Running out of fun ways to spark conversation in your gym community? Our This or That templates make it easy to create quick, playful posts that get members talking. Say goodbye to awkward silences and hello to lively engagement with these proven prompts.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That posts work because they remove the pressure to craft long answers, making participation feel effortless. By prompting members to choose between two familiar gym-related options, you lower the barrier to engagement and welcome even the shyest members into the conversation.
These posts also tap into the power of quick decision-making and personal preferences, which drives curiosity and friendly debate. When people see others picking sides, it naturally encourages more responses and playful banter, helping to build a sense of community and belonging.
Dumbbells or kettlebells - which do you prefer for strength training?
💡 Example: "Dumbbells or kettlebells - which do you prefer for strength training?"
Early morning workout or late-night session? Pick your favorite and tell us why!
💡 Example: "Early morning workout or late-night session? Pick your favorite and tell us why!"
Treadmill or outdoor run - which one gets you moving?
💡 Example: "Treadmill or outdoor run - which one gets you moving?"
Group classes or solo workouts - what is more your style?
💡 Example: "Group classes or solo workouts - what is more your style?"
Protein shake or smoothie post-workout? Let us know your go-to.
💡 Example: "Protein shake or smoothie post-workout? Let us know your go-to."
Yoga or HIIT for your recovery day?
💡 Example: "Yoga or HIIT for your recovery day?"
Rowing machine or elliptical - which one do you head for first?
💡 Example: "Rowing machine or elliptical - which one do you head for first?"
Music or podcasts while you train?
💡 Example: "Music or podcasts while you train?"
Leg day or arm day - which do you look forward to?
💡 Example: "Leg day or arm day - which do you look forward to?"
Pre-workout snack or post-workout meal? What is more important to you?
💡 Example: "Pre-workout snack or post-workout meal? What is more important to you?"
Wrist wraps or lifting gloves - which would you never skip?
💡 Example: "Wrist wraps or lifting gloves - which would you never skip?"
Cardio before or after weights?
💡 Example: "Cardio before or after weights?"
Short and intense or long and steady workouts?
💡 Example: "Short and intense or long and steady workouts?"
Gym selfies or progress logs - how do you track your journey?
💡 Example: "Gym selfies or progress logs - how do you track your journey?"
Stretching at the start or at the end of your workout?
💡 Example: "Stretching at the start or at the end of your workout?"
Squats or deadlifts - which would you keep if you could only do one?
💡 Example: "Squats or deadlifts - which would you keep if you could only do one?"
Gym playlist - upbeat pop or heavy rock?
💡 Example: "Gym playlist - upbeat pop or heavy rock?"
Machines or free weights for building muscle?
💡 Example: "Machines or free weights for building muscle?"
Foam rolling or static stretching for recovery?
💡 Example: "Foam rolling or static stretching for recovery?"
Personal bests or consistency - what motivates you more?
💡 Example: "Personal bests or consistency - what motivates you more?"
Tank top or hoodie for your workouts?
💡 Example: "Tank top or hoodie for your workouts?"
Hydration - water or sports drink during your session?
💡 Example: "Hydration - water or sports drink during your session?"
Barbell bench press or dumbbell bench press?
💡 Example: "Barbell bench press or dumbbell bench press?"
Gym bag must-have - towel or shaker bottle?
💡 Example: "Gym bag must-have - towel or shaker bottle?"
Cardio day - biking or running?
💡 Example: "Cardio day - biking or running?"
Train with a buddy or go solo?
💡 Example: "Train with a buddy or go solo?"
Jump rope warm-up or dynamic stretches?
💡 Example: "Jump rope warm-up or dynamic stretches?"
Protein bar or a handful of nuts for a quick snack?
💡 Example: "Protein bar or a handful of nuts for a quick snack?"
Push-ups or pull-ups - which challenge do you love more?
💡 Example: "Push-ups or pull-ups - which challenge do you love more?"
Gym shoes - minimalist or cushioned?
💡 Example: "Gym shoes - minimalist or cushioned?"
Spin class or bootcamp for a sweat session?
💡 Example: "Spin class or bootcamp for a sweat session?"
Sweat towels - bring your own or use the gym's?
💡 Example: "Sweat towels - bring your own or use the gym's?"
Rest day - active recovery or complete break?
💡 Example: "Rest day - active recovery or complete break?"
Motivation - new music playlist or new workout gear?
💡 Example: "Motivation - new music playlist or new workout gear?"
Battle ropes or sled pushes for a conditioning finisher?
💡 Example: "Battle ropes or sled pushes for a conditioning finisher?"
In-gym classes or online workouts - which do you prefer lately?
💡 Example: "In-gym classes or online workouts - which do you prefer lately?"
Squat rack or Smith machine for your lower body days?
💡 Example: "Squat rack or Smith machine for your lower body days?"
Foam mat or yoga mat for stretching?
💡 Example: "Foam mat or yoga mat for stretching?"
Sweat session - quick HIIT or steady cardio?
💡 Example: "Sweat session - quick HIIT or steady cardio?"
Sunday meal prep or spontaneous meals all week?
💡 Example: "Sunday meal prep or spontaneous meals all week?"
Goal for the month - add weight or add reps?
💡 Example: "Goal for the month - add weight or add reps?"
Gym playlist - create your own or listen to the gym's music?
💡 Example: "Gym playlist - create your own or listen to the gym's music?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your favorite prompt into your community platform. Post regularly to encourage ongoing participation, and rotate topics to keep things fresh. Invite members to share their reasons for choosing, or share your own choice in the comments to spark further discussion. For best results, use eye-catching visuals or emojis to make posts even more inviting.
For all platforms, keep your posts brief and mobile-friendly. Use images or emojis to highlight each option. Encourage replies in comments, stories, or polls depending on platform features. Monitor responses and reply quickly to keep momentum going.
For gym groups, it's impactful to tap into ongoing training debates, such as free weights vs. machines, HIIT vs. steady-state cardio, or early morning vs. evening workouts. These questions reflect real decision points gym-goers face, sparking passionate and relevant discussions. Make sure to keep options balanced and avoid polarizing language to maintain a positive atmosphere.
Absolutely! 'This or That' prompts are a low-pressure way to gauge member preferences on class offerings like circuit training vs. group spin or yoga vs. Pilates. This not only boosts engagement but also gives valuable insights for scheduling and program development tailored to your gym members’ interests.
When creating nutrition-themed prompts, focus on common gym scenarios such as 'pre-workout snack: banana or protein bar?' or 'post-workout: shake or meal?' Avoid making absolute claims or suggesting medical advice. Instead, frame choices as personal preferences or experiences, inviting members to share what works best for them.
Clearly state in your post guidelines that all preferences are valid, and encourage respectful sharing. For example, add a note like, 'No wrong answers—everyone’s fitness journey is unique!' Monitor discussions and intervene early if tone shifts towards judgment or negativity, especially on divisive topics like cardio vs. weights or lifting styles.
Yes, incorporating seasonal activities like 'outdoor bootcamp vs. indoor HIIT' or 'winter bulking vs. cutting' makes prompts timely and relatable. Tailoring prompts to current gym schedules, weather, or upcoming fitness events keeps content fresh and resonates with members' current routines.
Segment prompts for various experience levels by referencing specific terminology or routines: 'dumbbell bench press vs. barbell bench press' for advanced, or 'group classes vs. personal training' for beginners. You can also tag prompts with beginner/intermediate/advanced to help members relate, or alternate the complexity of your questions week to week.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks