Getting honest community feedback is key to building a thriving collectibles group, but it can be tough to know what to ask or how to get people talking. These ready-to-use feedback templates will help you spark real conversations and learn what your members truly care about.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Community feedback posts create space for everyone to feel heard and valued. By inviting members to share their experiences, opinions, and suggestions, you tap into the collective knowledge and passions of your group. This builds trust and helps members feel invested in the community's direction.
Open-ended feedback questions encourage a diversity of perspectives, uncovering insights that might otherwise go unnoticed. When members see that their input leads to real changes or improvements, they become more engaged and loyal, fostering a stronger sense of belonging and ownership.
Collectibles communities thrive on shared enthusiasm and expertise. Regularly seeking feedback ensures your group evolves with its members, staying relevant, welcoming, and highly active.
What collectible category do you wish we covered more? Tell us why.
💡 Example: "What collectible category do you wish we covered more? Tell us why. Example: Vintage toys because they are underrated."
How do you feel about our monthly spotlight posts? Any ideas to improve them?
💡 Example: "How do you feel about our monthly spotlight posts? Any ideas to improve them? Example: Maybe add more collector interviews."
Which part of the group do you enjoy most - discussion, trading, or news?
💡 Example: "Which part of the group do you enjoy most - discussion, trading, or news? Example: I like the trading section."
What is one feature you would like to see added to our community?
💡 Example: "What is one feature you would like to see added to our community? Example: A collectibles price tracker."
Have our rules and guidelines been clear? How could we make them better?
💡 Example: "Have our rules and guidelines been clear? How could we make them better? Example: Maybe post them at the top of the group."
What types of collectibles should we highlight next month?
💡 Example: "What types of collectibles should we highlight next month? Example: Limited edition cards."
If you could change one thing about our trading process, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could change one thing about our trading process, what would it be? Example: Add a safety checklist."
What format do you prefer for community updates - posts, videos, or emails?
💡 Example: "What format do you prefer for community updates - posts, videos, or emails? Example: I prefer posts."
Share your thoughts on our group’s trading safety resources.
💡 Example: "Share your thoughts on our group’s trading safety resources. Example: The safety tips are helpful."
Which recent event or challenge did you enjoy most? Any suggestions for future ones?
💡 Example: "Which recent event or challenge did you enjoy most? Any suggestions for future ones? Example: The trivia night was great, maybe try a photo contest next."
How easy is it to find information about your favorite collectibles here?
💡 Example: "How easy is it to find information about your favorite collectibles here? Example: Sometimes it is hard to search old posts."
What would make you participate more in our group activities?
💡 Example: "What would make you participate more in our group activities? Example: More beginner-friendly events."
Do you feel your knowledge as a collector is growing here? Why or why not?
💡 Example: "Do you feel your knowledge as a collector is growing here? Why or why not? Example: Yes, because of the detailed guides."
If you have invited friends, what did you tell them about our group?
💡 Example: "If you have invited friends, what did you tell them about our group? Example: That it is friendly and helpful."
What is one topic you wish we would discuss more in the community?
💡 Example: "What is one topic you wish we would discuss more in the community? Example: Proper storage tips."
How would you rate our community vibe? What could make it even better?
💡 Example: "How would you rate our community vibe? What could make it even better? Example: It is welcoming, maybe add an intro thread."
Tell us about your favorite group memory so far.
💡 Example: "Tell us about your favorite group memory so far. Example: Winning my first prize in a giveaway."
Is there a collectible expert you would like us to invite for a Q&A?
💡 Example: "Is there a collectible expert you would like us to invite for a Q&A? Example: Would love to hear from Sarah Smith about vintage comics."
How satisfied are you with our moderation? Any suggestions?
💡 Example: "How satisfied are you with our moderation? Any suggestions? Example: Moderation is good, maybe respond faster to reports."
What is the biggest challenge you face as a collector? How can we help?
💡 Example: "What is the biggest challenge you face as a collector? How can we help? Example: Finding reliable sellers."
Do you like our current posting schedule? Would you change anything?
💡 Example: "Do you like our current posting schedule? Would you change anything? Example: More posts on weekends."
What type of giveaways do you find most exciting?
💡 Example: "What type of giveaways do you find most exciting? Example: Mystery box giveaways."
How do you prefer to learn about new releases or drops?
💡 Example: "How do you prefer to learn about new releases or drops? Example: Email alerts."
Have you ever traded with another member here? How was your experience?
💡 Example: "Have you ever traded with another member here? How was your experience? Example: Yes, it was smooth and friendly."
What makes you feel most welcome in this community?
💡 Example: "What makes you feel most welcome in this community? Example: Friendly greetings from admins."
What can we do to help new members get started?
💡 Example: "What can we do to help new members get started? Example: Create a beginner's guide post."
Which collectible trends do you want us to cover in-depth?
💡 Example: "Which collectible trends do you want us to cover in-depth? Example: NFT-based collectibles."
How can we make our group more inclusive to all types of collectors?
💡 Example: "How can we make our group more inclusive to all types of collectors? Example: Spotlight lesser-known collectible types."
What was your first impression when you joined? Is it the same now?
💡 Example: "What was your first impression when you joined? Is it the same now? Example: I thought it was quiet, but now it feels lively."
What would help you connect with other collectors here?
💡 Example: "What would help you connect with other collectors here? Example: A monthly member meetup thread."
Do you use our resource guides? What could make them more helpful?
💡 Example: "Do you use our resource guides? What could make them more helpful? Example: Add more images."
What is your favorite way to contribute to the community?
💡 Example: "What is your favorite way to contribute to the community? Example: Sharing photos of my collection."
How often would you like us to host live events or Q&A sessions?
💡 Example: "How often would you like us to host live events or Q&A sessions? Example: Once a month."
What topics should we avoid or handle with extra care?
💡 Example: "What topics should we avoid or handle with extra care? Example: Pricing disputes."
Do you feel comfortable asking questions here? How can we improve?
💡 Example: "Do you feel comfortable asking questions here? How can we improve? Example: Yes, but sometimes replies are slow."
What motivates you to stay active in our group?
💡 Example: "What motivates you to stay active in our group? Example: Learning from others."
If you could change one thing about our group, what would it be?
💡 Example: "If you could change one thing about our group, what would it be? Example: More themed weeks."
How do you feel about our approach to handling disputes or issues?
💡 Example: "How do you feel about our approach to handling disputes or issues? Example: Fair, but updates would help."
What would make our collectible guides more useful for you?
💡 Example: "What would make our collectible guides more useful for you? Example: Add video walkthroughs."
What are some ways we can recognize active or helpful members?
💡 Example: "What are some ways we can recognize active or helpful members? Example: Monthly member shoutouts."
Is there anything stopping you from posting more often?
💡 Example: "Is there anything stopping you from posting more often? Example: Not sure what to share."
What do you wish you knew when you first joined the collectibles world?
💡 Example: "What do you wish you knew when you first joined the collectibles world? Example: How to avoid scams."
Choose a template that matches your current goal or topic, then post it to your group as-is or adapt it to fit your community's voice. Encourage responses by tagging members, pinning the post, or reminding everyone that their input directly shapes the group. After collecting feedback, share a summary or next steps so members know their voices matter.
Since these templates are designed for all platforms, adjust formatting for your platform's features. Use polls for quick answers, threads for deeper discussions, and stories or reels for instant reactions. Always follow your platform's guidelines to ensure posts stay visible and accessible.
You can adapt the templates to create targeted feedback posts asking members about their experiences and preferences with different grading services, such as PSA, BGS, or SGC. Frame questions around trust in grading accuracy, turnaround times, and impact on resale value. This helps surface community sentiment and informs potential group standards for trading or displaying graded items.
Use the templates to prompt discussions about specific authentication practices—like COA (Certificate of Authenticity), provenance tracking, or third-party verification. You can ask members to share their preferred methods, past issues with fakes, or recommend trusted authenticators. This will help educate the community and build collective expertise on spotting counterfeit items.
Leverage scenario-driven templates to gauge community appetite for collaborative activities like case breaks or blind box events. Ask members which product lines they’re most interested in, preferred price points, and previous experiences with such formats. This ensures you’re organizing engaging events tailored to actual member interest and budget.
Absolutely. Use the feedback templates to poll members about their experiences on various trading platforms. Inquire about transaction safety, ease of communication, fee structures, and overall satisfaction. This information can guide your community in recommending the safest and most effective platforms for peer-to-peer trades.
Customize the templates to solicit detailed feedback on collection displays—such as shelving types, lighting choices, or humidity control for preservation. Encourage members to share photos and ask specific questions about aesthetics versus preservation. This fosters mutual inspiration and helps solve common display challenges unique to collectibles.
Modify the feedback templates to gather insights on recent trade experiences, dispute resolution preferences, or scam encounters. Ask for suggestions on improving trust, such as implementing a vouching system or escrow service. This community-driven feedback can inform better group rules and educational posts on safe trading practices.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks