Running out of fresh ways to spark discussion in your cyber security community? Hypothetical scenarios are a powerful tool for encouraging creative problem-solving and participation. These ready-to-use templates will help you drive engagement and get members thinking outside the box.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Hypothetical scenarios stimulate imagination and invite members to apply their knowledge in novel ways. By presenting 'what if' questions, you reduce the pressure to have a 'right' answer and instead promote open-ended discussion, which encourages more members to share their perspectives. This format taps into curiosity and problem-solving instincts, making complex topics accessible and interesting.
In cyber security communities, hypothetical scenarios are particularly effective because they mirror real-world threat modeling and incident response exercises. Members get to safely explore consequences and strategies without real risk, which can be both fun and educational. This approach also helps surface diverse viewpoints, allowing your community to learn from each other while building camaraderie around shared challenges.
What would you do if your company laptop was stolen on a business trip?
💡 Example: "I would report it to IT right away and change all my passwords. What about you?"
Imagine a world where passwords do not exist. How would you secure your data?
💡 Example: "I would use biometrics everywhere. Anyone have better ideas?"
If you received a suspicious email from your CEO, what is your first step?
💡 Example: "First, I would verify the sender's address. What do you do in this case?"
Suppose you could invent one cyber security tool. What would it do?
💡 Example: "A tool that auto-detects deepfakes! What about your invention?"
You find a USB stick in your office parking lot. Do you plug it in or not?
💡 Example: "Never plug it in! Always turn it in to IT. What would you do?"
What if all Wi-Fi networks were suddenly insecure? How would you connect safely?
💡 Example: "I would only use wired connections and VPNs."
If your smart home device started talking to you about your work schedule, what would you check first?
💡 Example: "I would check its security settings. What do you think?"
You have 10 minutes to train a new hire on phishing. What is your top tip?
💡 Example: "Always check the sender and never click unknown links! What's your advice?"
Imagine you are in charge during a ransomware attack. What is your first move?
💡 Example: "Disconnect affected systems. What would you prioritize?"
Suppose your favorite app got hacked. Would you keep using it? Why or why not?
💡 Example: "Probably not, unless they showed real improvements. What about you?"
If you could change one common cyber security rule, what would it be?
💡 Example: "I would remove forced password changes every 90 days. Anyone else?"
What would you do if your phone kept restarting every time you connected to public Wi-Fi?
💡 Example: "I would avoid public Wi-Fi and scan my device for malware."
If you could time travel to prevent one famous cyber attack, which would you pick?
💡 Example: "I would stop the WannaCry outbreak. What about you?"
Suppose you must explain two-factor authentication to a grandparent. How do you do it?
💡 Example: "I would compare it to a double-locked door. How would you explain?"
What if your company banned all USB drives? How would you adapt?
💡 Example: "I would use secure cloud storage instead."
If you could have a superpower to stop cyber crime, what would it be?
💡 Example: "Mind reading, so I could spot hackers! What's your power?"
Imagine your social media account posts random things overnight. What do you check first?
💡 Example: "I would change my password and review app permissions. What about you?"
Suppose you had to teach a child about strong passwords. What analogy would you use?
💡 Example: "Like a secret recipe only you know! Any other ideas?"
What would you do if you accidentally clicked a suspicious link at work?
💡 Example: "Notify IT and disconnect my computer. How about you?"
If AI bots controlled all online security, what risks or benefits do you see?
💡 Example: "Faster response but more risk if compromised. What do you think?"
Imagine a cyber attack shuts down electricity in your city. What is your plan?
💡 Example: "Stock up on essentials and use offline backups."
Suppose you discover a security flaw in your favorite website. Do you report it?
💡 Example: "Yes, I would inform their security team. Would you?"
If you could remove one cyber threat forever, which would you choose?
💡 Example: "Phishing emails! What would you pick?"
Imagine all your online accounts were wiped. What is your backup plan?
💡 Example: "I keep secure offline backups. What's your strategy?"
What would you do if your smart fridge started ordering items you never requested?
💡 Example: "Change all passwords and check for malware. How would you respond?"
Suppose you had to choose between convenience and security. Which wins?
💡 Example: "Security, even if it is less convenient."
If you could ask a hacker one question, what would it be?
💡 Example: "Why do you do it? What would you ask?"
Imagine you are tasked with keeping a secret safe online for 100 years. How do you do it?
💡 Example: "Use strong encryption and regular updates. Any other ideas?"
What would you do if a colleague shared their password with you?
💡 Example: "Remind them of policy and report if needed. What would you do?"
Suppose your antivirus started deleting important files. How do you react?
💡 Example: "Restore from backup and contact support. What about you?"
If you could redesign online authentication, what would it look like?
💡 Example: "Maybe facial recognition plus a secret code. What is your idea?"
Imagine you must spot a deepfake video with only one clue. What do you look for?
💡 Example: "Check for unnatural blinking. What is your tip?"
Suppose your company emails everyone their password by mistake. What is the next step?
💡 Example: "Force password reset for all users. What would you do?"
If you could set one cyber security rule for the whole world, what would it be?
💡 Example: "Mandatory 2FA everywhere! What rule would you set?"
Imagine your favorite website asks for your mother's maiden name. Do you give it?
💡 Example: "I use a fake answer for better security."
Suppose you could spend a day as a cyber criminal to learn their tricks. What would you do?
💡 Example: "Analyze how phishing campaigns work. What would you focus on?"
What would you do if your online identity was mistaken for someone else?
💡 Example: "Contact support and update my credentials. How would you handle it?"
If you could make one cyber security myth disappear, what would it be?
💡 Example: "That Macs cannot get viruses! What myth would you erase?"
Imagine a world where everyone uses the same password. What happens?
💡 Example: "Total chaos and no security."
Suppose your smart car refused to unlock. What steps do you take?
💡 Example: "Contact support and check for remote access issues. What would you do?"
If you could teach the world one cyber security lesson, what would it be?
💡 Example: "Think before you click! What lesson would you share?"
Post these templates as regular discussion threads, weekly challenges, or conversation starters in your community. Customize the details to match your audience's expertise or current events. Encourage replies by tagging members or asking follow-up questions. You can also use these scenarios in live chats, polls, or as icebreakers during webinars and virtual meetups.
For all platforms, use engaging visuals or emojis to highlight scenario posts, pin popular threads to maximize visibility, and invite new members to participate by tagging or welcoming their first responses.
To ensure relevancy, base your scenarios on recent cyber incidents, such as high-profile ransomware attacks (e.g., WannaCry, REvil) or supply chain breaches (e.g., SolarWinds). Incorporate industry-specific terminology—like lateral movement, phishing entry points, or third-party risk—and ask members how they would identify, contain, and remediate these threats. This approach keeps the discussion up-to-date and highly practical for security professionals.
When drafting insider threat scenarios, focus on anonymized, generalized situations (e.g., 'A privileged user accesses sensitive data outside business hours'). Avoid referencing real or personal cases within your community. Encourage members to discuss risk mitigation strategies, monitoring tools (like UEBA), and incident response protocols, fostering learning while maintaining a constructive atmosphere.
Introduce scenarios with specific details such as 'Your SIEM has detected unusual outbound traffic late at night.' Ask members how they would apply their organization's IR playbooks, escalate to necessary teams, use tools like SOAR, or communicate with stakeholders. This encourages members to share actionable best practices tailored to real-world cyber security operations.
Absolutely. Craft scenarios where data exfiltration or unauthorized access triggers possible compliance violations. Ask members how they would manage breach notification timelines, reporting to authorities, and documentation under frameworks like GDPR, HIPAA, or PCI DSS. This fosters practical debate around legal and regulatory obligations unique to cyber security.
Design scenarios that present challenges from both perspectives, such as 'An adversary uses a zero-day exploit to bypass perimeter defenses.' Invite red teamers to discuss attack vectors and TTPs (tactics, techniques, and procedures), while blue teamers detail detection, forensics, and mitigation steps. This dual approach engages all skillsets and encourages cross-team knowledge sharing.
Post detailed, step-by-step incident progressions—like a phishing campaign escalating to privilege escalation—prompting members to role-play as SOC analysts, CISOs, or threat hunters. Ask how they would coordinate communication, escalate incidents, and document lessons learned. These exercises simulate real crisis management, improving readiness and teamwork among cyber security professionals.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks