Finding it hard to spark meaningful conversations in your email marketing community? Unpopular Opinion prompts can break the ice and encourage members to share fresh perspectives. Use these templates to create respectful debates and boost engagement with ease.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Unpopular Opinion posts tap into our natural curiosity and drive for discussion by challenging commonly held beliefs. When members see a viewpoint that differs from the norm, they are more likely to pause, reflect, and respond with their own experiences or counterpoints. This not only increases engagement but also brings new ideas and learning opportunities to the forefront.
By encouraging civil discourse around less-common perspectives, communities foster a culture of open-mindedness and innovation. In the context of email marketing, where best practices often dominate discussions, these prompts invite members to question the status quo, share nuanced insights, and learn from each other. The respectful tone ensures debates remain constructive, helping members feel safe to express themselves and participate more actively.
Unpopular opinion: Personalization in email subject lines is overrated. What do you think?
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Personalization in email subject lines is overrated. What do you think?"
I think plain text emails outperform fancy HTML designs more often than not. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "I think plain text emails outperform fancy HTML designs more often than not. Agree or disagree?"
Hot take: Sending emails on weekends gets better results. Has this worked for you?
💡 Example: "Hot take: Sending emails on weekends gets better results. Has this worked for you?"
Is it just me, or do A/B tests waste more time than they save?
💡 Example: "Is it just me, or do A/B tests waste more time than they save?"
Unpopular opinion: List size matters less than list quality. Who agrees?
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: List size matters less than list quality. Who agrees?"
I believe that unsubscribes are actually a good thing. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "I believe that unsubscribes are actually a good thing. Thoughts?"
Does anyone else think open rates are a misleading metric?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else think open rates are a misleading metric?"
Unpopular opinion: Email automation can make messages feel robotic. Agree?
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Email automation can make messages feel robotic. Agree?"
I think emojis in subject lines reduce professionalism. Do you use them?
💡 Example: "I think emojis in subject lines reduce professionalism. Do you use them?"
Hot take: Welcome emails are overrated. Share your experiences.
💡 Example: "Hot take: Welcome emails are overrated. Share your experiences."
Does segmenting lists ever backfire for you? I think it complicates things.
💡 Example: "Does segmenting lists ever backfire for you? I think it complicates things."
Unpopular opinion: Monthly newsletters drive more engagement than weekly ones.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Monthly newsletters drive more engagement than weekly ones."
I feel like click rates tell a better story than open rates. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I feel like click rates tell a better story than open rates. Anyone else?"
Is it wrong to believe that shorter emails always perform better?
💡 Example: "Is it wrong to believe that shorter emails always perform better?"
Unpopular opinion: Using lots of images in emails hurts deliverability.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Using lots of images in emails hurts deliverability."
I think sending emails without previews is risky. Do you disagree?
💡 Example: "I think sending emails without previews is risky. Do you disagree?"
Hot take: Email frequency matters less than content value. Share your thoughts.
💡 Example: "Hot take: Email frequency matters less than content value. Share your thoughts."
Unpopular opinion: Pop-ups for email signups annoy more than they convert.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Pop-ups for email signups annoy more than they convert."
I actually prefer single opt-in over double opt-in. Is that crazy?
💡 Example: "I actually prefer single opt-in over double opt-in. Is that crazy?"
Does anyone else think email marketing is better than social media ads?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else think email marketing is better than social media ads?"
Unpopular opinion: The 'best time to send' is a myth. Agree or disagree?
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: The 'best time to send' is a myth. Agree or disagree?"
I think triggered emails can overwhelm subscribers. Has this happened to you?
💡 Example: "I think triggered emails can overwhelm subscribers. Has this happened to you?"
Is list cleaning overrated? I rarely see big changes after a cleanup.
💡 Example: "Is list cleaning overrated? I rarely see big changes after a cleanup."
Unpopular opinion: Including videos in emails is more trouble than it's worth.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Including videos in emails is more trouble than it's worth."
I think GDPR made email marketing better. Do you agree?
💡 Example: "I think GDPR made email marketing better. Do you agree?"
Hot take: Email marketing can work without segmentation. Anyone else believe this?
💡 Example: "Hot take: Email marketing can work without segmentation. Anyone else believe this?"
Unpopular opinion: Too many CTAs in one email reduce conversions.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Too many CTAs in one email reduce conversions."
I believe that 'no reply' sender addresses damage trust. Thoughts?
💡 Example: "I believe that 'no reply' sender addresses damage trust. Thoughts?"
Does anyone else avoid using gifs in emails for deliverability reasons?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else avoid using gifs in emails for deliverability reasons?"
Unpopular opinion: Over-designed emails distract from the message.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Over-designed emails distract from the message."
I think resending emails to non-openers is annoying, not effective. Who agrees?
💡 Example: "I think resending emails to non-openers is annoying, not effective. Who agrees?"
Is it just me, or is dark mode support in email overrated?
💡 Example: "Is it just me, or is dark mode support in email overrated?"
Unpopular opinion: Discount emails hurt long-term brand value.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Discount emails hurt long-term brand value."
I believe that text-heavy emails can perform better than image-focused ones.
💡 Example: "I believe that text-heavy emails can perform better than image-focused ones."
Does anyone else think spam complaints are actually helpful feedback?
💡 Example: "Does anyone else think spam complaints are actually helpful feedback?"
Hot take: Email surveys rarely get honest answers. Agree?
💡 Example: "Hot take: Email surveys rarely get honest answers. Agree?"
Unpopular opinion: Using countdown timers in emails feels gimmicky.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Using countdown timers in emails feels gimmicky."
I actually prefer longer onboarding sequences. Anyone else?
💡 Example: "I actually prefer longer onboarding sequences. Anyone else?"
Is it just me, or are abandoned cart emails overused these days?
💡 Example: "Is it just me, or are abandoned cart emails overused these days?"
Unpopular opinion: Using humor in emails risks alienating your audience.
💡 Example: "Unpopular opinion: Using humor in emails risks alienating your audience."
I think list growth is less important than subscriber engagement. What do you think?
💡 Example: "I think list growth is less important than subscriber engagement. What do you think?"
Hot take: Email marketing is not dying, it's evolving. Do you agree?
💡 Example: "Hot take: Email marketing is not dying, it's evolving. Do you agree?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste them into your community platform as discussion starters. Modify the wording to fit your brand voice or current topics of interest. Always encourage members to explain their reasoning and respect differing opinions. Pin or highlight especially engaging threads to keep the conversation going, and monitor responses to ensure the discussion remains respectful and on-topic.
Since these templates are designed for all platforms, adapt the format to fit your channel. On forums or Facebook Groups, use them as new topics. In Slack or Discord, post in dedicated channels and tag active members to join the conversation. For newsletters, consider including a prompt and inviting replies or comments.
Start by sharing an unpopular opinion such as 'Over-segmentation leads to diminishing returns' or 'Batch-and-blast still has a place.' Encourage members to share their segmentation philosophies, campaign performance data, and case studies. These discussions can surface nuanced challenges like balancing personalization with scale, and help members evaluate when advanced segmentation is actually beneficial.
Absolutely. Posting something like 'Open rates are no longer a reliable KPI' can spark insightful debates about evolving email tracking standards. This gives members a chance to discuss alternatives like click rates, conversions, and engagement scoring, and share how privacy features have impacted their reporting and optimization processes.
Yes, templates such as 'Sending daily emails isn’t as risky as everyone thinks' can foster healthy debate, provided you encourage data-backed responses and real-world experiences. Remind your community to focus on audience preferences, A/B testing results, and unsubscribe rates to keep the discussion productive and actionable.
Phrase your post to invite nuanced discussion, for example: 'Are emojis in subject lines overrated for deliverability, or do they actually drive engagement?' or 'First-name personalization is passé.' This invites members to share deliverability metrics, A/B test results, and preferences for different email verticals, which adds value for both newcomers and seasoned pros.
Set clear community guidelines for respectful discourse upfront. When using a template like 'Manual sends outperform automated workflows,' prompt members to provide concrete examples, campaign results, and nuanced pros and cons. Intervene if debates become personal, and summarize key takeaways to keep discussions focused on practical email marketing strategies.
Yes, whenever posting opinions like 'Cold emailing is still effective if done right,' clarify applicable regulations such as CAN-SPAM, GDPR, or CASL. Encourage members to discuss experiences with deliverability challenges, spam traps, and legal considerations, and always remind the community of best practices and the importance of ethical outreach.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks