Ever wonder how to spark lively discussions in your metalworking community? Fact or Fiction posts challenge members to separate truth from myth, fueling curiosity and conversation. Use these templates to engage your group with intriguing statements and see who really knows their metal!
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Fact or Fiction content taps into our natural curiosity and desire to test our knowledge. By presenting surprising or controversial statements, you encourage members to engage, guess, and discuss, leading to higher participation rates. This interactive format lowers the pressure to be 'right,' making even hesitant members more likely to join in.
In niche spaces like metalworking, Fact or Fiction prompts can surface both common knowledge and industry myths, giving experts a chance to share insights and newcomers a safe way to learn. The playful nature of these posts also builds community spirit and fosters a habit of regular engagement.
Fact or Fiction: Stainless steel cannot rust. What do you think?
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Stainless steel cannot rust. What do you think?"
Fact or Fiction: Welding indoors always requires a fume extractor.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Welding indoors always requires a fume extractor."
Fact or Fiction: Brass is harder than bronze.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Brass is harder than bronze."
Fact or Fiction: Quenching hot steel in water always makes it harder.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Quenching hot steel in water always makes it harder. Share your thoughts!"
Fact or Fiction: You can weld aluminum with a standard MIG welder.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: You can weld aluminum with a standard MIG welder."
Fact or Fiction: Copper conducts heat better than silver.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Copper conducts heat better than silver."
Fact or Fiction: Cast iron is impossible to weld.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Cast iron is impossible to weld. Agree or disagree?"
Fact or Fiction: Galvanized steel is safe to weld without ventilation.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Galvanized steel is safe to weld without ventilation. Thoughts?"
Fact or Fiction: Forging makes metal stronger than casting.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Forging makes metal stronger than casting."
Fact or Fiction: Only steel can be hardened by heat treatment.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Only steel can be hardened by heat treatment."
Fact or Fiction: All stainless steels are magnetic.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: All stainless steels are magnetic."
Fact or Fiction: Bronze tools were used before iron tools in history.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Bronze tools were used before iron tools in history. What do you think?"
Fact or Fiction: TIG welding produces the strongest welds.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: TIG welding produces the strongest welds. Agree or disagree?"
Fact or Fiction: Aluminum cannot be magnetized.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Aluminum cannot be magnetized."
Fact or Fiction: You should always grind away all mill scale before welding.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: You should always grind away all mill scale before welding."
Fact or Fiction: Larger anvil size always means better forging results.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Larger anvil size always means better forging results."
Fact or Fiction: Heat-treating can fix cracks in metal.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Heat-treating can fix cracks in metal."
Fact or Fiction: Only experienced welders can do overhead welding safely.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Only experienced welders can do overhead welding safely. Agree?"
Fact or Fiction: Flux core welding does not need shielding gas.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Flux core welding does not need shielding gas."
Fact or Fiction: Hot rolling always makes for stronger steel than cold rolling.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Hot rolling always makes for stronger steel than cold rolling."
Fact or Fiction: Machinists' blue is only for marking metal before cutting.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Machinists' blue is only for marking metal before cutting."
Fact or Fiction: Annealing makes metal harder.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Annealing makes metal harder."
Fact or Fiction: You can solder copper without flux.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: You can solder copper without flux."
Fact or Fiction: Only ferrous metals can be magnetized.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Only ferrous metals can be magnetized."
Fact or Fiction: Chrome plating prevents all corrosion.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Chrome plating prevents all corrosion. Is this true?"
Fact or Fiction: You should never quench red-hot glass in water.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: You should never quench red-hot glass in water."
Fact or Fiction: Hammering cold steel makes it brittle.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Hammering cold steel makes it brittle."
Fact or Fiction: You must always use ear protection when grinding metal.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: You must always use ear protection when grinding metal. Do you?"
Fact or Fiction: Aluminum is heavier than steel.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Aluminum is heavier than steel."
Fact or Fiction: Using oil instead of water for quenching always gives a softer finish.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Using oil instead of water for quenching always gives a softer finish."
Fact or Fiction: The color of a weld always indicates its quality.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: The color of a weld always indicates its quality. What do you think?"
Fact or Fiction: Only pure metals can be recycled.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Only pure metals can be recycled."
Fact or Fiction: Blacksmiths use borax as a flux.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Blacksmiths use borax as a flux."
Fact or Fiction: Galvanizing protects steel from rusting forever.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Galvanizing protects steel from rusting forever. True or false?"
Fact or Fiction: You can braze with a propane torch.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: You can braze with a propane torch."
Fact or Fiction: Titanium sparks when cut with a grinder.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Titanium sparks when cut with a grinder."
Fact or Fiction: Metal filings can cause severe skin irritation.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Metal filings can cause severe skin irritation."
Fact or Fiction: Heated copper glows blue.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Heated copper glows blue."
Fact or Fiction: Soldering and welding are basically the same process.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Soldering and welding are basically the same process. Agree or not?"
Fact or Fiction: Steel wool can catch fire from friction alone.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: Steel wool can catch fire from friction alone."
Fact or Fiction: All metals expand when heated.
💡 Example: "Fact or Fiction: All metals expand when heated."
To maximize impact, post Fact or Fiction questions at peak engagement times and encourage members to comment before revealing the answer. Pin or feature threads for ongoing participation. When possible, follow up with credible sources or short explanations to keep the learning going. Use these prompts to kick off a weekly challenge, trivia night, or themed discussion, and invite members to submit their own Fact or Fiction ideas for even greater involvement.
On all platforms, use engaging visuals or polls if available to enhance interaction. Tag relevant members or experts to weigh in. Keep statements concise and avoid technical jargon where possible for broader participation. Use hashtags or group tags to make Fact or Fiction threads easy to find and revisit.
You can create Fact or Fiction posts that highlight frequent myths, such as 'TIG welding always produces stronger joints than MIG' or 'MIG welding can’t be used on aluminum.' This sparks discussion among welders and fabricators, encourages sharing of real-world experiences, and helps clarify technical differences for both novices and professionals.
Absolutely. Use templates to present statements like 'Visible cracks are the first sign of metal fatigue' or 'All alloy steels have the same resistance to fatigue.' This promotes knowledge-sharing about failure analysis, metallurgical properties, and encourages members to share their own inspection and testing protocols.
Focus on common safety beliefs, e.g., 'Face shields alone are sufficient for all grinding operations' or 'Cut-resistant gloves guarantee full hand protection during plasma cutting.' These posts can generate important discussions about proper PPE selection, standards (like ANSI or EN388 ratings), and real-life safety incidents.
Target statements like 'All CNC machines use identical G-code syntax' or 'Optimizing toolpaths always reduces tool wear.' This engages machinists and programmers, prompting them to discuss machine-specific nuances, CAM software quirks, and share expert tips on optimizing code for different equipment.
Yes. Create Fact or Fiction prompts like 'Quenching always increases hardness in all metals' or 'Annealed steel cannot be hardened later.' These open up space for metallurgists and experienced members to provide detailed explanations, share diagrams, and recommend best practices for specific alloys.
When discussing contentious topics—like 'Anyone can use the term “Stellite” for any cobalt alloy'—be prepared to step in with references to relevant patents, trademarks, and industry standards. Encourage respectful debate, fact-checking, and cite authoritative sources (like ASM Handbooks or ISO standards) to maintain a professional and informative discussion.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks