Tired of trying to get your collectibles community talking? This or That prompts are the perfect way to spark quick, fun conversations and help even the quietest members join in. With these ready-to-use templates, you will never run out of playful engagement ideas.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That posts work because they offer a low-pressure way for members to engage. The simplicity of choosing between two options lowers the barrier to participation, making it easy for anyone to join the conversation in just a few seconds. The playful tone taps into members' interests and preferences, encouraging more genuine and spontaneous responses.
For collectibles communities, these prompts help highlight members' unique tastes and spark friendly debates about favorite items, eras, or collecting styles. By keeping topics light and fun, you create a welcoming atmosphere that invites both seasoned collectors and newcomers to share opinions without fear of judgment.
Vinyl records or action figures - which would you rather collect?
💡 Example: "Vinyl records or action figures - which would you rather collect?"
Old school cards or modern limited editions - what catches your eye?
💡 Example: "Old school cards or modern limited editions - what catches your eye?"
Display in cases or keep in storage - how do you show off your finds?
💡 Example: "Display in cases or keep in storage - how do you show off your finds?"
Hunt at flea markets or buy online - what is your favorite way to collect?
💡 Example: "Hunt at flea markets or buy online - what is your favorite way to collect?"
Autographed or mint condition - which matters more to you?
💡 Example: "Autographed or mint condition - which matters more to you?"
Vintage toys or modern pop culture items - what is your style?
💡 Example: "Vintage toys or modern pop culture items - what is your style?"
Comic books or coins - if you had to choose only one?
💡 Example: "Comic books or coins - if you had to choose only one?"
First edition or complete set - what is your collector goal?
💡 Example: "First edition or complete set - what is your collector goal?"
Hunt for bargains or invest in rare finds - which collector are you?
💡 Example: "Hunt for bargains or invest in rare finds - which collector are you?"
Keep in original packaging or unbox and display?
💡 Example: "Keep in original packaging or unbox and display?"
Collect alone or join group hunts - what is more fun for you?
💡 Example: "Collect alone or join group hunts - what is more fun for you?"
Digital collectibles or physical items - what is your preference?
💡 Example: "Digital collectibles or physical items - what is your preference?"
Focus on one theme or collect everything that excites you?
💡 Example: "Focus on one theme or collect everything that excites you?"
Trade with others or keep your collection private?
💡 Example: "Trade with others or keep your collection private?"
Attend conventions or stick to online communities?
💡 Example: "Attend conventions or stick to online communities?"
Collect for nostalgia or for investment value?
💡 Example: "Collect for nostalgia or for investment value?"
Find hidden gems or chase trending items?
💡 Example: "Find hidden gems or chase trending items?"
Organize by year or by category - how do you sort your collection?
💡 Example: "Organize by year or by category - how do you sort your collection?"
Collect items from your childhood or explore new fandoms?
💡 Example: "Collect items from your childhood or explore new fandoms?"
Showcase your favorites or rotate displays often?
💡 Example: "Showcase your favorites or rotate displays often?"
Collect limited runs or go for mass releases?
💡 Example: "Collect limited runs or go for mass releases?"
Preserve in sleeves or frame your collectibles?
💡 Example: "Preserve in sleeves or frame your collectibles?"
Collect alone or involve family and friends?
💡 Example: "Collect alone or involve family and friends?"
Vintage posters or signed memorabilia - which would you choose?
💡 Example: "Vintage posters or signed memorabilia - which would you choose?"
Collect for fun or for the thrill of rare finds?
💡 Example: "Collect for fun or for the thrill of rare finds?"
Catalog your collection or keep it spontaneous?
💡 Example: "Catalog your collection or keep it spontaneous?"
Collect for yourself or as gifts for others?
💡 Example: "Collect for yourself or as gifts for others?"
Join auctions or stick to direct sales?
💡 Example: "Join auctions or stick to direct sales?"
Display by color or by brand - what looks best to you?
💡 Example: "Display by color or by brand - what looks best to you?"
Collect items with stories or focus on pristine pieces?
💡 Example: "Collect items with stories or focus on pristine pieces?"
Hunt locally or search worldwide?
💡 Example: "Hunt locally or search worldwide?"
Collect small items or go for statement pieces?
💡 Example: "Collect small items or go for statement pieces?"
Find deals or splurge on dream pieces?
💡 Example: "Find deals or splurge on dream pieces? Tell us your pick!"
Collect with a plan or let your collection grow naturally?
💡 Example: "Collect with a plan or let your collection grow naturally?"
Originals or replicas - what do you prefer to collect?
💡 Example: "Originals or replicas - what do you prefer to collect?"
Collect for display or as an investment?
💡 Example: "Collect for display or as an investment?"
Collect what you love or follow market trends?
💡 Example: "Collect what you love or follow market trends?"
Collect monthly or only on special occasions?
💡 Example: "Collect monthly or only on special occasions?"
Collect signed items or rare color variants?
💡 Example: "Collect signed items or rare color variants? Share your answer!"
Collect solo or with a collecting buddy?
💡 Example: "Collect solo or with a collecting buddy?"
Collecting for decades or just starting out?
💡 Example: "Collecting for decades or just starting out?"
Collect for fun or with a serious strategy? Why did you choose?
💡 Example: "Collect for fun or with a serious strategy? Why did you choose?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your chosen prompt into your community platform. You can schedule them as regular posts, use them to break the ice during live chats, or drop them into story features and polls. Encourage members to comment with their choice and, if they want, a quick reason why. Rotate topics to keep things fresh and make sure to engage with responses to keep the conversation flowing.
These This or That templates work on all platforms. For forums, post as a new thread or in a daily question section. On social media, use as image captions, stories, or polls. In chat apps, drop prompts during peak times for quick replies. Always invite participation and react to answers to keep engagement high.
When creating This or That prompts for collectibles, consider iconic contrasts such as 'pre-war vs post-war baseball cards' or 'original release action figure vs reissue.' This not only sparks debate but also educates members about eras, authenticity, and value trends unique to collectibles.
Absolutely! Grading company preferences are a hot topic among collectors. Posing 'PSA vs BGS' or 'raw vs slabbed' as This or That can generate passionate discussions and help members share expertise about resale value, grading standards, and market trust—challenges specific to collectibles communities.
Use rivalries such as 'Funko vs Kidrobot,' 'Magic: The Gathering vs Pokémon,' or 'Topps vs Upper Deck' as This or That options. These are instantly recognizable to collectors and tap into brand loyalty and nostalgia, which are key drivers of engagement in collectibles spaces.
Yes, framing preservation debates as This or That ('displayed vs in-box,' 'acid-free sleeves vs top loaders') encourages respectful sharing of tips and philosophies. Encourage members to explain their choice, which can help newer collectors learn best practices for preservation—a common challenge in the industry.
Try prompts like 'SDCC Exclusive vs Retail Release' or 'Holiday Variant vs Standard Edition.' This leverages timely collecting moments and helps members compare the excitement and value of con exclusives versus mass market items, both of which influence buying decisions in collectibles communities.
Yes, investment strategy is a major topic among collectors. Options like 'hold for long-term vs flip for quick profit' or 'invest in graded comics vs raw comics' spark informed discussion about market timing, trends, and risk—unique challenges for those collecting for both passion and profit.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks