Running out of fresh ways to spark lively conversations in your home improvement community? Would You Rather questions are a playful, creative way to get members sharing their preferences and project dreams. Use these ready-made prompts to break the ice and inspire engaging discussions.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions tap into the natural human love for choices and storytelling. They encourage members to use their imagination, revealing personal tastes and sparking conversations that go deeper than simple yes or no questions. Hypothetical scenarios lower the barrier to participation, making it easy for even shy members to join in.
For home improvement communities, these prompts let members share their design preferences, DIY skills, and renovation ambitions. The playful tone helps foster a welcoming environment where everyone feels comfortable sharing, learning, and connecting over their love for making spaces better.
Would you rather renovate your kitchen or your bathroom first? Tell us why.
💡 Example: "I would renovate my kitchen because we spend more time there as a family."
Would you rather have a huge walk-in closet or a spa-like bathroom?
💡 Example: "A spa-like bathroom sounds amazing for relaxing after a long day."
Would you rather install hardwood floors or plush carpeting in your living room?
💡 Example: "Hardwood feels cleaner and is easier to maintain for my family."
Would you rather DIY a major project or hire a pro for peace of mind?
💡 Example: "I love a good challenge so I would DIY if I have the time."
Would you rather have a backyard deck or a screened-in porch?
💡 Example: "A screened-in porch for sure because of the bugs where I live."
Would you rather paint a room a bold color or stick with neutral tones?
💡 Example: "I usually go neutral to keep things flexible with decor."
Would you rather live without a dishwasher or a washing machine for a year?
💡 Example: "I could live without a dishwasher, but I need my washing machine."
Would you rather have a tiny house with top-notch finishes or a larger home with basic finishes?
💡 Example: "I'd pick the tiny house with great finishes for quality over quantity."
Would you rather have a smart home system or a top-of-the-line kitchen?
💡 Example: "A top kitchen would make cooking so much easier for my family."
Would you rather build a custom home or renovate an older house?
💡 Example: "I love the character of old homes, so I'd renovate."
Would you rather have a home theater or a home gym?
💡 Example: "A home gym would help me stay motivated to work out."
Would you rather tackle a messy garage or a cluttered attic first?
💡 Example: "The garage is more visible, so I would start there."
Would you rather have an incredible garden or a chef-worthy kitchen?
💡 Example: "A chef-worthy kitchen is my dream for baking."
Would you rather manage a long renovation or move into a ready home?
💡 Example: "I like a challenge, so I would take on the renovation."
Would you rather have underfloor heating or central air conditioning?
💡 Example: "Central air is a must in my climate."
Would you rather improve curb appeal or invest in backyard upgrades?
💡 Example: "Backyard upgrades are more useful for my family gatherings."
Would you rather add a skylight or more windows to your living room?
💡 Example: "A skylight would make the room feel so open and bright."
Would you rather have a mudroom or a laundry room with lots of storage?
💡 Example: "A laundry room with storage is more practical for me."
Would you rather upgrade your front door or your garage door?
💡 Example: "The front door makes a big first impression, so I'd pick that."
Would you rather have a large pantry or a second bathroom?
💡 Example: "A second bathroom would be a lifesaver with kids."
Would you rather repaint your whole house or replace all the flooring?
💡 Example: "I'd repaint. It's a big change with less disruption."
Would you rather power-wash the house exterior or clean all the windows?
💡 Example: "Power-washing sounds more satisfying and less tedious."
Would you rather have a fireplace or a built-in bookcase in your living room?
💡 Example: "A fireplace makes the room so cozy in winter."
Would you rather have a huge backyard or a finished basement?
💡 Example: "A finished basement would be a great playroom for the kids."
Would you rather have a home filled with natural light or super efficient insulation?
💡 Example: "Natural light is a must for my mood and plants."
Would you rather have a rain shower or a soaking tub in your bathroom remodel?
💡 Example: "A soaking tub would be perfect for relaxing after work."
Would you rather invest in solar panels or a new HVAC system?
💡 Example: "Solar panels would pay off in the long run."
Would you rather have a gourmet outdoor kitchen or a relaxing fire pit?
💡 Example: "A fire pit is great for family nights and roasting marshmallows."
Would you rather have your dream home in the city or in the countryside?
💡 Example: "Countryside wins for me. I love the peace and quiet."
Would you rather have heated bathroom floors or a towel warmer?
💡 Example: "Heated floors make chilly mornings so much nicer."
Would you rather choose open shelving or closed cabinets in your kitchen?
💡 Example: "Closed cabinets keep everything looking tidy."
Would you rather have a private home office or a guest room?
💡 Example: "A home office is essential for me since I work remotely."
Would you rather have a quick weekend DIY project or a big month-long renovation?
💡 Example: "I love the satisfaction of a weekend project that I can finish fast."
Would you rather have a home with all new appliances or all new windows?
💡 Example: "New windows would help with energy bills in the long run."
Would you rather prioritize safety upgrades or style upgrades?
💡 Example: "Safety comes first, especially with kids at home."
Would you rather restore vintage fixtures or install the latest trends?
💡 Example: "Restoring vintage fixtures keeps the home's character alive."
Would you rather have a master suite with a balcony or with a walk-in closet?
💡 Example: "Walk-in closet for sure. I need the storage."
Would you rather do a full exterior paint job or new landscaping?
💡 Example: "Landscaping gives so much curb appeal instantly."
Would you rather take on a fixer-upper or buy move-in ready?
💡 Example: "Fixer-upper. I love putting my personal touch on a home."
Would you rather have a pool or a hot tub in your backyard?
💡 Example: "A pool would be perfect for summer parties."
Would you rather replace all your light fixtures or all your faucets?
💡 Example: "New light fixtures can really change the mood in a room."
Would you rather have a pet-friendly mudroom or a high-tech laundry room?
💡 Example: "A pet-friendly mudroom would save so much cleaning."
Post a Would You Rather question as a standalone discussion or as part of a weekly engagement series. Encourage members to elaborate on their choices by asking them to share their reasoning or related experiences. Consider using images or polls to add visual interest or make it easier for members to respond. Rotate topics to keep discussions fresh and relevant to different interests within home improvement.
On all platforms, use Would You Rather templates as standalone posts, in stories, or within group chats. Add images or reaction polls for quick engagement. Tag relevant topics or use hashtags to reach wider audiences. Adjust formatting as needed for platform-specific features like polls or threaded replies.
You can create 'Would You Rather' scenarios such as 'Would you rather install your own hardwood floors or hire a professional?' This taps into the common debate in home improvement communities about the pros and cons of DIY versus professional work, allowing members to share experiences, advice, and even cautionary tales unique to renovation projects.
Pose options that reflect real-world material decisions homeowners face, such as 'Would you rather have quartz countertops that are low maintenance, or butcher block for a classic look?' This encourages members to share insights about durability, cost, and installation, using terminology familiar to home improvement enthusiasts.
Yes, tailoring scenarios to the time of year increases relevance and engagement. For example, 'Would you rather tackle outdoor landscaping this spring or focus on indoor painting projects?' This recognizes the seasonal planning that is unique to home improvement, prompting timely and practical discussion.
Frame questions around real challenges, such as 'Would you rather deal with lengthy permit approvals or discover hidden electrical issues during demolition?' This invites members to share experiences with these specific hurdles, fostering empathy and practical advice-sharing within the community.
Create questions that highlight current debates in design preferences, like 'Would you rather remodel your kitchen with an open concept or keep a traditional closed layout?' This leverages industry trends and terminology, encouraging in-depth discussion about functionality, aesthetics, and resale value.
Present scenarios like 'Would you rather allocate your renovation budget to smart home automation or invest in energy-efficient windows?' This speaks to a frequent challenge in home improvement—prioritizing limited funds—while encouraging members to discuss cost-benefit analysis, ROI, and personal priorities.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks