Frustrated with sparking authentic conversations in your email marketing community? Experience share prompts invite members to open up, connect, and learn from each other. Use these templates to fuel valuable storytelling and build lasting bonds.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Experience share content taps into the power of personal storytelling, making community spaces feel more relatable and safe. When members share real-life stories, it creates empathy and helps others see themselves reflected in the group. This not only increases engagement but also deepens connections between members.
In the fast-evolving world of email marketing, everyone has unique journeys, challenges, and wins. Sharing these stories encourages learning through lived experience, not just theory. By prompting members to reflect and share, the community becomes a wellspring of inspiration, practical tips, and emotional support.
Share a time when an email campaign exceeded your expectations. What made it stand out?
💡 Example: "Last year, I tried a new segmentation approach and my open rates doubled. Has anyone else had a surprise win?"
When did you last feel challenged by email marketing? How did you overcome it?
💡 Example: "I struggled with deliverability last quarter but learned a lot from testing send times. How about you?"
Tell us about your first ever email campaign. What did you learn?
💡 Example: "My first campaign had a typo in the subject line! It taught me to always double-check."
Describe a mistake you made in an email campaign and what you would do differently now.
💡 Example: "I once sent a broken link to 10,000 subscribers. Now I always test every link before sending."
What is the most creative subject line you have used? Did it work?
💡 Example: "I tried 'You forgot something...' and it got our highest open rate ever! Anyone else tried something bold?"
Share an email marketing resource that changed your perspective.
💡 Example: "Reading 'Email Persuasion' helped me craft better calls to action. What resources inspired you?"
Recall a campaign that did not perform as expected. What would you change if you did it again?
💡 Example: "My spring sale email flopped, probably due to poor timing. Next time, I will check the calendar for conflicts."
What was your proudest moment in email marketing?
💡 Example: "I launched my first automated welcome series and saw a 25 percent uplift in retention."
Share a story about a small tweak that led to big results.
💡 Example: "Switching to a two-column layout increased my clicks by 15 percent. Anyone else had a similar win?"
Who inspired you most in your email marketing journey?
💡 Example: "My first manager encouraged me to experiment and never fear failure."
Describe a time when you helped someone else with their email strategy.
💡 Example: "I showed a coworker how to segment audiences, and their engagement improved."
Share a funny or unexpected response a subscriber sent you.
💡 Example: "A customer replied with a meme about our subject line. It made my day!"
What is the best advice you have received about email marketing?
💡 Example: "Always send a test email to yourself before every campaign."
Tell us about a time when automation made your life easier.
💡 Example: "Setting up a birthday email series saved me hours every month."
Have you ever had a campaign go viral? What do you think caused it?
💡 Example: "Our holiday giveaway email was shared widely because of its playful tone and prize."
What is your favorite email marketing tool and why?
💡 Example: "I love Mailchimp for its easy automation features."
Share a story about segmenting your audience and the results.
💡 Example: "Segmenting by purchase history led to a 30 percent increase in repeat purchases."
What email marketing trend has impacted your strategy the most?
💡 Example: "Interactive emails have helped me boost engagement in the last year."
Describe your biggest learning from an A/B test.
💡 Example: "I learned that shorter subject lines work best for my audience."
Tell us about a time you had to pivot your email approach quickly.
💡 Example: "When our event was canceled, we pivoted our emails to offer virtual options."
Share a surprising insight you gained from analyzing your email metrics.
💡 Example: "I found that Tuesday afternoons had the highest open rates for us."
Have you ever received negative feedback from a subscriber? How did you handle it?
💡 Example: "A subscriber disliked our frequency, so we adjusted our cadence based on feedback."
Describe a time you collaborated with another team on an email project.
💡 Example: "I worked with the design team to create a new template for our newsletters."
What is one thing you wish you knew earlier about email marketing?
💡 Example: "I wish I knew how important list hygiene was from the start."
Share a campaign you are currently working on or excited about.
💡 Example: "I am excited about our upcoming re-engagement series for dormant users."
Have you ever experimented with emojis in subject lines? What happened?
💡 Example: "Adding a rocket emoji increased our open rate by 10 percent."
What was your most memorable unsubscribe story?
💡 Example: "Someone replied with a heartfelt note explaining why they were leaving."
Tell us about a time you were surprised by your audience's response.
💡 Example: "I thought a plain text email would flop, but it got our best response rate ever."
Share your process for coming up with new email ideas.
💡 Example: "I keep a swipe file of interesting emails for inspiration."
Describe a time you used personalization in an email. What was the result?
💡 Example: "Using first names in the subject line boosted open rates significantly."
What email campaign are you most proud of and why?
💡 Example: "Our welcome series had a 60 percent open rate and helped build loyalty."
Share a behind-the-scenes look at your email creation process.
💡 Example: "I always start with a rough outline and collaborate with my designer."
What is your biggest email marketing pet peeve?
💡 Example: "I really dislike misleading subject lines."
Tell us about a workflow or automation that saves you time.
💡 Example: "Our automated re-engagement triggers have reduced manual follow-ups."
Share a tip for building or cleaning your email list.
💡 Example: "Running a quarterly list cleanup keeps our engagement high."
Has a subscriber reply ever changed your strategy? Tell us about it.
💡 Example: "A subscriber asked for more how-to content, and now we include it in every newsletter."
What is one myth about email marketing you have debunked through experience?
💡 Example: "I learned that sending more emails does not always mean more unsubscribes."
Tell us about a time your team celebrated an email marketing win.
💡 Example: "We ordered pizza after our holiday campaign hit a record conversion rate."
What is your favorite way to test new ideas in your campaigns?
💡 Example: "I like to run small A/B tests before rolling out big changes."
Share the story behind your most engaging email ever.
💡 Example: "A personalized holiday offer generated double our usual replies."
Describe a lesson you learned from a failed experiment.
💡 Example: "Animated gifs hurt deliverability for us, so we now use static images."
To implement these templates, simply copy and paste them into your community platform as new discussion prompts or thread starters. Rotate through different themes and adjust frequency based on engagement. Encourage replies by responding to early comments and tagging members who may have relevant stories. Consider pinning high-performing experience shares or highlighting them in newsletters to showcase the value of participation.
These templates work across all platforms. For forums, use as new threads. On Slack or Discord, post as daily or weekly prompts in dedicated channels. For Facebook or LinkedIn groups, format as status posts and use tagging or polls to boost visibility. Adapt language slightly for platform tone, but the core prompt remains effective everywhere.
Encourage members to discuss specific A/B test setups, such as testing personalization vs. generic subject lines or using emojis. Ask them to share what metrics they tracked (open rates, CTR), the audience segments involved, and which version performed better. You can start the conversation with a template post like, 'Share your most surprising A/B test result with us—what did you test, and what was the outcome?'
Frame the post to invite stories about real-world deliverability challenges: 'Have you ever had a campaign land in the spam folder? Tell us how you diagnosed and solved the issue.' Encourage sharing technical details like authentication protocols (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), sender reputation, and list hygiene practices.
Create Share Your Experience prompts that focus on adapting to legal requirements: 'How did GDPR affect your segmentation or consent processes? What tools or strategies did you implement to stay compliant?' This encourages practical, regulatory-focused discussion relevant to email marketers.
Ask members to share their approaches and findings: 'Have you experimented with different send times or adjusted frequency? What patterns have you noticed in your open or click rates?' This invites analysis of engagement metrics and allows members to compare strategies unique to email marketing.
Start a Share Your Experience thread focusing on specific workflows: 'Which automation sequence has brought you the highest ROI? Can you walk us through your setup and results for a welcome series or cart recovery flow?' Encourage sharing templates, automation tools, and measurable outcomes.
Pose a targeted question such as, 'Tell us about a time when segmenting your list (e.g., by engagement level, past purchases, or demographics) led to surprising results or posed unique challenges. How did you adjust your strategy?' This leads to detailed, actionable discussions around segmentation best practices.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks