Looking for fresh ways to spark conversation and creativity in your legal community? Hypothetical scenarios offer a fun, engaging approach that encourages members to think outside the box. Use these ready-made templates to drive participation and fuel thoughtful discussions.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios tap into the legal community's natural inclination for analysis and debate. By posing imaginative 'what if' situations, you invite members to apply their expertise in new and playful ways, sparking curiosity and deeper thinking. This approach also lowers barriers for participation, as there are no strictly right or wrong answers, making it easier for members of all experience levels to chime in.
Psychologically, these open-ended prompts activate problem-solving skills and encourage lateral thinking, which are at the core of legal practice. They also foster a sense of camaraderie and fun, as members can share creative or unexpected responses without judgment. This helps build a more vibrant and inclusive community atmosphere.
If you could create one new law, what would it be and why?
💡 Example: "If you could create one new law, what would it be and why? For example, a law requiring plain language in all contracts."
Imagine a world where lawyers are replaced by AI. How would justice change?
💡 Example: "Imagine a world where lawyers are replaced by AI. How would justice change? Would trials be faster or less fair?"
You wake up as a Supreme Court Justice for a day. What case do you choose to hear?
💡 Example: "You wake up as a Supreme Court Justice for a day. What case do you choose to hear? I would pick a big privacy rights case."
If courtroom attire had no rules, what would you wear to trial?
💡 Example: "If courtroom attire had no rules, what would you wear to trial? I would wear sneakers and a cape."
Suppose all contracts had to be written in haikus. How would you draft one?
💡 Example: "Suppose all contracts had to be written in haikus. How would you draft one? Share your best legal haiku!"
If you could argue any case in history, which would you choose?
💡 Example: "If you could argue any case in history, which would you choose? Brown v. Board of Education would be fascinating."
A client brings you a case with no precedent. What is your first step?
💡 Example: "A client brings you a case with no precedent. What is your first step? I would research similar fact patterns."
What would happen if juries were made up entirely of children?
💡 Example: "What would happen if juries were made up entirely of children? Would verdicts be unpredictable?"
If you could eliminate one legal jargon term, which would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could eliminate one legal jargon term, which would it be? I would get rid of 'heretofore.'"
Imagine every law firm had a mascot. What would yours be?
💡 Example: "Imagine every law firm had a mascot. What would yours be? Ours would be an owl."
What if all legal advice had to be given in the form of a meme?
💡 Example: "What if all legal advice had to be given in the form of a meme? Share your ideas!"
You can invite any historical figure to testify in court. Who and why?
💡 Example: "You can invite any historical figure to testify in court. Who and why? I pick Abraham Lincoln for his honesty."
If every lawyer had a superpower, what would yours be?
💡 Example: "If every lawyer had a superpower, what would yours be? I choose mind-reading."
A new law says all court decisions must rhyme. Can you give an example?
💡 Example: "A new law says all court decisions must rhyme. Can you give an example? 'The defendant must pay, starting today.'"
If you had to explain your job to an alien, where would you start?
💡 Example: "If you had to explain your job to an alien, where would you start? 'I help solve conflicts using rules.'"
What if laws were decided by public vote every year?
💡 Example: "What if laws were decided by public vote every year? Would things be more fair or chaotic?"
You can only use three words to win your case. What are they?
💡 Example: "You can only use three words to win your case. What are they? 'Justice, truth, fairness.'"
If you could swap roles with a judge for a week, what case would you want?
💡 Example: "If you could swap roles with a judge for a week, what case would you want? Maybe a landmark civil rights case."
Imagine there were no closing arguments allowed. How would trials change?
💡 Example: "Imagine there were no closing arguments allowed. How would trials change? Would juries be more confused?"
If you could rewrite any famous law, which one would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "If you could rewrite any famous law, which one would you choose and why? I would update the Copyright Act."
Suppose courtrooms had a 'pause' button. When would you use it?
💡 Example: "Suppose courtrooms had a 'pause' button. When would you use it? During surprise evidence."
A law requires all legal documents to be illustrated. Pick a document and describe your drawing.
💡 Example: "A law requires all legal documents to be illustrated. Pick a document and describe your drawing. I'd illustrate a will with a treasure map."
If you could add a subject to law school, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could add a subject to law school, what would it be? I would add negotiation skills."
What would happen if all law texts suddenly disappeared?
💡 Example: "What would happen if all law texts suddenly disappeared? Would oral tradition take over?"
You must defend a fictional character in court. Who do you pick?
💡 Example: "You must defend a fictional character in court. Who do you pick? I choose Sherlock Holmes."
All trials are now held outdoors. What changes?
💡 Example: "All trials are now held outdoors. What changes? Weather could delay proceedings."
If you could ban one legal cliché from movies, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could ban one legal cliché from movies, what would it be? I would ban 'I object!' shouted in every scene."
Imagine a world where every lawyer has a theme song. What is yours?
💡 Example: "Imagine a world where every lawyer has a theme song. What is yours? I pick 'Eye of the Tiger.'"
If you could have any mythical creature as co-counsel, who would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could have any mythical creature as co-counsel, who would it be? I would choose a unicorn for good luck."
What if lawyers were paid in barter instead of money?
💡 Example: "What if lawyers were paid in barter instead of money? What would you ask for?"
You can add one new courtroom gadget. What is it and how does it help?
💡 Example: "You can add one new courtroom gadget. What is it and how does it help? I would add a real-time fact checker."
If you had unlimited time for oral arguments, how would you use it?
💡 Example: "If you had unlimited time for oral arguments, how would you use it? I would build a thorough case."
Suppose you could change one thing about legal research. What would it be?
💡 Example: "Suppose you could change one thing about legal research. What would it be? I would make databases more user-friendly."
All legal deadlines are now twice as fast. How do you cope?
💡 Example: "All legal deadlines are now twice as fast. How do you cope? I would automate more tasks."
If you could have lunch with any judge, living or dead, who would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could have lunch with any judge, living or dead, who would it be? I pick Ruth Bader Ginsburg."
Suppose everyone in court had to communicate with emojis only. What happens?
💡 Example: "Suppose everyone in court had to communicate with emojis only. What happens? Could justice still be served?"
If you could give one piece of legal advice to your younger self, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could give one piece of legal advice to your younger self, what would it be? Network early and often."
What would trials look like if held entirely in virtual reality?
💡 Example: "What would trials look like if held entirely in virtual reality? Would jury bias be reduced?"
You must choose a new symbol for justice. What is it?
💡 Example: "You must choose a new symbol for justice. What is it? I choose a bridge."
If you could automate one part of your legal work, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could automate one part of your legal work, what would it be? I would automate document review."
Choose a scenario that fits your community's tone and current discussions. Post the template as a standalone thread or as part of a regular feature, such as 'What If Wednesdays.' Invite members to share their thoughts, and consider highlighting especially creative or thoughtful responses. You can also use these scenarios in live chats, newsletters, or as icebreakers during virtual events.
On all platforms, use clear formatting to make your hypothetical scenarios stand out. Add a question mark or bold the scenario to draw attention. Pin or feature popular threads, and monitor responses to keep the conversation positive and on-topic.
You can adapt these templates by crafting fact patterns that closely resemble recent Supreme Court rulings, encouraging members to analyze reasoning, dissenting opinions, and practical implications. This not only helps members practice applying new legal precedents but also drives engagement through current, high-stakes scenarios.
To spotlight ethical issues, design scenarios that present conflicts of interest, confidentiality breaches, or challenges with client representation. Include reference to relevant Model Rules and ask members to identify potential violations, discuss mitigation steps, and debate appropriate courses of action.
Tailor fact patterns by incorporating specific statutes, case law, and typical client situations unique to your focus area. For example, IP scenarios might involve patent infringement claims, while family law could center on custody disputes or asset division. Solicit feedback from practitioners to ensure accuracy and applicability.
Pose scenarios that hinge on ambiguous statutory language or conflicting provisions. Ask members to argue from both the plain meaning and legislative intent perspectives, and invite them to cite canons of statutory construction or relevant case law in their analyses.
Acknowledge jurisdictional differences by encouraging members to specify which state or federal circuit they're referencing. You can prompt further discussion by asking how the scenario would be resolved in different jurisdictions or by inviting comparisons across legal systems.
Absolutely. You can format scenarios in the style of bar exam essays or moot court problems, specifying issues to be spotted and legal standards to be applied. Offering structured prompts—like identifying relevant causes of action or drafting argument outlines—mirrors exam conditions and helps members develop analytical skills.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks