Frustrated with sparking lively conversations in your horse training community? Engaging members with creative Would You Rather questions is an easy way to drive participation and bring some fun to your feed. Use these ready-to-post templates to inspire creative thinking and get everyone talking.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions tap into our natural curiosity and the joy of imagining different possibilities. These prompts are low-pressure and playful, making them easy for all members to answer, regardless of expertise or experience. This inclusivity creates a welcoming environment and encourages even quieter members to share their thoughts.
For horse training communities, these scenarios can be both entertaining and thought-provoking, prompting members to reflect on their preferences, experiences, and goals. When participants explain their choices, it opens the door to deeper discussions, shared stories, and learning opportunities. The playful nature of Would You Rather posts helps build community bonds, lowers barriers to participation, and keeps engagement high.
Would you rather train a spirited young colt or a wise old mare? Tell us why.
💡 Example: "I would rather train a spirited colt because I love the challenge and energy they bring."
Would you rather have unlimited time or unlimited money for horse training?
💡 Example: "Unlimited time, because good training takes patience!"
Would you rather ride bareback every day or always use a saddle?
💡 Example: "Always saddle for me, it feels more secure on long rides."
Would you rather teach a horse to jump or to dance dressage?
💡 Example: "Dressage! I love the elegance and precision involved."
Would you rather train outdoors in any weather or always indoors?
💡 Example: "Outdoors, even in the rain. Horses need to be adaptable."
Would you rather work with a nervous horse or a stubborn one? Why?
💡 Example: "Nervous, because I enjoy building trust and confidence."
Would you rather spend a month at a top clinic or shadow a famous trainer for a week?
💡 Example: "Shadow a famous trainer for sure, hands-on learning is my style."
Would you rather have a horse with perfect ground manners or perfect under saddle skills?
💡 Example: "Ground manners, makes everything else so much safer and easier."
Would you rather only train in the early morning or late at night?
💡 Example: "Early morning, I like to start my day with horses."
Would you rather teach a horse to load calmly or to stand perfectly for the farrier?
💡 Example: "Load calmly, as trailering is always a challenge for me."
Would you rather train a miniature horse or a draft horse?
💡 Example: "Draft horse, I love their gentle giants' personalities."
Would you rather compete in a local show or ride just for fun with friends?
💡 Example: "Fun rides with friends, every time!"
Would you rather use positive reinforcement only or traditional training methods?
💡 Example: "Positive reinforcement, it builds a better bond."
Would you rather ride through the mountains or along the beach?
💡 Example: "Mountains, I love the views and the challenge."
Would you rather train a horse with no prior handling or one with some bad habits?
💡 Example: "No prior handling, it is a clean slate to start with."
Would you rather spend an hour grooming or an hour doing groundwork?
💡 Example: "Grooming, I find it relaxing and great for bonding."
Would you rather have the perfect horse trailer or the perfect tack room?
💡 Example: "Tack room, organization is everything!"
Would you rather teach a horse to bow or to fetch an object?
💡 Example: "Fetch, I think that would be adorable."
Would you rather work with horses in a group lesson or one-on-one?
💡 Example: "One-on-one, more focused attention for both me and the horse."
Would you rather have a horse that talks or one that reads your mind?
💡 Example: "Reads my mind! That would make training so easy."
Would you rather train with music playing or in complete silence?
💡 Example: "Music, it helps me relax and focus."
Would you rather teach a horse to open a gate or to pick up a hat?
💡 Example: "Open a gate, that is so useful on the farm."
Would you rather always ride in boots or barefoot?
💡 Example: "Boots, more protection for me and my horse."
Would you rather have your horse win a big competition or be your best friend?
💡 Example: "Best friend, the bond is what matters most."
Would you rather learn a new discipline or master your current one?
💡 Example: "Master my current one, I love perfecting my skills."
Would you rather ride a horse with endless stamina or perfect manners?
💡 Example: "Perfect manners, safety first."
Would you rather teach your horse a flying lead change or a piaffe?
💡 Example: "Flying lead change, I think it is so impressive."
Would you rather have your horse always come when called or stand still wherever you leave them?
💡 Example: "Come when called, saves me so much time in the pasture."
Would you rather spend a day at a famous racetrack or a world-class dressage arena?
💡 Example: "Dressage arena, I love the atmosphere."
Would you rather always have perfect weather for training or access to the world's best trainers?
💡 Example: "Best trainers, learning is everything."
Would you rather teach a horse to sidepass or to back up calmly?
💡 Example: "Back up calmly, it comes in handy all the time."
Would you rather have an endless supply of treats or the fanciest tack?
💡 Example: "Treats, my horses would appreciate that more."
Would you rather train for trail riding or for show jumping?
💡 Example: "Trail riding, I love exploring new places."
Would you rather teach your horse to self-load into a trailer or bathe calmly?
💡 Example: "Self-load, makes traveling so much easier."
Would you rather have a horse that is always enthusiastic or always calm?
💡 Example: "Always calm, it suits my riding style."
Would you rather ride in a parade or compete in a cross-country event?
💡 Example: "Parade, it sounds like so much fun."
Would you rather teach your horse to bow on command or count with their hoof?
💡 Example: "Bow, I think it would be a great party trick."
Would you rather have a horse that loves water or one that is unafraid of traffic?
💡 Example: "Unafraid of traffic, makes trail rides much safer."
Would you rather train in total silence or with a supportive group cheering you on?
💡 Example: "Supportive group! I thrive on encouragement."
Would you rather teach your horse to smile for photos or pose with props?
💡 Example: "Smile for photos, that would be hilarious."
Pick a Would You Rather template from the list and post it to your group, forum, or chat. You can schedule these prompts weekly or use them whenever you notice engagement dipping. Encourage members to share not only their choices but also the reasons behind them to spark even more conversation. Mix up the scenarios to keep things fresh and relevant, and consider highlighting some of the most interesting responses.
Would You Rather templates work on all platforms. For forums or Facebook Groups, pin the post or use scheduled posts for regularity. On chat platforms like Discord or Slack, use them as conversation starters. For Instagram or TikTok, pair with a visual or short video to draw attention. Always prompt for brief explanations to encourage richer discussion.
Focus your 'Would You Rather' prompts on realistic scenarios trainers encounter, such as: 'Would you rather work on tarp desensitization or flag desensitization with a spooky horse?' This sparks discussion about specific techniques, personal experiences, and problem-solving strategies unique to horse desensitization.
Absolutely! Pose questions like: 'Would you rather use clicker training or traditional pressure-release methods for teaching a horse to yield forequarters?' This encourages trainers to share perspectives, fostering respectful debate around widely discussed training philosophies within the community.
Alternate questions to cover both areas. For example: 'Would you rather spend an extra 30 minutes on groundwork or in the saddle when working with a green horse?' This ensures engagement from trainers specializing in various stages of a horse's education.
Frame questions around real-world dilemmas, such as: 'Would you rather tackle barn sourness first or focus on trailer loading if a horse struggles with both?' This draws on members' expertise with specific behavioral challenges in horse training.
Create discipline-specific scenarios: 'Would you rather spend a session on basic lateral work for dressage or practicing flying lead changes for reining?' This invites discipline-focused trainers to engage and share their specialized insights.
Yes, you can ask questions like: 'Would you rather always wear a helmet during groundwork or prioritize gloves when longeing a young horse?' This starts conversations about safety habits and risk management that are highly relevant to hands-on horse trainers.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks