Need a quick way to get your homesteading community talking? This or That prompts are the perfect icebreaker, sparking lively choices without putting anyone on the spot. Use these ready-to-go ideas to build connections and keep your discussions fresh.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That prompts tap into our natural desire to make choices, especially when the stakes are light and fun. In homesteading communities, members often have unique preferences or experiences, so simple either-or questions encourage everyone to chime in without feeling judged. The format is approachable for both new and seasoned members, lowering the barrier to participation.
Psychologically, quick choices activate engagement by requiring minimal effort but offering instant gratification. Members enjoy seeing where others stand, which can lead to follow-up stories and connections. These prompts also gently highlight the diverse practices within homesteading, reinforcing a sense of belonging and sparking curiosity about different lifestyles.
Overall, This or That posts are highly shareable and can be posted frequently without feeling repetitive, making them a valuable tool for any homesteading community manager looking to boost daily interaction.
Chickens or goats - which would you rather raise on your homestead?
💡 Example: "Chickens or goats - which would you rather raise on your homestead? Tell us why!"
Would you rather bake bread or make cheese from scratch?
💡 Example: "Would you rather bake bread or make cheese from scratch? Drop your pick!"
Rainwater harvesting or solar power - which would you install first?
💡 Example: "Rainwater harvesting or solar power - which would you install first?"
Compost pile or worm bin - which is your go-to for scraps?
💡 Example: "Compost pile or worm bin - which is your go-to for scraps?"
Grow your own veggies or shop at the farmers market?
💡 Example: "Grow your own veggies or shop at the farmers market?"
Would you rather preserve food by canning or dehydrating?
💡 Example: "Would you rather preserve food by canning or dehydrating? Share your experience!"
Fresh eggs or fresh milk - what would you pick every morning?
💡 Example: "Fresh eggs or fresh milk - what would you pick every morning?"
Hand tools or power tools for your daily chores?
💡 Example: "Hand tools or power tools for your daily chores?"
Would you rather start your day in the garden or the barn?
💡 Example: "Would you rather start your day in the garden or the barn? Why?"
Sourdough bread or homemade jam - which do you crave more?
💡 Example: "Sourdough bread or homemade jam - which do you crave more?"
Would you prefer to raise ducks or rabbits on your homestead?
💡 Example: "Would you prefer to raise ducks or rabbits on your homestead? Tell us!"
Apple trees or berry bushes - what would you plant first?
💡 Example: "Apple trees or berry bushes - what would you plant first?"
Would you rather build a greenhouse or a root cellar?
💡 Example: "Would you rather build a greenhouse or a root cellar? Share your reasons!"
DIY cleaning products or store-bought - which do you use more?
💡 Example: "DIY cleaning products or store-bought - which do you use more?"
Would you rather spend a day harvesting honey or collecting eggs?
💡 Example: "Would you rather spend a day harvesting honey or collecting eggs? Pick one!"
Morning chores or evening chores - which do you enjoy more?
💡 Example: "Morning chores or evening chores - which do you enjoy more?"
Would you rather grow herbs indoors or outdoors?
💡 Example: "Would you rather grow herbs indoors or outdoors?"
DIY soap or DIY candles - which would you try first?
💡 Example: "DIY soap or DIY candles - which would you try first? Vote below!"
Would you rather have a big vegetable garden or a large orchard?
💡 Example: "Would you rather have a big vegetable garden or a large orchard? Comment!"
Straw bale gardening or raised beds - which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Straw bale gardening or raised beds - which do you prefer?"
Would you rather barter with neighbors or sell at a local market?
💡 Example: "Would you rather barter with neighbors or sell at a local market? Share below!"
Wood stove or pellet stove - which would you choose for heating?
💡 Example: "Wood stove or pellet stove - which would you choose for heating?"
Would you rather learn blacksmithing or woodworking?
💡 Example: "Would you rather learn blacksmithing or woodworking? Let us know!"
Planting by the moon or by the calendar - what do you follow?
💡 Example: "Planting by the moon or by the calendar - what do you follow?"
Would you rather keep bees or raise quail?
💡 Example: "Would you rather keep bees or raise quail? Pick one!"
Outdoor shower or outdoor kitchen - which would you build first?
💡 Example: "Outdoor shower or outdoor kitchen - which would you build first? Comment!"
Would you rather forage for wild berries or mushrooms?
💡 Example: "Would you rather forage for wild berries or mushrooms? Tell us!"
Mulch with straw or wood chips - what's your favorite?
💡 Example: "Mulch with straw or wood chips - what's your favorite?"
Would you rather keep a journal by hand or use a digital app?
💡 Example: "Would you rather keep a journal by hand or use a digital app?"
Homemade soap or homemade lotion - which would you give as a gift?
💡 Example: "Homemade soap or homemade lotion - which would you give as a gift? Share below!"
Would you rather take care of the animals or tend the garden?
💡 Example: "Would you rather take care of the animals or tend the garden? What's your pick?"
Solar oven or rocket stove - which would you try for outdoor cooking?
💡 Example: "Solar oven or rocket stove - which would you try for outdoor cooking? Vote!"
Would you rather have fresh herbs year-round or fresh fruit in season?
💡 Example: "Would you rather have fresh herbs year-round or fresh fruit in season? Comment!"
Would you rather mend clothing or knit something new?
💡 Example: "Would you rather mend clothing or knit something new?"
Build a pond or install a rain garden - which project excites you more?
💡 Example: "Build a pond or install a rain garden - which project excites you more? Tell us!"
Would you rather have a root cellar or a walk-in pantry?
💡 Example: "Would you rather have a root cellar or a walk-in pantry?"
Would you rather host a seed swap or a skills workshop?
💡 Example: "Would you rather host a seed swap or a skills workshop? Share your choice!"
Would you rather grow tomatoes or potatoes if you had to pick one?
💡 Example: "Would you rather grow tomatoes or potatoes if you had to pick one? Vote below!"
Would you rather live off-grid in the woods or on a small farm near town?
💡 Example: "Would you rather live off-grid in the woods or on a small farm near town? Why?"
Would you rather cook on a wood-fired stove or a propane range?
💡 Example: "Would you rather cook on a wood-fired stove or a propane range?"
Would you rather have a bumper crop of zucchini or cucumbers?
💡 Example: "Would you rather have a bumper crop of zucchini or cucumbers?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your chosen prompt into your community platform. Add a friendly opener, or use the example as-is. For extra engagement, encourage members to share why they chose their answer. Use images or emojis to make posts more eye-catching, and consider pairing the prompt with a poll for quick voting. Rotate topics to keep content fresh and invite all members to participate, not just your most active contributors.
These This or That templates work on all platforms. For forums or Facebook, post as a question or with a poll. On Instagram Stories, use the poll sticker. For Discord or Slack, use quick message formats or dedicated channels. Always make sure to engage with replies to keep momentum.
To spark meaningful discussions, craft prompts like 'Rainwater harvesting vs. well water for irrigation?' or 'Manual hand tools vs. power equipment for daily chores?' These posts resonate with homesteaders who often have strong preferences rooted in experience or philosophy. Highlighting the pros and cons of each option encourages members to share their own stories and tips.
Livestock topics are highly relevant—try prompts like 'Raising chickens vs. ducks for fresh eggs?' or 'Goat milk vs. cow milk for homemade cheese?' These encourage members to share practical advice and personal anecdotes, fostering knowledge exchange about animal care, feed, and productivity specific to homesteading.
Absolutely! Posts like 'Growing heirloom tomatoes vs. hybrid varieties in your climate?' or 'Using straw bale vs. cob for natural building methods?' help members discuss solutions tailored to local challenges. Regional specificity drives engagement by validating diverse experiences and encouraging local expertise sharing.
Prompts such as 'DIY soap making vs. trading for handmade soap?' or 'Canning your own produce vs. joining a local food co-op?' allow members to weigh in on real-life choices they face in pursuit of sustainability. These scenarios prompt lively discussions about values, resourcefulness, and practical considerations unique to homesteaders.
Yes, you can use questions like 'Neem oil vs. diatomaceous earth for pest control?' or 'Handpicking bugs vs. setting up companion plant barriers?' These prompts lead to the sharing of tested methods, experiences with organic certifications, and strategies for balancing effectiveness with eco-friendliness—key concerns in homesteading.
Create posts that address different skill levels, such as 'Freezing vs. dehydrating garden surplus for winter storage?' or 'Fermenting vs. pickling for long-term vegetable preservation?' This approach ensures that both beginners and experts can contribute, offering tips, troubleshooting, and personal preferences, thus fostering an inclusive learning environment.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks