Looking to spark creativity and conversation in your crocheting community? Would You Rather questions are a playful way to inspire members to imagine, share, and connect. Use these ready-made templates to get everyone chatting and sharing their unique perspectives.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions work because they offer a low-pressure entry point for conversation. Members do not need to be experts to participate, and everyone can relate to making a choice. This format encourages imaginative thinking, letting crocheters envision fun or unusual scenarios that spark laughter and creativity.
The format also prompts members to explain their reasoning, which leads to deeper connections and helps members get to know each other beyond just sharing projects. When you use Would You Rather questions in a crocheting community, you invite playful debate, banter, and storytelling, all of which are key drivers of engagement and belonging.
Would you rather crochet with only one color yarn for a year or only one type of stitch?
💡 Example: "I would pick one type of stitch, because I love using different colors!"
Would you rather make a giant blanket or dozens of tiny amigurumi creatures?
💡 Example: "Tiny amigurumi for sure, I love making cute gifts for friends."
Would you rather crochet with glow-in-the-dark yarn or yarn that changes color in sunlight?
💡 Example: "Sunlight color-changing sounds so cool for outdoor accessories."
Would you rather always have perfectly even tension or never have to weave in ends?
💡 Example: "Never weaving in ends would save me so much time!"
Would you rather teach a beginner class or take a masterclass with a crochet celebrity?
💡 Example: "I would love to take a masterclass and keep learning new things."
Would you rather crochet only hats or only scarves for a whole winter?
💡 Example: "Hats, since I love quick projects."
Would you rather use chunky yarn or lace weight yarn forever?
💡 Example: "Chunky yarn all the way, I like fast progress."
Would you rather crochet in a cozy cabin or on a sunny beach?
💡 Example: "Cozy cabin with a fireplace sounds perfect for crocheting."
Would you rather design your own pattern or follow a mystery crochet-along?
💡 Example: "Mystery crochet-along, I love surprises!"
Would you rather win a year of free yarn or all the crochet hooks you ever wanted?
💡 Example: "Free yarn for a year, hands down."
Would you rather crochet with your favorite color forever or have unlimited pattern choices?
💡 Example: "Unlimited pattern choices, variety keeps it interesting."
Would you rather finish every project perfectly or never run out of inspiration?
💡 Example: "Never out of inspiration, I love starting new things."
Would you rather crochet with friends in person or join a huge online crochet-along?
💡 Example: "In person, nothing beats crafting with friends."
Would you rather only make wearable items or only make home decor?
💡 Example: "Wearable items, I love making gifts."
Would you rather always have perfect lighting or the comfiest chair for crocheting?
💡 Example: "Perfect lighting, my eyes will thank me."
Would you rather try a challenging new technique or stick to your favorite stitches?
💡 Example: "Challenging technique, I love learning new things."
Would you rather crochet with metallic yarn or sparkly yarn for every project?
💡 Example: "Sparkly yarn, it adds a fun touch."
Would you rather crochet for relaxation or for creativity?
💡 Example: "Relaxation, it helps me unwind after work."
Would you rather have your work featured in a magazine or displayed at a craft fair?
💡 Example: "Magazine feature would be a dream come true!"
Would you rather crochet using only recycled yarn or only luxury fibers?
💡 Example: "Recycled yarn, I love being eco-friendly."
Would you rather make a complex lace shawl or a cozy oversized sweater?
💡 Example: "Oversized sweater for sure, I love comfy clothes."
Would you rather always find the perfect yarn sale or always finish your WIPs quickly?
💡 Example: "Finishing WIPs quickly would be a game changer for me."
Would you rather crochet with a group of friends or solo with music playing?
💡 Example: "Music and solo time is my favorite way to crochet."
Would you rather make crochet gifts for others or keep your creations for yourself?
💡 Example: "Gifting, I love seeing people enjoy what I make."
Would you rather always have matching dye lots or magically fix any mistake instantly?
💡 Example: "Fixing mistakes instantly would be amazing."
Would you rather make a crochet item for your favorite celebrity or for a loved one?
💡 Example: "A loved one, it means more to me."
Would you rather crochet an item you designed or follow a pattern from a famous designer?
💡 Example: "My own design, I like the creative process."
Would you rather only be able to use cotton yarn or wool yarn for all projects?
💡 Example: "Cotton, it is so versatile and easy to care for."
Would you rather crochet in total silence or with a favorite audiobook playing?
💡 Example: "Audiobook, it makes time fly."
Would you rather always have the perfect hook size or the perfect yarn for every project?
💡 Example: "Perfect yarn every time would be so helpful."
Would you rather crochet something practical or something purely decorative?
💡 Example: "Practical, I love making things I can use."
Would you rather crochet while traveling or at home in your favorite spot?
💡 Example: "At home, nothing beats my cozy chair."
Would you rather have unlimited time to crochet or unlimited yarn?
💡 Example: "Unlimited time, I never seem to have enough!"
Would you rather crochet with eco-friendly yarns or with the softest yarns ever made?
💡 Example: "Eco-friendly, I care about sustainability."
Would you rather join a crochet retreat in the mountains or by the sea?
💡 Example: "By the sea, I love the sound of waves while I crochet."
Would you rather always have inspiration for new projects or extra time to finish WIPs?
💡 Example: "Extra time for WIPs, my list is endless!"
Would you rather crochet a themed blanket or a set of matching accessories?
💡 Example: "Matching accessories, I like coordinating my look."
Would you rather get a surprise box of yarn every month or a new crochet pattern each week?
💡 Example: "Surprise yarn box, I love new textures and colors."
Would you rather crochet something huge in a week or a tiny project every day for a month?
💡 Example: "Tiny project daily, it feels more achievable."
Would you rather crochet using only vintage patterns or only modern patterns?
💡 Example: "Modern patterns, I like clean lines and new techniques."
Would you rather only be able to crochet in the morning or only late at night?
💡 Example: "Morning, I am more productive and alert."
Post a Would You Rather question as a standalone thread or as part of your regular engagement schedule. Encourage members to share their choice and why they picked it. Pin especially popular threads, or highlight fun responses in your community news or recaps. Use these questions to kick off events, break the ice in new member introductions, or revive quieter channels. Always respond to answers to keep the conversation flowing.
For all platforms, use clear and concise formatting. Use emojis or images to make posts stand out if your platform supports them. Tag posts for easy searching and consider using polls where available. Respond to answers to keep the thread active and welcoming.
To boost engagement, include choices that reflect common techniques, like 'Would you rather crochet only in the round or only in rows for a month?' or 'Would you rather master Tunisian crochet or perfect your amigurumi skills?' This sparks discussion among members with different preferences and skill levels.
Try prompts like 'Would you rather work with bulky wool yarn or fine cotton thread for your next project?' or 'Would you rather crochet with acrylic for versatility or bamboo for softness?' These options let members share their experiences and advice about different materials.
Frame questions around relatable challenges, such as 'Would you rather frog (unravel) an entire sweater or untangle a giant yarn mess?' Keep the tone lighthearted and encourage members to share funny or memorable stories, fostering a supportive community vibe.
Absolutely! Prompts such as 'Would you rather crochet blankets for a year or only make wearable garments?' help members express preferences and swap tips for large vs. small projects, stimulating conversation tailored to the community’s interests.
Pose tool-related questions, e.g., 'Would you rather use ergonomic crochet hooks forever or never use stitch markers again?' This encourages members to share tool recommendations and personal hacks, which can be especially helpful for both new and seasoned crocheters.
Yes! Questions like 'Would you rather follow written patterns or symbol charts for every project?' open up discussions about learning styles, favorite resources, and pattern accessibility, helping members discover new ways to approach their crochet projects.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks