Looking for a quick way to spark fun conversations in your knitting community? These This or That templates make it easy to engage your members with lighthearted, on-topic choices. Say goodbye to quiet feeds and hello to lively sharing with just a simple question.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That content taps into our natural desire to express preferences and see how we compare with others. The low-pressure, playful format encourages even shy or new members to participate, since all they need to do is choose between two options. This creates a sense of belonging and helps members feel seen and involved.
In knitting communities, these prompts are especially effective because they celebrate the small joys and quirks of the craft. Whether it's picking favorite yarns or choosing between project types, this content type sparks friendly debates and shared laughter, making your group feel more connected. Plus, the simplicity means posts are quick to answer, perfect for busy crafters.
Do you prefer knitting socks or scarves? Which one would you pick?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer knitting socks or scarves? Which one would you pick? I am all about cozy socks!"
Are you team circular needles or straight needles?
💡 Example: "Are you team circular needles or straight needles? I love my circulars."
Do you enjoy knitting with bright colors or earthy tones more?
💡 Example: "Do you enjoy knitting with bright colors or earthy tones more? Earthy tones for me!"
Would you rather knit a chunky blanket or a delicate lace shawl?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit a chunky blanket or a delicate lace shawl? I am all about chunky blankets!"
Do you like working on one project at a time or juggling multiple WIPs?
💡 Example: "Do you like working on one project at a time or juggling multiple WIPs? I am a proud WIP juggler!"
Are you an early morning knitter or a late night stitcher?
💡 Example: "Are you an early morning knitter or a late night stitcher? Nights for me!"
Do you knit more for gifts or for yourself?
💡 Example: "Do you knit more for gifts or for yourself? I love gifting knits."
Are you a fan of wool or cotton yarn?
💡 Example: "Are you a fan of wool or cotton yarn? Wool all the way."
Would you rather follow a pattern or improvise as you go?
💡 Example: "Would you rather follow a pattern or improvise as you go? I love improvising!"
Is your ideal knit quick and easy or slow and challenging?
💡 Example: "Is your ideal knit quick and easy or slow and challenging? Quick and easy for me."
Do you prefer solid colors or variegated yarns?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer solid colors or variegated yarns? Variegated is my favorite."
Are you more likely to knit hats or mittens in winter?
💡 Example: "Are you more likely to knit hats or mittens in winter? Hats for me!"
Do you listen to music or watch TV while knitting?
💡 Example: "Do you listen to music or watch TV while knitting? TV shows all the way."
Would you rather knit with bamboo or metal needles?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit with bamboo or metal needles? Bamboo for me."
Are you a fan of knitting cables or lace?
💡 Example: "Are you a fan of knitting cables or lace? Cables are my jam."
Do you prefer knitting alone or with friends?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer knitting alone or with friends? I love knit nights with friends!"
Would you rather frog a mistake or leave it and move on?
💡 Example: "Would you rather frog a mistake or leave it and move on? I'll frog every time."
Do you love knitting sweaters or shawls more?
💡 Example: "Do you love knitting sweaters or shawls more? Sweaters for me."
Are you all about chunky yarns or fine lace yarns?
💡 Example: "Are you all about chunky yarns or fine lace yarns? Chunky for sure."
Would you rather knit in public or keep it private?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit in public or keep it private? I love public knitting!"
Are you a fan of top-down or bottom-up sweater patterns?
💡 Example: "Are you a fan of top-down or bottom-up sweater patterns? Top-down for me."
Do you like knitting for holidays or anytime?
💡 Example: "Do you like knitting for holidays or anytime? Holidays are my excuse to knit!"
Would you rather join a knit-along or knit solo?
💡 Example: "Would you rather join a knit-along or knit solo? Knit-alongs are so fun!"
Do you finish projects quickly or savor them slowly?
💡 Example: "Do you finish projects quickly or savor them slowly? I savor every stitch."
Are you drawn to bold patterns or simple classics?
💡 Example: "Are you drawn to bold patterns or simple classics? Simple classics for me."
Would you rather knit with friends in person or join a virtual meetup?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit with friends in person or join a virtual meetup? In person all the way!"
Do you prefer making baby knits or adult-sized projects?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer making baby knits or adult-sized projects? Baby knits are so cute!"
Are you more of a sweater knitter or an accessory maker?
💡 Example: "Are you more of a sweater knitter or an accessory maker? Sweaters for me."
Do you prefer hand-dyed yarns or commercial brands?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer hand-dyed yarns or commercial brands? Hand-dyed is my favorite."
Would you rather knit on rainy days or sunny afternoons?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit on rainy days or sunny afternoons? Rainy days for me."
Are you a fan of textured stitches or smooth stockinette?
💡 Example: "Are you a fan of textured stitches or smooth stockinette? Textured for sure!"
Do you block your knits every time or only sometimes?
💡 Example: "Do you block your knits every time or only sometimes? Only sometimes for me."
Would you rather knit a mystery project or know exactly what you are making?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit a mystery project or know exactly what you are making? Mystery is more fun!"
Are you more likely to knit while traveling or at home?
💡 Example: "Are you more likely to knit while traveling or at home? Always at home."
Do you prefer following video tutorials or written patterns?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer following video tutorials or written patterns? Video all the way!"
Would you rather knit for relaxation or accomplishment?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit for relaxation or accomplishment? Relaxation is my goal."
Are you more likely to buy yarn in person or online?
💡 Example: "Are you more likely to buy yarn in person or online? In person for sure."
Do you like knitting from stash or buying new yarn for each project?
💡 Example: "Do you like knitting from stash or buying new yarn for each project? I love using my stash."
Would you rather knit for pets or for people?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit for pets or for people? Pet knits are too cute."
Are you a fan of knitting charts or written instructions?
💡 Example: "Are you a fan of knitting charts or written instructions? Charts for me."
Do you prefer short rows or simple stripes in your projects?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer short rows or simple stripes in your projects? Stripes are my favorite."
Would you rather knit all year round or just in the colder months?
💡 Example: "Would you rather knit all year round or just in the colder months? All year round!"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your favorite prompt into your community platform. Post them as regular threads, stories, or polls depending on what your platform supports. Encourage members to respond in the comments or vote, and consider sharing your own answer to kick things off. Rotate through different prompts weekly or tie them to seasons, holidays, or trending projects for maximum relevance and engagement.
These templates are designed for all platforms. On forums or Facebook Groups, use them as standalone posts or in weekly threads. On Instagram, try using Stories with poll stickers for instant interaction. In chat-based spaces like Discord, share them as quick prompts and encourage real-time banter. Always adapt your posting format to what feels most natural for your community.
Both comparison types work well, but posts about yarn fibers like 'merino wool vs. acrylic' tend to spark more technical discussions about properties, allergies, and use cases. Project comparisons such as 'socks vs. scarves' engage knitters at various skill levels and often elicit pattern recommendations. Rotate between fiber-based and project-based This or That prompts to keep all knowledge levels engaged.
These templates are ideal for tackling classic knitting debates. Use scenarios such as 'top-down vs. bottom-up' or 'circular vs. flat needles' to encourage members to share their experiences and tips. This not only fosters community learning but also helps newer knitters see the pros and cons of different techniques through real user stories.
It depends on your community’s interests. Technical finishing technique comparisons like 'mattress stitch vs. whip stitch' are great for advanced knitters, while 'Fair Isle vs. Intarsia' can appeal to both intermediate and experienced members interested in colorwork. Review past engagement on similar topics to decide, or alternate between techniques and styles for balanced participation.
Absolutely! Seasonal This or That prompts are highly engaging for knitting communities because project planning often aligns with upcoming weather. Questions like 'cotton vs. wool for summer projects' or 'holiday gift knitting vs. personal projects' generate timely conversation and help members connect over shared seasonal challenges.
After asking a This or That question about stitch patterns, invite members to post photos of completed projects using their chosen stitch or to link to their favorite patterns. You can add a prompt in your post, such as, 'Vote for your favorite and show us a photo of your latest seed or garter stitch project!' This increases visual engagement and helps inspire others.
Knitting communities can be passionate about topics like 'seamed vs. seamless construction.' To keep discussions positive, remind members that all preferences are valid, and encourage them to share why a method works for them personally. Moderators can also highlight helpful, respectful comments and steer the conversation back to learning and sharing, rather than criticizing.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks