Running out of creative ways to spark discussion in your content creator community? Would You Rather prompts offer a fun, low-pressure way to get everyone talking and thinking. Use these templates to inspire imaginative conversations and connect your members.
Get personalized templates for your community in seconds
Would You Rather questions are a proven way to drive engagement because they invite everyone to participate, regardless of experience or confidence level. The binary choice format lowers the barrier to entry and encourages even shy community members to join in. By framing options around creative scenarios relevant to content creation, you tap into your community's passions and expertise.
These prompts also stimulate critical thinking and storytelling, as members often elaborate on their choices with personal anecdotes or creative reasoning. This not only builds connection but also helps members learn from each other's perspectives and experiences. Over time, playful Would You Rather posts can contribute to a more vibrant, inclusive, and collaborative community culture.
Would you rather get a million views on one video or a loyal following of 1,000 fans?
💡 Example: "I'd rather have 1,000 loyal fans because steady support means more long-term success."
Would you rather create daily short videos or weekly long-form content?
💡 Example: "Weekly long-form works better for me since I like deep dives!"
Would you rather collaborate with your idol or mentor a beginner creator?
💡 Example: "I'd love to mentor a beginner and help them grow."
Would you rather go viral for a meme or for a helpful tutorial?
💡 Example: "A helpful tutorial, so people see my expertise."
Would you rather have unlimited creative ideas or endless editing skills?
💡 Example: "Unlimited ideas would help me post more regularly."
Would you rather never run out of time or never run out of inspiration?
💡 Example: "More time! Inspiration is pointless if I can't create."
Would you rather film with top equipment or have a dream editing studio?
💡 Example: "A dream editing studio would boost my workflow."
Would you rather get instant feedback from your audience or from a pro creator?
💡 Example: "Instant audience feedback helps me improve quickly."
Would you rather focus on one niche or experiment with many topics?
💡 Example: "I love experimenting with topics to keep things fresh."
Would you rather livestream twice a week or upload polished videos monthly?
💡 Example: "Monthly polished videos suit my style better."
Would you rather have 1,000 likes or 100 meaningful comments on your latest post?
💡 Example: "Meaningful comments any day, I love the connection."
Would you rather create under a tight deadline or have all the time you need?
💡 Example: "Deadlines keep me motivated to finish projects."
Would you rather never face creative block or always get top search rankings?
💡 Example: "No more creative block, please!"
Would you rather host a podcast or star in a video series?
💡 Example: "Podcasting fits my style since I'm camera-shy."
Would you rather edit your content yourself or hire a pro editor?
💡 Example: "I'd love to hire a pro and focus on creating."
Would you rather create content at home or travel to exciting locations?
💡 Example: "Traveling would inspire new stories for my channel."
Would you rather have a viral video once or steady growth every month?
💡 Example: "Steady growth feels more sustainable to me."
Would you rather write scripts or improvise all your content?
💡 Example: "Writing scripts helps me stay on track."
Would you rather have your own merch line or host exclusive workshops?
💡 Example: "Workshops! I love connecting with my audience."
Would you rather work alone or be part of a creator collective?
💡 Example: "A collective could open up new opportunities."
Would you rather have unlimited stock footage or unlimited copyright-free music?
💡 Example: "Music options make every video unique!"
Would you rather be known for your humor or your deep insights?
💡 Example: "Humor helps me connect with my viewers."
Would you rather post at midnight or early morning for best audience reach?
💡 Example: "Early morning works for my audience's time zone."
Would you rather manage your own community or hire a community manager?
💡 Example: "I'd rather manage it myself to stay close to fans."
Would you rather win a creator award or be recognized by your followers?
💡 Example: "Follower recognition feels more personal to me."
Would you rather have every video perfectly scripted or always nail it in one take?
💡 Example: "One-take wins would save me so much editing time."
Would you rather focus on trending topics or evergreen content?
💡 Example: "Evergreen content keeps bringing in views."
Would you rather have unlimited brand deals or total creative freedom?
💡 Example: "Creative freedom is everything to me."
Would you rather answer Q and A sessions live or through edited videos?
💡 Example: "Edited videos let me organize my thoughts better."
Would you rather have instant video ideas or instant topic research?
💡 Example: "Instant research helps me plan ahead."
Would you rather create for fun or focus on monetization?
💡 Example: "Fun first, then the money follows."
Would you rather have your content shared by a celebrity or go viral in your niche?
💡 Example: "Viral in my niche means more relevant followers."
Would you rather always meet deadlines or always have creative freedom?
💡 Example: "Creative freedom keeps me motivated."
Would you rather be known for your visuals or your storytelling?
💡 Example: "Storytelling connects on a deeper level."
Would you rather attend a creator retreat or take an online masterclass?
💡 Example: "A retreat would help me network in person."
Would you rather focus on quality or quantity for your uploads?
💡 Example: "Quality always wins for my audience."
Would you rather have a viral TikTok or a trending YouTube video?
💡 Example: "Trending YouTube video for long-term reach."
Would you rather your content inspire others or entertain them?
💡 Example: "Inspiring others makes my work meaningful."
Would you rather never worry about algorithms or never worry about trolls?
💡 Example: "No more trolls would mean a healthier community."
Would you rather have your own app or a feature on a major platform?
💡 Example: "My own app for more control over my content."
Would you rather create anonymous content or always show your face?
💡 Example: "I prefer staying anonymous for privacy."
Would you rather have unlimited data on your audience or unlimited editing resources?
💡 Example: "Audience data helps me grow smarter."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste one into your platform's post or chat tool, customizing the specifics if desired. Encourage members to explain their choices and tag friends for added participation. Schedule these prompts regularly, such as once a week, to create anticipation and routine engagement. Consider pinning especially active threads or summarizing interesting insights to foster ongoing conversation.
For all platforms, use eye-catching formatting like emojis or bold text to spotlight your Would You Rather prompts. On chat-first platforms, consider sharing as a quick poll or using threads for extended discussion. On forums or social media, encourage replies and tag active members to boost visibility.
They spark engagement, encourage creativity, and help members bond over shared interests and challenges.
Once a week is ideal for regular engagement, but you can adjust frequency based on your community's activity.
Absolutely. Feel free to adjust scenarios to better fit your community's specific focus or interests.
Try tagging active members, rephrasing the question, or posting at a different time for better visibility.
Yes, they are designed to be accessible and relevant for both new and experienced content creators.
Yes, encouraging reasoning leads to richer discussion and deeper community connections.
Yes, they work well as polls, stories, or regular posts across all major platforms.