This or That Questions for Dating Communities (40+ Ideas)

Finding it hard to spark conversations in your dating community? This or That prompts offer a simple, playful way to break the ice and get members talking. Use these ready-made templates to immediately boost engagement and bring your community together.

Dating 40 Templates

πŸ“… Schedule a Week of Posts in 5 Minutes

Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks

Try Free for 14 Days β†’

Why This Works

This or That posts tap into our natural desire to share preferences and opinions without feeling put on the spot. The low-pressure format encourages even shy members to join in, since the choices are easy and lighthearted. By inviting quick responses, these prompts keep conversations flowing and help members discover what they have in common.

In dating communities, where starting a conversation can feel intimidating, these prompts break down barriers. Members can reveal bits of their personality and start playful debates without too much vulnerability. This approach not only boosts participation, but also helps members connect through shared experiences and interests.

The simplicity and fun of This or That questions make them highly shareable and perfect for all platforms. They create a welcoming environment where members feel comfortable joining in and expressing themselves.

40 Ready-to-Use Templates

1

Dinner date or coffee date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Dinner date or coffee date? Which do you prefer for a first meetup?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #dating #icebreaker
2

Texting or phone calls when getting to know someone?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Texting or phone calls when getting to know someone? Vote below!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #communication #preferences
3

Funny or romantic first messages?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Funny or romantic first messages? Which catches your attention?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #messaging #fun
4

Group date or one-on-one date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Group date or one-on-one date? Share your pick below!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #dating #choices
5

Adventurous date or cozy night in?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Adventurous date or cozy night in? Tell us why you chose!"

πŸ”΄ High Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Frequent #lifestyle #date ideas
6

Matching playlists or swapping favorite books?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Matching playlists or swapping favorite books? Which helps you bond?"

πŸ”΄ High Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #interests #music #books
7

Meet online or meet in person first?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Meet online or meet in person first? What feels more comfortable for you?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #dating #icebreaker
8

Date night: movies or mini golf?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Date night: movies or mini golf? Pick your favorite below!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #date ideas #fun
9

Spontaneous plans or scheduled dates?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Spontaneous plans or scheduled dates? Which do you prefer?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #planning #dating
10

Beach walk or city stroll for a date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Beach walk or city stroll for a date? Which one sounds better to you?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #outdoors #date ideas
11

Morning date or evening date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Morning date or evening date? When do you feel most relaxed?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #timing #preferences
12

Dressed up or casual for first date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Dressed up or casual for first date? What is your go-to look?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #style #first date
13

Ice cream or pizza date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Ice cream or pizza date? Which treat wins for you?"

🟒 Low Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Lurker #food #fun
14

Share memes or deep conversations?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Share memes or deep conversations? Tell us your vibe!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #conversation #fun
15

Would you rather cook together or order takeout?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather cook together or order takeout? What sounds more fun?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #food #date ideas
16

Surprise date or plan together?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Surprise date or plan together? Share your pick in the comments!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #planning #dating
17

Dog lover or cat lover?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Dog lover or cat lover? Which team are you on?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #pets #personal
18

Laughing together or meaningful talks?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Laughing together or meaningful talks? What matters more to you?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #conversation #connection
19

Road trip or staycation with a date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Road trip or staycation with a date? Drop your answer below!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #travel #dating
20

Sushi night or taco night?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Sushi night or taco night? What's your pick?"

🟒 Low Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Lurker #food #fun
21

Board games or video games for a fun date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Board games or video games for a fun date? Which do you enjoy more?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #games #date ideas
22

First meet: brunch or dinner?

πŸ’‘ Example: "First meet: brunch or dinner? Cast your vote!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #first date #food
23

Long walks or cozy chats at home?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Long walks or cozy chats at home? Which feels more romantic?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #connection #date ideas
24

Would you rather meet someone through friends or online?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather meet someone through friends or online? Comment below!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #meeting #preferences
25

Picnic in the park or rooftop drinks?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Picnic in the park or rooftop drinks? What's your dream date?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #outdoors #date ideas
26

Movie marathon or hiking adventure?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Movie marathon or hiking adventure? Let us know!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #activities #date ideas
27

Sweet texts or surprise gifts?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Sweet texts or surprise gifts? Which means more to you?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #romance #preferences
28

Would you rather have a picnic or go out to eat?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather have a picnic or go out to eat? Share your answer!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #food #date ideas
29

Share your favorite meme or favorite quote?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Share your favorite meme or favorite quote? Which do you send first?"

🟒 Low Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Irregular #fun #sharing
30

Would you rather chat late at night or early in the morning?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather chat late at night or early in the morning? Vote now!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #timing #communication
31

Outdoor festival or art gallery date?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Outdoor festival or art gallery date? Which would you pick?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #culture #date ideas
32

Would you rather send a GIF or emoji to start a chat?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather send a GIF or emoji to start a chat?"

🟒 Low Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Lurker #messaging #fun
33

First date: go for a walk or grab a drink?

πŸ’‘ Example: "First date: go for a walk or grab a drink? Tell us your style!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #first date #activities
34

Would you rather find love by chance or through searching?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather find love by chance or through searching? Share below!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #romance #preferences
35

Travel together or stay local for dates?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Travel together or stay local for dates? Which do you like more?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #travel #dating
36

Would you rather get flowers or a handwritten note?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather get flowers or a handwritten note? Let us know!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #romance #gifts
37

Call each other cute nicknames or stick to real names?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Call each other cute nicknames or stick to real names? Which do you prefer?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #fun #nicknames
38

Would you rather meet for brunch or dessert?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather meet for brunch or dessert? Which sounds better?"

🟒 Low Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Irregular #food #date ideas
39

Share playlists or swap photos to get to know someone?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Share playlists or swap photos to get to know someone? Drop your answer!"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #music #getting to know
40

Would you rather date someone with similar hobbies or different ones?

πŸ’‘ Example: "Would you rather date someone with similar hobbies or different ones?"

🟑 Medium Engagement Barrier πŸ‘€ Average #hobbies #preferences

How to Use These Templates

To use these templates, simply copy and paste your chosen prompt into your community platform as a post or story. Encourage members to reply in the comments or with quick reactions. For extra engagement, follow up with your own answer or tag a few active members to kick things off. Rotate themes regularly to keep things fresh and relevant, and adjust your prompts based on your community's unique vibe and interests.

Best Practices

  • Keep prompts light and non-controversial to encourage wide participation
  • Rotate between lifestyle, hobbies, and dating-related topics for variety
  • Respond to answers to show appreciation and keep the conversation going
  • Tag or mention frequent members to kickstart engagement if needed
  • Avoid overly personal or sensitive topics to maintain a safe space

All Platforms Tips

These This or That templates work across all platforms. For forums and groups, post as a new thread and pin it for visibility. On social media, use interactive features like polls or stories for instant feedback. In chat-based communities, drop prompts during peak activity times for maximum participation. Always encourage replies and thank members for sharing their choices.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I create 'This or That' questions that appeal to diverse relationship goals (e.g., casual dating vs. long-term commitment)?

Tailor your questions to reflect the variety within your community. For example, use scenarios like 'First date: Coffee shop or fancy dinner?' or 'Looking for sparks: Love at first sight or slow burn romance?'. Clarify in your post if you want answers from those seeking casual connections or long-term relationships to make everyone feel included.

What are some effective 'This or That' prompts to spark discussion about dating app experiences?

Focus on relatable app-specific scenarios, such as 'Swipe right for a great profile pic or an intriguing bio?' or 'Preferred convo starter: Memes or thoughtful questions?'. These prompts encourage users to share their real-life app experiences, leading to meaningful engagement and advice exchanges.

How do I address sensitive topics like dealbreakers or red flags in 'This or That' questions without making members uncomfortable?

Frame sensitive topics positively and keep them light-hearted. For example, ask 'Must-have: Sense of humor or ambition?' or 'Red flag: Always late or bad texter?'. Encourage respectful sharing and remind members to focus on preferences, not personal critiques, to maintain a supportive environment.

Can I use 'This or That' questions to help members reveal their love languages or communication styles?

Absolutely! Tailor questions like 'Prefer to give: Compliments or acts of service?' or 'Best way to resolve conflict: Talk it out or take a break?'. These not only make for fun polls but also allow members to reflect on and discuss their unique dating styles, deepening connections.

How can I leverage popular dating culture trends (e.g., ghosting, slow fades, soft launches) in 'This or That' templates to boost participation?

Reference current dating trends with prompts like 'Deal with ghosting: Move on or message again?' or 'Relationship reveal: Soft launch or full announcement?'. These trending topics resonate with users’ recent experiences, prompting more shares, reactions, and lively debates.

What strategies work best for encouraging shy or new members to join 'This or That' conversations about first dates or messaging etiquette?

Use approachable, low-pressure prompts such as 'First message: Classic 'Hey' or unique opener?' or 'First date: Group activity or one-on-one?'. Pin these questions, tag new members, and remind everyone that all preferences are valid to foster inclusivity and participation from every comfort level.

πŸ“…
Schedule these posts to your community
Plan ahead & auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Try Free β†’
✓ Copied to clipboard!