Looking to spark more conversations in your horse training community? This or That prompts are the perfect way to encourage quick, lighthearted participation from everyone. Use these templates to break the ice and get members sharing their preferences in seconds.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That questions tap into our natural desire to make quick decisions and share opinions without much pressure. Because the options are simple and fun, members feel comfortable jumping in, even if they are usually shy or new to the group. These prompts lower the barrier to participation, making it easy for everyone to get involved.
In horse training communities, sharing preferences helps members find common ground and swap stories about their horses and routines. The playful tone keeps things positive and upbeat, creating a welcoming environment. Over time, regular use of This or That posts can build rapport among members and boost overall engagement.
English saddle or Western saddle? Which do you prefer and why?
💡 Example: "English saddle or Western saddle? Which do you prefer and why? I love my Western for trail rides!"
Morning rides or evening rides? Pick one!
💡 Example: "Morning rides or evening rides? Pick one! I am always an early bird."
Training indoors or outdoors - what is your go-to?
💡 Example: "Training indoors or outdoors - what is your go-to? Outdoors for me, especially in spring."
Bareback riding or with a saddle?
💡 Example: "Bareback riding or with a saddle? I only go bareback for short rides."
Treat rewards or scratches as a reward?
💡 Example: "Treat rewards or scratches as a reward? My horse loves a good scratch."
Long trail ride or quick arena session?
💡 Example: "Long trail ride or quick arena session? Trail rides any day!"
Grooming before or after riding?
💡 Example: "Grooming before or after riding? I always groom before."
Jumping or dressage - which would you rather train?
💡 Example: "Jumping or dressage - which would you rather train? Dressage for sure!"
Groundwork or riding - which is more important to you?
💡 Example: "Groundwork or riding - which is more important to you? Groundwork helps so much!"
Favorite horse color: bay or chestnut?
💡 Example: "Favorite horse color: bay or chestnut? Chestnut all the way."
Ride in the rain or wait for clear skies?
💡 Example: "Ride in the rain or wait for clear skies? I am a fair-weather rider!"
Halter training or lead rope work - what do you start with?
💡 Example: "Halter training or lead rope work - what do you start with? Always halter first for me."
Arena work or hitting the open trail?
💡 Example: "Arena work or hitting the open trail? Trails every time!"
Teach tricks or focus on basics?
💡 Example: "Teach tricks or focus on basics? Basics are key for me."
Horse boots or bell boots?
💡 Example: "Horse boots or bell boots? Bell boots for my jumper."
Favorite breed: Quarter Horse or Thoroughbred?
💡 Example: "Favorite breed: Quarter Horse or Thoroughbred? Quarter Horse for sure!"
Solo rides or group rides?
💡 Example: "Solo rides or group rides? I love the peace of solo rides."
Horse show or fun ride at home?
💡 Example: "Horse show or fun ride at home? Home rides are the best."
Favorite horse treat: carrots or apples?
💡 Example: "Favorite horse treat: carrots or apples? Apples win every time."
Clip in the winter or leave the coat natural?
💡 Example: "Clip in the winter or leave the coat natural? I prefer natural coats."
Would you rather muck stalls or clean tack?
💡 Example: "Would you rather muck stalls or clean tack? I'll take tack cleaning!"
Riding gloves or bare hands?
💡 Example: "Riding gloves or bare hands? Gloves for me."
Favorite training aid: lunge line or side reins?
💡 Example: "Favorite training aid: lunge line or side reins? Lunge line for sure."
Horse movies or horse books?
💡 Example: "Horse movies or horse books? I read every horse book I can find."
Fast canter or slow trot?
💡 Example: "Fast canter or slow trot? Slow trot for me!"
Winter blankets or tough it out?
💡 Example: "Winter blankets or tough it out? I always blanket my horse."
Show jumping or cross country?
💡 Example: "Show jumping or cross country? Cross country for the thrill!"
DIY horse treats or store-bought?
💡 Example: "DIY horse treats or store-bought? I love making my own treats."
Lead from the left or right side?
💡 Example: "Lead from the left or right side? Left side always."
Favorite horse pattern: solid or paint?
💡 Example: "Favorite horse pattern: solid or paint? I love paints."
Would you rather ride bareback in summer or winter?
💡 Example: "Would you rather ride bareback in summer or winter? Summer for me!"
Early morning feed or late night check?
💡 Example: "Early morning feed or late night check? I am up early for feeding."
Favorite horse show outfit: classic or colorful?
💡 Example: "Favorite horse show outfit: classic or colorful? I love a classic look."
Would you rather train a young horse or a seasoned one?
💡 Example: "Would you rather train a young horse or a seasoned one? Young horses are so rewarding."
Natural horsemanship or traditional training?
💡 Example: "Natural horsemanship or traditional training? I mix both styles."
Favorite season to ride: spring or fall?
💡 Example: "Favorite season to ride: spring or fall? Fall rides are so beautiful."
Grooming day or riding day?
💡 Example: "Grooming day or riding day? I enjoy both, but riding wins."
Horse podcasts or YouTube training videos?
💡 Example: "Horse podcasts or YouTube training videos? Videos help me learn more."
Barn chores solo or with friends?
💡 Example: "Barn chores solo or with friends? Always more fun with friends."
Would you rather own a pony or a draft horse?
💡 Example: "Would you rather own a pony or a draft horse? Ponies are adorable."
Favorite horse event: trail class or barrel racing?
💡 Example: "Favorite horse event: trail class or barrel racing? Barrel racing is so exciting."
Would you rather train for speed or for precision?
💡 Example: "Would you rather train for speed or for precision? Precision is my focus."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your chosen prompt into your community platform. Post at times when members are most active, or use them to kick off discussions during slow periods. Invite members to share their pick in the comments, and encourage them to explain why if they want. You can also use these prompts for Instagram Stories, Facebook polls, or as quick icebreakers in live sessions.
These This or That templates work across all platforms. For text-based groups, post as a question and invite replies in comments. On Instagram or Facebook Stories, use the poll or question sticker for quick taps. In forums or Discord, pin the thread for the day. Adapt the format to your platform's features to maximize participation.
Both training methodologies and care routines can spark engaging discussions, but for a horse training community, posts comparing specific training philosophies (like positive vs. negative reinforcement, groundwork vs. under-saddle training) tend to drive deeper professional engagement. You can occasionally include care routines to diversify content, but prioritize scenarios trainers regularly debate.
Incorporating breed-specific This or That questions is highly effective, as trainers often have strong opinions and experience with different breeds’ aptitudes. For example, comparing breeds for disciplines such as dressage versus jumping, or suitability for beginner riders, encourages knowledge sharing and debate that’s unique to horse training.
Presenting real-world horse training challenges in your This or That prompts—like 'Which is more difficult: teaching trailer loading or water crossing?'—encourages members to share solutions, tips, and anecdotes. This deepens peer learning and often leads to discussions about methods, equipment, and horse behavior, making your community more valuable.
Absolutely! Tack and equipment choices are central to horse training decisions. Comparing items such as snaffle vs. curb bits, rope halters vs. flat halters, or protective boots vs. wraps can generate lively responses and help trainers discuss the practical impacts of their choices in the ring or on the trail.
Tailor your This or That questions to the disciplines and training stages relevant to your community. For example, 'Do you prefer starting green horses with arena work or trail training first?' or 'Ground poles vs. cavaletti for improving rhythm?' This allows trainers to share discipline-specific experiences, leading to nuanced discussions.
Seasonal challenges are a big part of horse training. Posing questions such as 'Do you keep up indoor schooling routines or give your horses a winter turnout break?' addresses real-world adjustments trainers face. These prompts invite members to share regional practices, management strategies, and creative solutions for keeping horses engaged year-round.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks