Looking for a fun way to spark more interaction in your metalworking community? 'This or That' prompts are a lighthearted way to get members talking, sharing preferences, and connecting over shared interests. Use these templates to make your group feel more lively and welcoming.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That questions work because they lower the barrier to participation. Members can join in with just a word or two, making it less intimidating for lurkers or newcomers. The playful, casual nature of these prompts invites quick responses, leading to more comments and organic conversations.
In metalworking communities, these questions help reveal personal preferences and experiences, which can foster a sense of camaraderie among members. Whether someone is a hobbyist or a seasoned pro, everyone has an opinion on tools, techniques, or favorite projects. By tapping into these shared interests, you encourage broader engagement and help build community bonds.
Welding or machining - which do you enjoy more?
💡 Example: "Welding or machining - which do you enjoy more? Tell us your favorite!"
Stainless steel or aluminum - what do you prefer working with?
💡 Example: "Stainless steel or aluminum - what do you prefer working with? Share your reason!"
Hand tools or power tools - which do you reach for first?
💡 Example: "Hand tools or power tools - which do you reach for first? Let us know!"
Morning shift or night shift - when do you feel most productive?
💡 Example: "Morning shift or night shift - when do you feel most productive?"
Lathe or mill - if you had to pick one, which would it be?
💡 Example: "Lathe or mill - if you had to pick one, which would it be? Why?"
TIG welding or MIG welding - what is your go-to?
💡 Example: "TIG welding or MIG welding - what is your go-to?"
Blueprints or sketches - how do you start a project?
💡 Example: "Blueprints or sketches - how do you start a project?"
Ear protection or safety glasses - which do you never skip?
💡 Example: "Ear protection or safety glasses - which do you never skip?"
Grinding or sanding - which finishing step do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Grinding or sanding - which finishing step do you prefer?"
Steel-toed boots or sneakers - what is your workshop footwear?
💡 Example: "Steel-toed boots or sneakers - what is your workshop footwear?"
Solo projects or team builds - which do you enjoy more?
💡 Example: "Solo projects or team builds - which do you enjoy more? Why?"
Classic designs or modern innovation - what inspires you more?
💡 Example: "Classic designs or modern innovation - what inspires you more?"
Spray paint or powder coat - which finish do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Spray paint or powder coat - which finish do you prefer?"
Sheet metal or bar stock - which material do you use most?
💡 Example: "Sheet metal or bar stock - which material do you use most?"
DIY repairs or custom builds - what are you more into?
💡 Example: "DIY repairs or custom builds - what are you more into?"
Workshop tunes - rock music or podcasts?
💡 Example: "Workshop tunes - rock music or podcasts? What is your go-to?"
Measuring tape or calipers - what is your must-have?
💡 Example: "Measuring tape or calipers - what is your must-have?"
Painted finish or raw metal - which look do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Painted finish or raw metal - which look do you prefer?"
Shortcuts or precision - which matters more in your projects?
💡 Example: "Shortcuts or precision - which matters more in your projects?"
Bench grinder or angle grinder - which do you use more?
💡 Example: "Bench grinder or angle grinder - which do you use more?"
Clean workspace or creative chaos - which describes your bench?
💡 Example: "Clean workspace or creative chaos - which describes your bench?"
Measuring twice or just eyeballing - what is your style?
💡 Example: "Measuring twice or just eyeballing - what is your style?"
Early bird or night owl - when do you hit the shop?
💡 Example: "Early bird or night owl - when do you hit the shop?"
Favorite project - functional or decorative?
💡 Example: "Favorite project - functional or decorative? Which did you enjoy more?"
Workshop snack - coffee or energy drink?
💡 Example: "Workshop snack - coffee or energy drink? What keeps you going?"
Old-school machines or new tech - what do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Old-school machines or new tech - what do you prefer?"
Quick fixes or long-term builds - which do you tackle more?
💡 Example: "Quick fixes or long-term builds - which do you tackle more?"
Favorite tool brand - US made or international?
💡 Example: "Favorite tool brand - US made or international?"
Lunch break - eat at the bench or leave the shop?
💡 Example: "Lunch break - eat at the bench or leave the shop?"
Protective gloves or bare hands - what is your comfort zone?
💡 Example: "Protective gloves or bare hands - what is your comfort zone?"
Scrap bin hero or precise planner - which are you?
💡 Example: "Scrap bin hero or precise planner - which are you?"
Drill press or cordless drill - which tool gets more use?
💡 Example: "Drill press or cordless drill - which tool gets more use?"
Learning - YouTube videos or books?
💡 Example: "Learning - YouTube videos or books? How do you prefer to learn?"
Wire brush or flap disc - what is your cleaning tool of choice?
💡 Example: "Wire brush or flap disc - what is your cleaning tool of choice?"
Project start - plan first or dive right in?
💡 Example: "Project start - plan first or dive right in? What is your approach?"
Metal art or practical fabrication - what do you like more?
💡 Example: "Metal art or practical fabrication - what do you like more?"
Workshop lighting - bright white or warm yellow?
💡 Example: "Workshop lighting - bright white or warm yellow?"
Weekend warrior or full-time pro - which are you?
💡 Example: "Weekend warrior or full-time pro - which are you?"
Favorite finish - brushed or polished?
💡 Example: "Favorite finish - brushed or polished?"
Workshop pet - shop cat or shop dog?
💡 Example: "Workshop pet - shop cat or shop dog? Who is your sidekick?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste a question into your community platform of choice. Pair it with a fun intro or an inviting emoji to catch attention. Rotate topics regularly to keep things fresh and encourage different members to participate. Consider pinning a This or That thread or sharing one as a weekly feature to create a recurring engagement touchpoint.
For all platforms, keep posts concise and visually clear. Use formatting like line breaks or emojis to separate the two options. Encourage replies in comments, threads, or with quick polls where available. Adapt the template to fit your platform's style, whether it's a forum, Facebook group, Discord server, or Slack channel.
Focus on highlighting practical scenarios where each welding technique excels. Use images or videos demonstrating the differences, and ask members to share their preferred method and why. This sparks experienced-based discussions and allows hobbyists and professionals to connect over real-world applications.
Pose questions around common fabrication tasks, for example: 'For cutting 1/4" steel plate, do you prefer an angle grinder or plasma cutter?' Include context like material thickness, desired finish, and shop setup to drive meaningful debate and knowledge sharing among metalworkers.
Frame these posts as learning opportunities. Encourage members to share pros and cons rather than just picking sides. Set clear rules about respectful discourse, and prompt users to mention specific project types or materials where one method may have an advantage. This keeps the conversation constructive and educational.
Absolutely! Safety is a core concern in metalworking. Use prompts like 'Welding: heavy gauntlet gloves or TIG gloves?' and ask members to share their experiences and reasons. This both educates newer members and fosters a culture of safety awareness specific to common shop scenarios.
Target nuanced decisions faced by skilled professionals, such as 'For stainless turning: HSS or carbide inserts?' Provide context like production volume and machine type, and ask users to share their outcomes or technical tips. This encourages expert-level engagement and knowledge transfer within the community.
Create visually rich posts comparing finishes on similar workpieces, and ask members about their experiences with durability, cost, and aesthetics. For example, 'For outdoor metal projects: powder coat or anodize?' This allows members to share process challenges and successes unique to metalworking applications.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks