Finding it hard to spark lively conversations in your food community? Would You Rather posts are the perfect solution, offering engaging, playful prompts that get everyone talking. Use these templates to encourage both quick participation and deeper discussion.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions tap into our natural curiosity and invite members to share personal preferences in a low-pressure way. The food theme adds an extra layer of fun, letting people imagine new experiences, debate favorites, and reveal hidden quirks. This approach creates connection points between members, as they discover shared tastes or friendly differences.
These prompts are effective because they are simple to answer but often spark longer conversations as people explain their choices. The playful format lowers barriers for participation, especially for lurkers or newer members, while also giving regulars fresh material to engage with. Over time, this format can help foster a sense of community, belonging, and shared enjoyment around food.
Would you rather never eat pizza again or never eat ice cream again? Tell us why!
💡 Example: "I would give up ice cream because I cannot live without pizza nights!"
Would you rather only eat sweet breakfasts or only savory breakfasts for a year?
💡 Example: "Sweet breakfasts all the way, pancakes every morning sounds perfect."
Would you rather have unlimited sushi or unlimited tacos for life?
💡 Example: "Tacos for me! So many fillings to try, I would never get bored."
Would you rather eat only homemade meals or only restaurant food for a month?
💡 Example: "Homemade for sure, I like knowing what's in my food."
Would you rather give up chocolate or give up cheese forever?
💡 Example: "I would give up chocolate. Cheese is life!"
Would you rather eat spicy food at every meal or never eat anything spicy again?
💡 Example: "Never spicy again, my stomach could not handle that."
Would you rather always eat dessert before dinner or never have dessert again?
💡 Example: "Dessert before dinner sounds like a dream!"
Would you rather try a new food every week or always eat your favorites?
💡 Example: "New food every week, I love exploring new tastes."
Would you rather cook with only five ingredients or unlimited ingredients but no spices?
💡 Example: "Five ingredients, but with spices I can make it work!"
Would you rather eat breakfast foods for every meal or dinner foods for every meal?
💡 Example: "Breakfast foods all day, I love eggs and pancakes."
Would you rather never drink coffee again or never drink tea again? Share your pick!
💡 Example: "Never tea again, I need my morning coffee."
Would you rather only eat foods that are green or only foods that are red?
💡 Example: "Green foods, because I love avocados and spinach."
Would you rather always eat your meals cold or always eat them extra hot?
💡 Example: "Extra hot, cold meals are not my thing."
Would you rather have breakfast in bed every day or dinner at a fancy restaurant once a week?
💡 Example: "Dinner at a fancy restaurant, I love trying new places."
Would you rather eat only street food or only fine dining for a year?
💡 Example: "Street food, so much variety and flavor."
Would you rather never use salt or never use sugar in your cooking?
💡 Example: "Never use sugar, salt is too important for flavor."
Would you rather eat only pasta or only rice for the rest of your life?
💡 Example: "Only pasta, there are so many types and sauces."
Would you rather eat food from your favorite restaurant every day or cook your own meals?
💡 Example: "Cook my own meals, I like experimenting."
Would you rather eat only appetizers or only desserts at every meal?
💡 Example: "Appetizers, I love savory snacks."
Would you rather eat entirely plant-based or never eat vegetables again?
💡 Example: "Plant-based, I could not live without veggies."
Would you rather eat food from only one cuisine or try a new cuisine every month?
💡 Example: "Try a new cuisine every month, I love variety."
Would you rather bake your own bread every week or never eat bread again?
💡 Example: "Bake my own bread, homemade tastes amazing."
Would you rather always eat your favorite dish with ketchup or with mayonnaise?
💡 Example: "Ketchup, I put it on everything already."
Would you rather eat a five-course meal alone or a simple meal with friends?
💡 Example: "Simple meal with friends, company matters most."
Would you rather only eat foods that are crunchy or only foods that are creamy?
💡 Example: "Crunchy for sure, I love the sound and feel."
Would you rather never eat fast food again or never eat home-cooked meals again?
💡 Example: "Never eat fast food, home-cooked is healthier."
Would you rather eat only food you can eat with your hands or only food you need a fork for?
💡 Example: "With my hands, it feels more fun and casual."
Would you rather have unlimited snacks or unlimited drinks at every party?
💡 Example: "Unlimited snacks, I love munching at parties."
Would you rather eat a meal cooked by a celebrity chef or by your grandma?
💡 Example: "Grandma's cooking, nothing beats it."
Would you rather only eat foods you disliked as a kid or never eat your childhood favorites again?
💡 Example: "I would miss my favorites too much, so I pick never again."
Would you rather have breakfast for dinner or dinner for breakfast?
💡 Example: "Breakfast for dinner, pancakes at night sound awesome."
Would you rather eat only food you cook yourself or only food others make for you?
💡 Example: "Others make for me, I like surprises."
Would you rather travel the world for food or have the world’s best chefs come to your kitchen?
💡 Example: "Travel the world, I want to see and taste everything."
Would you rather eat only spicy food or only bland food for a month?
💡 Example: "Spicy, I need some excitement in my meals."
Would you rather eat only food that is blue or only food that is orange?
💡 Example: "Orange, there are way more options."
Would you rather eat everything with chopsticks or never use chopsticks again?
💡 Example: "Never use chopsticks, I am not that skilled."
Would you rather have dessert for breakfast or breakfast for dessert?
💡 Example: "Dessert for breakfast, a sweet start to the day."
Would you rather eat only frozen foods or only foods straight from the oven?
💡 Example: "From the oven, I love fresh and hot meals."
Would you rather eat food that is always too salty or always too bland?
💡 Example: "Too bland, I can add my own seasonings."
Would you rather have a fridge that restocks itself with your favorites or a kitchen that cleans itself?
💡 Example: "Kitchen that cleans itself, cleaning is the worst part."
Would you rather never eat your favorite snack again or never eat your favorite meal again?
💡 Example: "Never eat my favorite snack, meals matter more."
Pick a template that matches your community's vibe and schedule it weekly or during quiet periods to boost interaction. Encourage members to not just vote but also comment with their reasoning. Use polls if your platform supports them, or ask for replies in threads. For even more engagement, follow up in the comments with fun facts or related questions based on member responses. Rotate between easy, whimsical, and thought-provoking prompts to keep things fresh.
On all platforms, keep your prompts concise and visually appealing. Use emojis or food images to grab attention. On chat-based platforms, pin the question to the top for the day. In forums or Facebook Groups, start a new thread for each prompt and tag it for easy searching later.
Incorporate questions that pit popular diets or food philosophies against each other, such as 'Would you rather eat keto for a month or go fully plant-based?' This approach encourages members to discuss their preferences, share experiences, and debate the pros and cons of each dietary trend, increasing engagement and fostering knowledge sharing. Be sure to moderate discussions for respectful and evidence-based conversations.
Frame questions around typical industry challenges, such as 'Would you rather serve undercooked chicken to a critic or overcooked steak to a regular?' or 'Would you rather discard a whole batch of food due to potential cross-contamination or risk serving it?' These scenarios encourage food professionals to think critically about food safety protocols and ethical decision-making.
Design questions that challenge members to pick between nutrient-dense options, e.g., 'Would you rather swap all your grains for legumes or all your fruits for vegetables?' This not only makes the game fun but also educates members on the roles of different food groups in a balanced diet, sparking thoughtful nutritional discussions.
Yes, referencing real-world supply chain issues can make your posts timely and relevant. For example, 'Would you rather pay double for avocados or never use eggs in your menu again?' Such questions resonate with professionals facing these challenges, prompt practical discussions, and create a sense of shared experience.
Pose scenarios that highlight the challenges of accommodating restrictions, such as 'Would you rather develop a gluten-free bread that tastes like the original or create a nut-free pesto that's just as flavorful?' These questions raise awareness about inclusivity in recipe development and can inspire members to share creative solutions.
Use questions like 'Would you rather cook with only asparagus in spring or only pumpkins in fall for a week?' This celebrates seasonality, encourages members to share recipes and sourcing tips, and connects the community around local food movements and sustainable practices.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks