Want to spark more fun and quick engagement in your carnivore community? These This or That templates are designed to break the ice, get members talking, and invite everyone to share their preferences. Make your space lively and interactive with simple, playful choices.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That content works because it lowers the barrier to participation. Members feel comfortable answering light and easy questions without overthinking or worrying about being judged. By giving just two options, you make engagement almost effortless, even for shy or new members.
Psychologically, quick-choice prompts trigger instant reactions and tap into members' desire to share opinions. They create a sense of belonging as people see others with similar or different preferences. In the carnivore niche, these posts can also spark conversation and friendly debates about food choices, routines, and lifestyle, strengthening community bonds.
Ribeye or New York strip - which steak wins for you?
💡 Example: "Ribeye or New York strip - which steak wins for you?"
Morning bacon or evening brisket - which would you pick and why?
💡 Example: "Morning bacon or evening brisket - which would you pick and why?"
Ground beef or steak - what do you eat more often?
💡 Example: "Ground beef or steak - what do you eat more often?"
Salt or no salt on your meat?
💡 Example: "Salt or no salt on your meat?"
Grilled or pan-seared - how do you like your steaks?
💡 Example: "Grilled or pan-seared - how do you like your steaks?"
Eggs with yolk or just the whites?
💡 Example: "Eggs with yolk or just the whites?"
Oxtail or short ribs - which do you crave more?
💡 Example: "Oxtail or short ribs - which do you crave more?"
Lamb chops or pork chops - what is your go-to?
💡 Example: "Lamb chops or pork chops - what is your go-to?"
Cook at home or eat out on carnivore?
💡 Example: "Cook at home or eat out on carnivore?"
Spicy sausage or mild sausage?
💡 Example: "Spicy sausage or mild sausage?"
Butter or tallow for cooking?
💡 Example: "Butter or tallow for cooking?"
Rare or well-done steak?
💡 Example: "Rare or well-done steak?"
Organ meats or muscle meats - what do you eat more?
💡 Example: "Organ meats or muscle meats - what do you eat more?"
Carnivore pizza or carnivore burgers?
💡 Example: "Carnivore pizza or carnivore burgers?"
Beef liver or chicken liver - which one do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Beef liver or chicken liver - which one do you prefer?"
Carnivore snacks - jerky or pork rinds?
💡 Example: "Carnivore snacks - jerky or pork rinds?"
Meal prep or spontaneous cooking?
💡 Example: "Meal prep or spontaneous cooking?"
Fish or shellfish - what do you pick when you want seafood?
💡 Example: "Fish or shellfish - what do you pick when you want seafood?"
Simple steak or steak with butter on top?
💡 Example: "Simple steak or steak with butter on top?"
One big meal a day or several small meals?
💡 Example: "One big meal a day or several small meals?"
Hard-boiled eggs or scrambled eggs?
💡 Example: "Hard-boiled eggs or scrambled eggs?"
Carnivore coffee - black or with butter?
💡 Example: "Carnivore coffee - black or with butter?"
Chicken thighs or chicken breasts?
💡 Example: "Chicken thighs or chicken breasts?"
Meaty breakfast or skip breakfast?
💡 Example: "Meaty breakfast or skip breakfast?"
Homemade broth or store-bought?
💡 Example: "Homemade broth or store-bought?"
Beef ribs or pork ribs - which is your favorite?
💡 Example: "Beef ribs or pork ribs - which is your favorite?"
Eat alone or with friends and family?
💡 Example: "Eat alone or with friends and family?"
Carnivore taco shells - cheese or pork rinds?
💡 Example: "Carnivore taco shells - cheese or pork rinds?"
Slow-cooked or grilled meats?
💡 Example: "Slow-cooked or grilled meats?"
Do you prefer beef or pork as your main protein?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer beef or pork as your main protein?"
Organ meats cooked or raw?
💡 Example: "Organ meats cooked or raw?"
Do you eat bone marrow or skip it?
💡 Example: "Do you eat bone marrow or skip it?"
Carnivore ice cream or skip dessert?
💡 Example: "Carnivore ice cream or skip dessert?"
Eat when hungry or scheduled meal times?
💡 Example: "Eat when hungry or scheduled meal times?"
Do you track macros or keep it intuitive?
💡 Example: "Do you track macros or keep it intuitive?"
Fatty cuts or lean cuts - what do you choose more often?
💡 Example: "Fatty cuts or lean cuts - what do you choose more often?"
Steak for breakfast or steak for dinner?
💡 Example: "Steak for breakfast or steak for dinner?"
Carnivore travel - pack food or find local spots?
💡 Example: "Carnivore travel - pack food or find local spots?"
Do you prefer classic steak seasoning or just salt?
💡 Example: "Do you prefer classic steak seasoning or just salt?"
Carnivore chili - with or without eggs?
💡 Example: "Carnivore chili - with or without eggs?"
Post a This or That template as a standalone question, a story, or even in your group chat. Encourage members to answer in the comments and share their reasons if they like. Use these templates to kick off the week, fill quiet periods, or welcome new members. Rotate topics to keep things fresh and relevant to the carnivore lifestyle.
For all platforms, keep your This or That posts concise and visually clean. Use polls where supported, or ask members to reply with their choice. On platforms with Stories, use interactive stickers. In forums or chats, highlight the question at the top of your post. Always follow up with replies to keep the thread alive.
To engage your Carnivore community, design 'This or That' posts that spotlight both staple ruminant cuts and more adventurous choices like heart, liver, or wild game. Use clear visuals and context, such as flavor profiles, nutrient density, or preparation methods. This helps both seasoned carnivores and newcomers explore the variety and benefits within the diet, sparking discussion and sharing of preparation tips.
Polarizing Carnivore topics like raw vs cooked can drive engagement but may also stir controversy. Set clear community guidelines for respectful discussion, and preface posts by encouraging members to share personal experience rather than debate dogma. Consider adding a disclaimer or prompt, such as 'Share what works for you and why,' to keep conversations constructive.
Address community interest in zero-carb versus low-carb by designing 'This or That' posts that compare meal types, such as 'ribeye only' vs 'ribeye with eggs.' Use template prompts that highlight real Carnivore dilemmas, like seasoning choices (salt-only vs spices) or meal frequency (one meal a day vs two). These nuanced scenarios foster relevant, authentic interaction.
Craft 'This or That' questions that reflect common Carnivore challenges, such as 'electrolyte drinks vs incorporating more kidney/liver.' Use the template to prompt members to share their experiences managing issues like cramps or fatigue. This fosters peer-to-peer support and helps the community learn practical solutions specific to the Carnivore lifestyle.
Absolutely! Create 'This or That' scenarios like 'no dairy vs heavy cream & cheese' to reflect ongoing debates in the Carnivore world. Encourage members to discuss their tolerance, preferences, and results. These posts can clarify differing interpretations of the Carnivore diet and help new members make informed choices.
Highlight regional differences by featuring 'This or That' comparisons relevant to your audience, such as 'grass-fed beef vs grain-fed beef' or 'venison vs bison.' Include prompts about taste, availability, and price. This approach makes the content relatable across global Carnivore communities and encourages members to share sourcing tips and local experiences.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks