Looking for an easy way to spark fun conversations in your crocheting community? These This or That prompts are designed to break the ice and boost participation with light, fast questions. Get your members talking and sharing in seconds.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That prompts succeed because they lower the barrier to participation. Members do not need to write long answers or overthink their responses. Instead, they can quickly pick an option and join the conversation without pressure.
The simplicity and playfulness of these questions create a relaxed atmosphere, making even shy or new members feel comfortable chiming in. By tapping into shared crocheting experiences, these prompts foster a sense of belonging and encourage members to reveal their preferences in a low-stakes way. Over time, this builds stronger connections and increases overall engagement in your community.
Do you prefer working with cotton yarn or acrylic yarn?
💡 Example: "I love acrylic for its versatility. What about you?"
Are you a fan of making blankets or amigurumi?
💡 Example: "Definitely blankets for me. Which do you pick?"
Do you like crocheting in the morning or at night?
💡 Example: "Nighttime is my creative zone. How about you?"
Are you team written patterns or video tutorials?
💡 Example: "Videos help me most. Which do you use?"
Do you prefer solid colors or variegated yarn?
💡 Example: "Variegated yarn is so much fun!"
Are you more likely to crochet gifts or keep your projects?
💡 Example: "I love gifting. What about you?"
Do you like using metal hooks or ergonomic hooks?
💡 Example: "Ergonomic hooks all the way. You?"
Are you a pattern follower or a freestyle creator?
💡 Example: "I tend to freestyle a lot. How do you approach projects?"
Would you rather crochet at home or in a group setting?
💡 Example: "Home is my comfort zone. What about you?"
Scarves or hats - which do you enjoy making more?
💡 Example: "Scarves every winter!"
Do you start one project at a time or have multiple WIPs?
💡 Example: "I always have at least three WIPs. How about you?"
Do you prefer simple stitches or intricate patterns?
💡 Example: "Simple stitches for relaxing. Which do you choose?"
Are you a fast crocheter or do you take your time?
💡 Example: "I crochet slowly and enjoy every stitch!"
Do you prefer making wearables or home decor?
💡 Example: "Home decor is my thing. You?"
Do you like working with chunky yarn or fine yarn?
💡 Example: "Chunky yarn for quick projects!"
Do you weave in ends as you go or at the end?
💡 Example: "I leave them for last. What about you?"
Do you crochet more in summer or winter?
💡 Example: "Winter inspires me to crochet."
Are you all about bright colors or neutral shades?
💡 Example: "Bright colors make me happy!"
Do you prefer round projects like hats or flat ones like blankets?
💡 Example: "Flat projects are easier for me. Which do you like?"
Do you like to crochet with music or in silence?
💡 Example: "Music sets the mood for me."
Are you team granny squares or team chevron stripes?
💡 Example: "Granny squares forever! Which side are you on?"
Do you block your finished pieces or skip it?
💡 Example: "I always block my shawls. Do you?"
Would you rather use stitch markers or just count stitches?
💡 Example: "Stitch markers keep me sane!"
Do you like following CALs (crochet-alongs) or solo projects?
💡 Example: "CALs help me stay motivated. How about you?"
Are you more likely to crochet for relaxation or productivity?
💡 Example: "Relaxation always. What motivates you?"
Do you crochet on the couch or at a desk?
💡 Example: "Couch all the way!"
Do you prefer making small projects or large ones?
💡 Example: "Small projects give instant results. What do you prefer?"
Are you a fan of seasonal projects or year-round classics?
💡 Example: "I love making holiday items."
Do you like learning new stitches or sticking to favorites?
💡 Example: "I am always trying new stitches. You?"
Are you more likely to crochet while watching TV or listening to podcasts?
💡 Example: "TV for me. What about you?"
Do you finish projects before starting new ones or juggle several?
💡 Example: "I always juggle a few. How about you?"
Do you prefer soft pastels or bold jewel tones?
💡 Example: "Jewel tones all day!"
Are you into making toys or accessories?
💡 Example: "Accessories are my go-to. You?"
Do you prefer working with wool or plant-based yarns?
💡 Example: "Plant-based yarns are my favorite."
Would you rather crochet with a friend or solo?
💡 Example: "Solo time is my creative time. What about you?"
Are you a fan of textured stitches or flat stitches?
💡 Example: "Textured stitches add so much interest."
Do you prefer to frog mistakes or work around them?
💡 Example: "I usually frog and fix. What do you do?"
Are you team stitch counter or mental math?
💡 Example: "I trust my mental math!"
Do you prefer amigurumi animals or food items?
💡 Example: "Animals are my favorite to make. You?"
Would you rather crochet with bright light or cozy low light?
💡 Example: "Bright light helps me see my stitches."
Do you like to plan projects in advance or decide on the fly?
💡 Example: "I plan everything out. What about you?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste a prompt into your community platform of choice. You can schedule them as regular weekly posts, sprinkle them in during lulls in conversation, or use them as icebreakers for new member introductions. For best results, encourage members to share not just their pick, but also a quick reason why. This keeps the thread lively and personal.
These This or That templates are designed for all platforms. Adjust formatting to fit platform norms: use images or polls for Instagram and Facebook, text-only posts for Discord or forums, and consider using Stories or Reels for extra visibility. Always respond to member comments to keep the thread active, regardless of the platform.
To engage both amigurumi and garment-focused members, alternate between This or That prompts that reference techniques, yarn types, or project challenges unique to each group. For example, use prompts like ‘Magic Ring vs Chained Circle for amigurumi starts’ and ‘Top-down vs Bottom-up sweater construction.’ This keeps the content fresh and inclusive for all crochet specialties.
Yes! Stitches are a core part of crocheting, and asking members to choose between techniques like ‘front post’ and ‘back post’ double crochet can spark technical discussions, share tips, and help beginners learn. Just ensure the choices are relevant to your members’ typical skill levels and projects.
Healthy debate is common with fiber preferences. Moderate the discussion by encouraging members to share their reasons and project experiences (e.g., ‘Acrylic for baby blankets, wool for hats’). Remind members to respect differing opinions, as factors like allergies, budget, and availability all play a role in yarn choice.
Absolutely! Seasonal posts such as ‘summer tops vs cozy blankets’ or ‘holiday ornaments vs winter hats’ are great for sparking timely interest and sharing project inspiration. They also help members plan their upcoming makes and discover new patterns relevant to the season.
Yes, including prompts like ‘mirror patterns vs standard patterns’ or ‘video tutorials for lefties vs written instructions’ can help left-handed crocheters feel seen. It also opens up helpful discussions about adapting patterns and sharing resources for different dominant hands.
Prompts that reference problem-solving scenarios (‘frogging a mistake vs working around it’) encourage members to share valuable experience and creative fixes. These posts can foster a supportive environment and help normalize mistakes as part of the crochet journey.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks