Having trouble sparking fun conversations in your dieting community? Would You Rather questions make it easy to get members chatting, thinking, and connecting. Use these playful templates to ignite creative debates and keep your community active.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather posts tap into the human love for playful dilemmas and friendly debate. They invite everyone, from the shyest lurker to the most active member, to imagine themselves in entertaining scenarios. Because there are no right or wrong answers, the pressure is off, lowering barriers to participation.
These questions also encourage self-reflection, helping members share their preferences, habits, and goals in a lighthearted way. When members explain their choices, it leads to deeper discussion, stronger bonds, and long-lasting engagement. Plus, the simplicity of the format makes it suitable for all community sizes and platforms.
Would you rather give up chocolate or cheese for a month? Tell us why.
💡 Example: "I'd rather give up cheese because chocolate is my go-to treat!"
Would you rather meal prep every Sunday or cook fresh every day?
💡 Example: "I prefer meal prepping on Sundays to save time during the week."
Would you rather only eat salads or only eat soups for a week?
💡 Example: "Salads for me, since I love crunchy veggies!"
Would you rather never eat bread again or never eat pasta again?
💡 Example: "I'd give up pasta. I can't live without toast!"
Would you rather track calories or track macros for your diet?
💡 Example: "Macros all the way. It gives me more flexibility."
Would you rather have a cheat day once a week or small daily treats?
💡 Example: "Small daily treats keep me motivated!"
Would you rather eat only home-cooked meals or only restaurant meals for a month?
💡 Example: "Home-cooked for sure. I love knowing what's in my food."
Would you rather never have to grocery shop again or never have to clean dishes again?
💡 Example: "No more dishes, please!"
Would you rather always eat sweet breakfasts or savory breakfasts?
💡 Example: "Savory breakfasts fill me up longer."
Would you rather have unlimited avocados or unlimited berries in your kitchen?
💡 Example: "Berries all day. I love adding them to yogurt."
Would you rather stick to your diet 100 percent with boring meals or 80 percent with tasty variety?
💡 Example: "80 percent with variety keeps me going!"
Would you rather have to drink only smoothies or only eat salads for a week?
💡 Example: "Smoothies are more my style."
Would you rather plan every meal or be spontaneous with your food choices?
💡 Example: "I like being spontaneous when possible."
Would you rather give up all sweet snacks or all salty snacks?
💡 Example: "Salty snacks can go. I need my chocolate!"
Would you rather hit your daily protein goal or your daily fiber goal every day?
💡 Example: "Protein is my priority for muscle."
Would you rather cook a new recipe or stick to your tried-and-true favorites?
💡 Example: "I love trying new recipes on weekends."
Would you rather only eat fruits as snacks or only eat veggies as snacks?
💡 Example: "Fruits for snacks, hands down."
Would you rather have a personal chef or a personal grocery shopper?
💡 Example: "A chef would make healthy eating so easy!"
Would you rather eat only one type of cuisine for a month or try a new cuisine every day?
💡 Example: "New cuisine every day sounds exciting."
Would you rather always eat breakfast or always skip breakfast?
💡 Example: "I cannot skip breakfast!"
Would you rather have unlimited access to healthy snacks or free gym membership?
💡 Example: "Healthy snacks all the way."
Would you rather give up coffee or give up soda?
💡 Example: "Soda can go. Coffee stays!"
Would you rather eat dessert first or last at every meal?
💡 Example: "Dessert first, just for the novelty!"
Would you rather never eat out again or never order delivery again?
💡 Example: "I prefer eating out to delivery."
Would you rather always feel full or always feel energized after eating?
💡 Example: "Energized is my goal!"
Would you rather have to eat spicy food every day or bland food every day?
💡 Example: "Spicy food makes meals exciting."
Would you rather only drink water or only drink herbal tea for a month?
💡 Example: "Water is my go-to."
Would you rather eat the same breakfast every day or the same dinner every day?
💡 Example: "Breakfast can repeat. I want variety at dinner."
Would you rather spend extra time cooking or extra time exercising?
💡 Example: "I'd rather cook than work out longer."
Would you rather hit your goal weight but give up your favorite food, or keep your favorite food and take longer?
💡 Example: "I'd take longer if it means keeping my favorite pizza."
Would you rather always have to eat leftovers or always have to cook from scratch?
💡 Example: "Leftovers save me time."
Would you rather eat all your meals with friends or always eat alone?
💡 Example: "Eating with friends makes meals more fun."
Would you rather try a new diet trend every month or stick with one plan for a year?
💡 Example: "I like experimenting with new trends."
Would you rather always have to eat spicy snacks or sour snacks?
💡 Example: "Spicy snacks are my favorite."
Would you rather have breakfast for dinner or dinner for breakfast?
💡 Example: "Breakfast for dinner is the best!"
Would you rather prep lunches for the whole week or decide each day?
💡 Example: "I like prepping ahead to save time."
Would you rather eat only raw foods or only cooked foods for a month?
💡 Example: "Cooked foods are my pick."
Would you rather always eat your least favorite veggie or never eat fruit again?
💡 Example: "I'll eat my least favorite veggie. Can't give up fruit."
Would you rather have to eat standing up or sitting down for every meal?
💡 Example: "Sitting down is a must for me."
Would you rather always eat with chopsticks or always eat with your hands?
💡 Example: "Chopsticks make meals interesting."
Would you rather eat out at a new place every week or cook a new dish every week?
💡 Example: "Cooking new dishes is my thing."
Simply copy and paste a template into your community post, group chat, or social story. Add an open-ended CTA to prompt members to share their reasoning or stories. Rotate through different questions weekly or during themed challenges to keep things fresh. Encourage replies and interact with responses to keep the conversation lively.
For all platforms, use eye-catching graphics or emojis to make Would You Rather posts stand out. Pin the post or use stories for increased visibility. Reply to member comments to boost further engagement and show appreciation for participation.
When designing Dieting Would You Rather posts, be mindful of community diversity by including options that cater to popular dietary lifestyles. For example, frame questions like 'Would you rather swap bread for lettuce wraps (low-carb) or try gluten-free bread?' This ensures inclusivity and helps members with specific restrictions feel represented and engaged.
Leverage Would You Rather prompts to spark conversation about common dieting pitfalls. For instance, ask 'Would you rather have an extra dessert at a party or skip the appetizer?' This safely opens up discussion about real-life scenarios and helps members share strategies for handling cravings or social eating situations.
When tackling controversial topics, use neutral, curious language and clarify that answers are about personal preference, not 'right or wrong.' For example: 'Would you rather follow intermittent fasting or eat multiple small meals a day—what works best for you?' This encourages respectful sharing and learning rather than debate.
Absolutely! Use prompts like 'Would you rather track macros meticulously or focus on portion control by eye?' This not only sparks engagement but also subtly introduces educational themes, prompting members to share experiences and tips about nutrition management.
Incorporate scenarios such as 'Would you rather meal prep for a week or cook fresh daily?' or 'Would you rather give up sugar or salty snacks for a month?' These resonate with common challenges and preferences in the dieting journey, making posts more relatable and likely to generate responses.
Monitor responses for signs of distress and remind members that all choices are valid and the goal is to share experiences, not promote guilt or shame. Consider providing supportive follow-up comments and resources, and avoid prompts that directly reference weight or body size. Focus on behaviors and preferences rather than outcomes.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks