imagine you are tasked with writing a national anthem. What style or message would you pick?
💡 Example: "Imagine you are tasked with writing a national anthem. What style or message would you pick? Example: Uplifting pop with unity theme."
What if every musician had to wear costumes like Daft Punk? Who would have the best outfit?
💡 Example: "What if every musician had to wear costumes like Daft Punk? Who would have the best outfit? Example: Lady Gaga."
Suppose your favorite song was banned for a year. What would you listen to instead?
💡 Example: "Suppose your favorite song was banned for a year. What would you listen to instead? Example: Second favorite song."
If you could teach any musician from history about modern music tech, who would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you could teach any musician from history about modern music tech, who would you pick? Example: Beethoven."
Imagine your playlist could be heard by everyone in the world for one hour. What would you play?
💡 Example: "Imagine your playlist could be heard by everyone in the world for one hour. What would you play? Example: Songs of peace."
What if you could only go to one more live show in your life? Which artist or band?
💡 Example: "What if you could only go to one more live show in your life? Which artist or band? Example: Coldplay."
Suppose you are in charge of creating a music awards show. What new award would you add?
💡 Example: "Suppose you are in charge of creating a music awards show. What new award would you add? Example: Best Virtual Performance."
If every song had to be performed as a duet, which two artists would you pair up?
💡 Example: "If every song had to be performed as a duet, which two artists would you pair up? Example: Billie Eilish and Bruno Mars."
Imagine music was only allowed during certain hours of the day. How would you structure your listening?
💡 Example: "Imagine music was only allowed during certain hours of the day. How would you structure your listening? Example: Morning and evening."
What if you could assign a musical genre to every day of the week? What would your schedule look like?
💡 Example: "What if you could assign a musical genre to every day of the week? What would your schedule look like? Example: Jazz Monday, Rock Friday."
Suppose you could only use lyrics from one artist for all your social posts. Whose lyrics?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could only use lyrics from one artist for all your social posts. Whose lyrics? Example: Taylor Swift."
If you could turn any book or movie into a concept album, which would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you could turn any book or movie into a concept album, which would you pick? Example: 'Harry Potter.'"
Imagine you are curating a playlist for an alien visitor. Which songs would you include?
💡 Example: "Imagine you are curating a playlist for an alien visitor. Which songs would you include? Example: 'Here Comes the Sun.'"
What if you could experience any music festival from the front row? Which one?
💡 Example: "What if you could experience any music festival from the front row? Which one? Example: Glastonbury."
Suppose you could bring a fictional character to life as a musician. Who and what would they play?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could bring a fictional character to life as a musician. Who and what would they play? Example: Darth Vader on drums."
If you could make one music trend disappear forever, which would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could make one music trend disappear forever, which would it be? Example: Auto-tuned vocals."
To implement these templates, simply copy and paste a prompt into your community feed, group, or chat. Encourage members to elaborate on their answers and interact with each other's ideas. Rotate between fun and serious scenarios to keep things fresh, and consider tagging or featuring the best responses to motivate participation. Use these prompts during low-activity periods for a quick engagement boost or as regular themed posts.
On all platforms, pair each hypothetical scenario with a catchy intro or relevant image to capture attention. Use polls for simple choices, or open-ended posts for deeper discussion. Pin or highlight popular threads to sustain momentum. Adapt the prompt's length to suit platform norms (shorter for Twitter, longer for forums or Facebook Groups).
To engage both instrumentalists and vocalists, tailor your prompts to reference situations relevant to each group. For example, pose scenarios like 'If you could collaborate with any living composer or lyricist, who would it be and why?' or 'Imagine your instrument or voice develops a new superpower—how would it change your approach to performance?' This ensures inclusivity and sparks discussion across different musician roles.
Scenarios such as 'If your band suddenly lost its drummer before a major gig, how would you adapt your set?' or 'Imagine a rehearsal where two members have conflicting ideas about song arrangement—how would you resolve the creative differences?' help members discuss real-world ensemble challenges and share conflict-resolution strategies from their own experiences.
Prompt members with scenarios like 'If you could only use one plugin or effect for your next track, which would you choose and why?' or 'Imagine your DAW introduces a game-changing feature overnight—how would it impact your workflow?' These questions get producers talking shop about their favorite tools and creative processes, fostering deeper engagement.
Pose questions such as 'If you could merge two genres for your next project, which would you pick and what would the result sound like?' or 'Imagine a famous classical composer collaborating with a modern EDM artist—what might their single sound like and what challenges would they face?' This inspires creative thinking and genre-blending discussions unique to musicians.
Try prompts like 'If all your live shows had to be performed in virtual reality, how would you adapt your stage presence or setlist?' or 'Imagine wireless technology fails during a set—what backup solutions would you implement?' These scenarios spark conversations about adapting to technological advances and troubleshooting common live-performance issues.
When posting scenarios like 'If AI could write hit songs indistinguishable from human compositions, should they qualify for awards?' set clear guidelines for respectful debate. Remind members to back up opinions with experience or industry knowledge, and be ready to intervene if discussions become heated or personal. This ensures a constructive environment while tackling complex industry issues.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks