Ever feel like your gaming community conversations need a spark? Hypothetical scenarios ignite creativity and draw out even the quietest members. Use these ready-made prompts to inspire imagination and keep your community buzzing.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios tap into gamers' natural love for speculation and creative problem-solving. By presenting 'what if' situations, you invite members to imagine different outcomes, test their knowledge, and share unique perspectives. This type of content lowers the barrier to participation, since there are no wrong answers and everyone can contribute regardless of skill level or experience.
Scenarios also foster a sense of camaraderie as members bond over shared dreams and playful debates. Whether the question is silly or serious, it encourages members to interact, reveal their personalities, and build lasting connections with others who share their passion for gaming.
If you could add any real-world item as a power-up in your favorite game, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could add any real-world item as a power-up in your favorite game, what would it be? I would pick a coffee mug that gives unlimited stamina."
You wake up inside the last game you played. What is your first move?
💡 Example: "You wake up inside the last game you played. What is your first move? I would look for a weapon and some armor ASAP!"
A villain offers you unlimited coins in exchange for your best weapon. Do you accept?
💡 Example: "A villain offers you unlimited coins in exchange for your best weapon. Do you accept? I would hold onto my sword no matter what."
If your main character could have any superpower, what would you pick and why?
💡 Example: "If your main character could have any superpower, what would you pick and why? I choose teleportation for faster travel."
Imagine your favorite game as a horror title. What changes?
💡 Example: "Imagine your favorite game as a horror title. What changes? Mario with jump scares would be wild."
If you could swap one game mechanic between two games, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could swap one game mechanic between two games, what would it be? Stamina from Dark Souls in Animal Crossing."
Your favorite NPC suddenly becomes the main villain. How does the story change?
💡 Example: "Your favorite NPC suddenly becomes the main villain. How does the story change? Isabelle would make a surprisingly tough boss!"
If you could bring one gaming character into the real world, who would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could bring one gaming character into the real world, who would it be? I pick Pikachu."
What would happen if your favorite game had realistic physics?
💡 Example: "What would happen if your favorite game had realistic physics? Mario jumps would be impossible!"
You can only play one genre for a year. Which do you choose and why?
💡 Example: "You can only play one genre for a year. Which do you choose and why? I would pick RPGs for the variety."
If you had to face a boss fight IRL, which boss would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you had to face a boss fight IRL, which boss would you pick? Maybe King Slime for an easy win."
Imagine your gaming avatar swapped places with you for a day. What chaos would follow?
💡 Example: "Imagine your gaming avatar swapped places with you for a day. What chaos would follow? My Sim would probably set the kitchen on fire."
If all weapons in your favorite game were replaced with food items, how would you win?
💡 Example: "If all weapons in your favorite game were replaced with food items, how would you win? Pizza swords for the win!"
You get to add one cheat code to any game. What does it do?
💡 Example: "You get to add one cheat code to any game. What does it do? Infinite double jumps, please."
If your favorite game had a movie adaptation, who would play the main character?
💡 Example: "If your favorite game had a movie adaptation, who would play the main character? Tom Holland as Link."
A glitch gives you one random power from another game. What power do you hope for?
💡 Example: "A glitch gives you one random power from another game. What power do you hope for? Warp pipes from Mario!"
You can only communicate in emotes for your next match. How do you strategize?
💡 Example: "You can only communicate in emotes for your next match. How do you strategize? I would use the thumbs up a lot."
If your favorite game had an endless mode, how long could you survive?
💡 Example: "If your favorite game had an endless mode, how long could you survive? Maybe 10 minutes in Doom Eternal."
What if every enemy in your last game teamed up against you at once?
💡 Example: "What if every enemy in your last game teamed up against you at once? I would run for my life."
Your favorite franchise gets a crossover with any other game. Which do you pick?
💡 Example: "Your favorite franchise gets a crossover with any other game. Which do you pick? Zelda x Monster Hunter would be amazing."
If you could make one in-game pet real, which would you choose and why?
💡 Example: "If you could make one in-game pet real, which would you choose and why? Chocobo for fast travel."
You can only use melee attacks for your next play session. What is your strategy?
💡 Example: "You can only use melee attacks for your next play session. What is your strategy? Get up close and dodge a lot."
Imagine your favorite game with a 90s retro art style. How does it look?
💡 Example: "Imagine your favorite game with a 90s retro art style. How does it look? Elden Ring as pixel art would be epic."
If you could delete one annoying feature from any game, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could delete one annoying feature from any game, what would it be? Escort missions, gone forever."
Your favorite game is now a board game. What is the main rule?
💡 Example: "Your favorite game is now a board game. What is the main rule? Roll a 6 to respawn."
If your least favorite enemy became your sidekick, how would things change?
💡 Example: "If your least favorite enemy became your sidekick, how would things change? Creepers from Minecraft would keep me on my toes."
You have to speedrun your next game session. What is your plan?
💡 Example: "You have to speedrun your next game session. What is your plan? Skip all side quests!"
If you could combine two game soundtracks, which would you pick?
💡 Example: "If you could combine two game soundtracks, which would you pick? Skyrim and Animal Crossing would be peaceful and epic."
You are granted a permanent buff from any game. Which do you choose?
💡 Example: "You are granted a permanent buff from any game. Which do you choose? Double XP forever!"
If your favorite game had a secret ending, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If your favorite game had a secret ending, what would it be? The hero retires on a tropical island."
You can only bring three items from your inventory into real life. What are they?
💡 Example: "You can only bring three items from your inventory into real life. What are they? Health potion, grappling hook, and a magic ring."
If your character could break the fourth wall, what would they say to you?
💡 Example: "If your character could break the fourth wall, what would they say to you? 'Stop making me jump off cliffs!'"
You can only use one button for your next play session. Which do you pick?
💡 Example: "You can only use one button for your next play session. Which do you pick? The jump button, of course."
If you could invite any game villain to dinner, who would it be and why?
💡 Example: "If you could invite any game villain to dinner, who would it be and why? Bowser, just to see what he eats."
Imagine your favorite game with reversed roles. Heroes are now villains. What changes?
💡 Example: "Imagine your favorite game with reversed roles. Heroes are now villains. What changes? Link as the enemy would be tough."
If your favorite game was set in your hometown, what would be different?
💡 Example: "If your favorite game was set in your hometown, what would be different? Less dragons, more coffee shops."
You can add one famous meme to your game of choice. What is it and how is it used?
💡 Example: "You can add one famous meme to your game of choice. What is it and how is it used? Doge as a secret boss."
If you had to explain your favorite game to someone using only three words, what would they be?
💡 Example: "If you had to explain your favorite game to someone using only three words, what would they be? Jump, run, collect."
A random event gives you infinite lives. What do you attempt that you never dared before?
💡 Example: "A random event gives you infinite lives. What do you attempt that you never dared before? Try the hardest boss."
If you could mash up two games' worlds, which combo would be the most fun?
💡 Example: "If you could mash up two games' worlds, which combo would be the most fun? Minecraft and Stardew Valley."
You can only play games from one decade for the next month. Which do you pick?
💡 Example: "You can only play games from one decade for the next month. Which do you pick? The 2000s for nostalgia."
If the main character in your favorite game could only speak in puns, how would it affect the story?
💡 Example: "If the main character in your favorite game could only speak in puns, how would it affect the story? The dialogue would be legendary."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your chosen scenario into your community platform. Encourage replies by tagging a few active members or adding a fun call to action. Rotate between light-hearted and thought-provoking scenarios to keep things fresh. For extra engagement, consider following up with polls or summary posts that highlight the most creative responses.
On all platforms, use clear formatting and tag or mention specific members to kickstart engagement. If possible, use polls or reaction features to add an interactive twist. Encourage members to reply with images, memes, or short stories for more creative fun.
To appeal to both casual and hardcore gamers, mix scenario complexity. Use approachable topics like 'If you could add one new power-up to Mario Kart, what would it be?' for casual players, and deeper hypotheticals like 'If you were a game dev, how would you balance an overpowered hero in Overwatch?' for hardcore players. Always reference popular games or mechanics familiar to your audience.
Leverage scenario templates that pose 'what if' questions about patch notes, nerfs, or buffs (e.g., 'If League of Legends removed jungle camps, how would the meta shift?'). These encourage members to share opinions grounded in their experience with evolving metas and balancing, leading to lively, informed debates.
Yes, frame hypothetical scenarios to focus on solutions or design perspectives rather than blame (e.g., 'If you could redesign microtransactions in FIFA, how would you ensure fairness?'). Moderators should remind members to keep discussions respectful and highlight community guidelines before posting sensitive hypotheticals.
Customize scenarios to reflect genre-specific tropes and mechanics. For RPG communities, use party composition or quest dilemmas (e.g., 'If your healer refuses to heal until loot drops, what do you do?'). For Battle Royale fans, focus on endgame strategies or loot choices (e.g., 'If the final circle is in an open field, what's your ideal loadout?').
Pose 'what if' scenarios that invite speculation about plot twists, character decisions, or alternate endings (e.g., 'If Geralt had chosen a different Witcher school, how would the story unfold?'). Encourage members to support their answers with in-game lore or examples, enhancing engagement and depth of discussion.
Frame hypotheticals around rumored or announced updates (e.g., 'If Apex Legends introduces wall-running, how might it affect current legends’ abilities?'). This invites members to share predictions and concerns based on gameplay experience, providing valuable, targeted feedback you can relay to game devs or use to inform future community content.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks