42 Must-Have Would You Rather Post Ideas for Health Communities

Looking for a fun way to spark conversations in your health community? Would You Rather posts are the perfect tool to get members thinking, laughing, and sharing their personal preferences on health topics. Use these ready-made templates to encourage participation and keep discussions lively.

Health 42 Templates

Generate Unlimited Templates with AI

Get personalized templates for your community in seconds

Start Free Trial →

Why This Works

Would You Rather questions work so well in health communities because they lower the barrier to participation. The simple structure and playful tone invite both new and seasoned members to join in, making it easy for everyone to share their thoughts without pressure. By presenting two interesting choices, you spark curiosity and creativity, leading to engaging discussions.

This format also taps into the psychology of decision-making and personal reflection. Members consider their habits, values, and goals in a low-stakes way, often revealing surprising insights about themselves and others. As everyone explains their reasoning, community bonds strengthen and new conversation threads naturally emerge.

42 Ready-to-Use Templates

1

Would you rather give up coffee for a month or sugar for a month? Tell us why!

💡 Example: "Would you rather give up coffee for a month or sugar for a month? Tell us why!"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #nutrition #habits #fun
2

Would you rather start every day with a cold shower or a 10-minute meditation?

💡 Example: "Would you rather start every day with a cold shower or a 10-minute meditation?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #wellness #routine
3

Would you rather walk 10,000 steps daily or do 30 minutes of yoga each morning?

💡 Example: "Would you rather walk 10,000 steps daily or do 30 minutes of yoga each morning?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #exercise #movement
4

Would you rather cook every meal at home for a week or not use your phone for a day?

💡 Example: "Would you rather cook every meal at home for a week or not use your phone for a day?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #nutrition #lifestyle #challenge
5

Would you rather have unlimited smoothies or unlimited salads for a year?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have unlimited smoothies or unlimited salads for a year?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #food #choices
6

Would you rather sleep 8 hours every night or wake up naturally without an alarm?

💡 Example: "Would you rather sleep 8 hours every night or wake up naturally without an alarm?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #sleep #wellbeing
7

Would you rather run a 5K or join a dance class every weekend?

💡 Example: "Would you rather run a 5K or join a dance class every weekend?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Top #exercise #fun
8

Would you rather never eat fast food again or never drink soda again? Why?

💡 Example: "Would you rather never eat fast food again or never drink soda again? Why?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #nutrition #choices #discussion
9

Would you rather have an unlimited supply of healthy snacks or free fitness classes?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have an unlimited supply of healthy snacks or free fitness classes?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #rewards #motivation
10

Would you rather take a long walk in nature or relax with a good book for stress relief?

💡 Example: "Would you rather take a long walk in nature or relax with a good book for stress relief?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #mental health #relaxation
11

Would you rather do a month of meal prepping or a month of tracking your sleep?

💡 Example: "Would you rather do a month of meal prepping or a month of tracking your sleep?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #habits #challenge
12

Would you rather have perfect posture or never catch a cold again?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have perfect posture or never catch a cold again?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #health #prevention
13

Would you rather take the stairs everywhere or bike to work every day?

💡 Example: "Would you rather take the stairs everywhere or bike to work every day?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #active #lifestyle
14

Would you rather join a group fitness class or work out solo at home? Share your pick!

💡 Example: "Would you rather join a group fitness class or work out solo at home? Share your pick!"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #fitness #community
15

Would you rather eat only breakfast foods or only dinner foods for a week?

💡 Example: "Would you rather eat only breakfast foods or only dinner foods for a week?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #food #fun
16

Would you rather do a digital detox weekend or a sugar-free weekend?

💡 Example: "Would you rather do a digital detox weekend or a sugar-free weekend?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #challenge #wellness
17

Would you rather always have to stretch for 10 minutes before bed or after waking up?

💡 Example: "Would you rather always have to stretch for 10 minutes before bed or after waking up?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #stretching #habits
18

Would you rather have more energy in the morning or feel more relaxed at night? Why?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have more energy in the morning or feel more relaxed at night? Why?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #energy #wellbeing #discussion
19

Would you rather swap your favorite snack for fruit or for veggies for a week?

💡 Example: "Would you rather swap your favorite snack for fruit or for veggies for a week?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #nutrition #challenge
20

Would you rather get a free health checkup or a free massage this month?

💡 Example: "Would you rather get a free health checkup or a free massage this month?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #wellness #selfcare
21

Would you rather always eat spicy food or never have dessert again?

💡 Example: "Would you rather always eat spicy food or never have dessert again?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Top #food #choices
22

Would you rather do a sunrise workout or a sunset walk? Which one and why?

💡 Example: "Would you rather do a sunrise workout or a sunset walk? Which one and why?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #exercise #daily routine #discussion
23

Would you rather take vitamins daily or drink a green smoothie every morning?

💡 Example: "Would you rather take vitamins daily or drink a green smoothie every morning?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #nutrition #supplements
24

Would you rather try a new healthy recipe every week or learn a new exercise?

💡 Example: "Would you rather try a new healthy recipe every week or learn a new exercise?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #challenge #growth
25

Would you rather have perfect skin or perfect teeth? Why did you choose that?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have perfect skin or perfect teeth? Why did you choose that?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #appearance #personal #discussion
26

Would you rather go a month without TV or a month without snacks?

💡 Example: "Would you rather go a month without TV or a month without snacks?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Irregular #lifestyle #challenge
27

Would you rather get 30 minutes extra sleep or 30 minutes more exercise each day?

💡 Example: "Would you rather get 30 minutes extra sleep or 30 minutes more exercise each day?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #sleep #fitness
28

Would you rather always take the stairs or always park far away for extra steps?

💡 Example: "Would you rather always take the stairs or always park far away for extra steps?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #movement #habits
29

Would you rather meal prep on Sundays or shop for groceries every other day?

💡 Example: "Would you rather meal prep on Sundays or shop for groceries every other day?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #nutrition #planning
30

Would you rather give up bread or cheese for a month? Which would be harder?

💡 Example: "Would you rather give up bread or cheese for a month? Which would be harder?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #food #challenge #discussion
31

Would you rather have more flexibility or more strength? Why do you choose that?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have more flexibility or more strength? Why do you choose that?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Top #fitness #goals #discussion
32

Would you rather eat only home-cooked meals or only restaurant meals for a month?

💡 Example: "Would you rather eat only home-cooked meals or only restaurant meals for a month?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #nutrition #lifestyle
33

Would you rather walk in the rain or run in the snow for exercise?

💡 Example: "Would you rather walk in the rain or run in the snow for exercise?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #exercise #weather
34

Would you rather always have healthy snacks on hand or a gym nearby?

💡 Example: "Would you rather always have healthy snacks on hand or a gym nearby?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #fitness #nutrition
35

Would you rather join a health challenge with friends or go solo?

💡 Example: "Would you rather join a health challenge with friends or go solo?"

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #community #challenge
36

Would you rather drink only water for a week or eat only vegetables for a day?

💡 Example: "Would you rather drink only water for a week or eat only vegetables for a day?"

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #nutrition #challenge
37

Would you rather spend more time outdoors or more time cooking healthy meals?

💡 Example: "Would you rather spend more time outdoors or more time cooking healthy meals?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #lifestyle #wellbeing
38

Would you rather have a personal trainer or a personal chef for a year?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have a personal trainer or a personal chef for a year?"

🔴 High Engagement Barrier 👤 Top #motivation #goals
39

Would you rather always know your exact step count or your exact nutrient intake?

💡 Example: "Would you rather always know your exact step count or your exact nutrient intake?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Frequent #tracking #health tech
40

Would you rather try a new sport or a new relaxation technique this month?

💡 Example: "Would you rather try a new sport or a new relaxation technique this month?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #wellness #discovery
41

Would you rather have more time for meal planning or more time for workouts?

💡 Example: "Would you rather have more time for meal planning or more time for workouts?"

🟡 Medium Engagement Barrier 👤 Average #planning #priorities
42

Would you rather always have fresh fruit or fresh veggies available at home?

💡 Example: "Would you rather always have fresh fruit or fresh veggies available at home?"

🟢 Low Engagement Barrier 👤 Lurker #nutrition #choices

How to Use These Templates

To use these templates, simply copy your favorite Would You Rather question and post it to your health community. Encourage members to choose an option and explain why. Rotate between lighthearted and thought-provoking scenarios to keep things fresh. For best results, post at times when your audience is most active, and interact with replies to foster deeper conversation.

Best Practices

  • Keep scenarios light, positive, and easy to answer.
  • Mix up topics to appeal to different health interests and lifestyles.
  • Always encourage members to explain their choice for richer discussion.
  • Avoid controversial or overly complex dilemmas.
  • Respond to answers to show appreciation and keep the conversation going.

All Platforms Tips

For all platforms, visually highlight the two options with emojis or formatting when possible. Use polls or reactions where available to make participation even easier. On chat platforms, pin your Would You Rather post for greater visibility, and on forums, use a clear subject line to invite quick responses.

Frequently Asked Questions

What topics work best for health-related Would You Rather posts?

Focus on relatable topics like nutrition, exercise, wellness routines, and healthy habits. Keep choices light, fun, and easy to discuss.

How often should I post these templates in my community?

Aim for once or twice a week to keep engagement high without overwhelming your members. Rotate themes to keep it fresh.

What if my community is quiet? Will these get people talking?

Yes, Would You Rather questions are designed to lower the barrier to entry. Even shy members often enjoy quick, low-pressure choices.

How do I encourage deeper conversations with these posts?

Ask members to explain their choice and share personal stories. Reply to answers to spark further discussion.

Can I use these templates as polls?

Absolutely. Many platforms support polls, making it easy for members to vote and engage. Follow up with a comment thread for discussion.

Are these templates suitable for all ages?

Yes, these templates are designed to be inclusive and non-controversial, making them appropriate for most age groups.

Can I customize the templates for my specific community?

Definitely. Feel free to edit the questions to better reflect your community's unique interests and culture.

Want these customized for your Health community?
Generate unlimited templates with AI - tailored to your brand voice
Try Free →
✓ Copied to clipboard!