Running out of fresh ways to spark conversations in your hunting community? These This or That templates make it easy to encourage interaction and get members sharing their preferences. Use these playful prompts to break the ice and keep your group active.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That prompts are effective because they lower the barrier to participation. The simple format invites quick decisions, making it easy for even shy or busy members to join in. By offering two lighthearted choices, you create a relaxed environment where no answer is wrong.
In the context of hunting, these prompts tap into shared interests and experiences. Members get to compare their habits, gear, or favorite locations and see how they stack up with peers. This builds camaraderie, reveals common ground, and often leads to deeper conversations as members explain their choices or share stories.
Tree stand or ground blind, which do you prefer for deer hunting?
💡 Example: "Tree stand or ground blind, which do you prefer for deer hunting?"
Bow hunting or rifle hunting - which gets your vote?
💡 Example: "Bow hunting or rifle hunting - which gets your vote?"
Early morning hunts or late afternoon hunts?
💡 Example: "Early morning hunts or late afternoon hunts?"
Camo or blaze orange - what is your go-to?
💡 Example: "Camo or blaze orange - what is your go-to?"
Solo hunts or group hunts - which do you enjoy more?
💡 Example: "Solo hunts or group hunts - which do you enjoy more?"
Elk or whitetail - which would you rather hunt this season?
💡 Example: "Elk or whitetail - which would you rather hunt this season?"
Hunting boots: rubber or leather?
💡 Example: "Hunting boots: rubber or leather?"
Public land or private land - where do you hunt more?
💡 Example: "Public land or private land - where do you hunt more?"
Favorite hunting snack: jerky or trail mix?
💡 Example: "Favorite hunting snack: jerky or trail mix?"
Would you rather track or call in your game?
💡 Example: "Would you rather track or call in your game?"
Sit in silence or listen to music while waiting?
💡 Example: "Sit in silence or listen to music while waiting?"
Hunt in snow or hunt in rain?
💡 Example: "Hunt in snow or hunt in rain?"
Duck calls: wood or acrylic?
💡 Example: "Duck calls: wood or acrylic?"
Field dressing or processing at home?
💡 Example: "Field dressing or processing at home?"
Turkey hunting: sit and wait or run and gun?
💡 Example: "Turkey hunting: sit and wait or run and gun?"
ATV or hiking to your stand?
💡 Example: "ATV or hiking to your stand?"
Would you rather hunt a new spot or a favorite old one?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt a new spot or a favorite old one?"
Blind snacks: sweet or salty?
💡 Example: "Blind snacks: sweet or salty?"
Favorite big game: bear or moose?
💡 Example: "Favorite big game: bear or moose?"
Would you rather hunt upland birds or waterfowl?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt upland birds or waterfowl?"
Do you prefer hunting with a dog or without?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer hunting with a dog or without?"
Would you rather pack light or bring extra gear?
💡 Example: "Would you rather pack light or bring extra gear?"
Favorite camo: digital or woodland?
💡 Example: "Favorite camo: digital or woodland?"
Would you rather hunt locally or travel far?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt locally or travel far?"
Favorite hunting season: fall or spring?
💡 Example: "Favorite hunting season: fall or spring?"
Would you rather hunt for meat or for the challenge?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt for meat or for the challenge?"
Do you prefer a short hunt or an all-day outing?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer a short hunt or an all-day outing?"
Would you rather hunt in the mountains or in the woods?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt in the mountains or in the woods?"
Favorite scent control: sprays or natural cover?
💡 Example: "Favorite scent control: sprays or natural cover?"
Would you rather hunt in hot or cold weather?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt in hot or cold weather?"
Shed hunting or scouting for sign - which is more fun?
💡 Example: "Shed hunting or scouting for sign - which is more fun?"
Would you rather spot and stalk or sit and wait?
💡 Example: "Would you rather spot and stalk or sit and wait?"
Favorite hunting memory: first harvest or biggest harvest?
💡 Example: "Favorite hunting memory: first harvest or biggest harvest?"
Would you rather use trail cameras or keep it old school?
💡 Example: "Would you rather use trail cameras or keep it old school?"
Do you prefer hunting from a blind or spot and stalk?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer hunting from a blind or spot and stalk?"
Would you rather hunt with family or friends?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt with family or friends?"
Favorite wild game meat: venison or duck?
💡 Example: "Favorite wild game meat: venison or duck?"
Would you rather hunt in thick cover or open fields?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt in thick cover or open fields?"
Do you prefer classic camo or high-tech gear?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer classic camo or high-tech gear?"
Would you rather cook wild game over a fire or at home?
💡 Example: "Would you rather cook wild game over a fire or at home?"
Select a template that fits your group's vibe and post it as a question or poll. Encourage members to vote, comment, or elaborate on their pick. Mix up the timing—try a weekly This or That post or drop one in whenever conversation slows. You can also use these as icebreakers for new members or during seasonal lulls in activity.
On all platforms, use visuals like polls or images to boost participation. Pair your prompt with a relevant photo or emoji for added appeal. Pin your This or That post during slow periods or at the start of the week to maximize visibility.
Absolutely! Posts comparing specific firearm types—like bolt-action vs. lever-action rifles—spark great discussions among seasoned hunters and newcomers alike. Just make sure to provide some context or basic pros and cons for each choice, so less experienced members can join the conversation as well. Incorporating photos or brief descriptions can also help clarify the differences.
While public vs. private land hunting is a hot topic, it can definitely generate lively debate and engagement. However, be mindful of your community's tone and encourage respectful discussion. Consider framing the question around personal experiences (e.g., 'Which do you prefer for deer season: public land or private land?') and ask members to share reasons and stories, rather than making it a divisive poll.
Ethical topics such as fair chase versus baiting are highly relevant in hunting circles. Use This or That templates to facilitate thoughtful conversations by presenting both sides neutrally and encouraging members to share their reasoning and local regulations. Remind participants to respect differing opinions, as ethical norms can vary regionally.
Yes, tailoring your This or That prompts to coincide with hunting seasons (e.g., 'Archery vs. Shotgun for spring turkey?') keeps content timely and relevant. This encourages members to share their preparations, tips, and recent field experiences, making your community feel current and engaged with the real-world hunting calendar.
Both types work well, but mixing them up can broaden participation. Gear comparisons (such as Realtree vs. Mossy Oak camo) appeal to those interested in equipment, while technique-based prompts (like spot and stalk vs. stand hunting) engage members who love discussing strategy. Rotating topics ensures all members find something they relate to.
Create prompts that celebrate diverse approaches (e.g., 'Longbow vs. Crossbow for whitetail?'), and invite members to share why they prefer one method over another. Highlighting the unique challenges and rewards of each method fosters respect across skillsets and encourages sharing of tips and stories, making everyone feel welcome no matter their hunting style.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks