Need a quick way to spark conversation in your boating community? This or That posts are the perfect low-pressure, high-engagement icebreakers. Use these playful prompts to get members picking sides and sharing their boating preferences in seconds.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That templates work because they lower the barrier for participation. Members do not have to craft long responses or worry about saying the 'right' thing. Instead, they pick a side and, if they want, share a quick reason why. This format invites even shy or busy members to engage, helping to transform lurkers into contributors.
The playful, casual tone of This or That questions creates a fun atmosphere. By focusing on lighthearted boating topics, you encourage spontaneous answers and friendly banter. These simple prompts often lead to lively discussions, debates, and shared stories, deepening community bonds and keeping your group active.
Sailing or powerboating - which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Sailing or powerboating - which do you prefer? I am team sailing!"
Lake days or ocean adventures?
💡 Example: "Lake days or ocean adventures? Tell us why you picked your favorite!"
Early morning cruises or sunset rides?
💡 Example: "Early morning cruises or sunset rides? I love the sunsets!"
Fishing trips or watersports fun?
💡 Example: "Fishing trips or watersports fun? I am always up for watersports."
Solo boating or group outings?
💡 Example: "Solo boating or group outings? Share your reason!"
Anchor out or dock up?
💡 Example: "Anchor out or dock up? I prefer to anchor out every time."
Cooler full of snacks or grilling on board?
💡 Example: "Cooler full of snacks or grilling on board? Let us know your pick!"
Smooth sailing or choppy challenge?
💡 Example: "Smooth sailing or choppy challenge? I like a little adventure!"
Music on deck or peace and quiet?
💡 Example: "Music on deck or peace and quiet? Give me quiet every time."
Sandbar stops or hidden coves?
💡 Example: "Sandbar stops or hidden coves? Tell us your favorite!"
Life jackets in bright colors or classic white?
💡 Example: "Life jackets in bright colors or classic white? I like the bright ones."
Canoe or kayak for exploring?
💡 Example: "Canoe or kayak for exploring? Kayak is my go-to."
Chartplotter or compass?
💡 Example: "Chartplotter or compass? I trust my chartplotter."
Swim off the boat or stay dry on deck?
💡 Example: "Swim off the boat or stay dry on deck? Which are you?"
Classic wooden boats or modern fiberglass?
💡 Example: "Classic wooden boats or modern fiberglass? I love the classics."
Short day trip or long weekend adventure?
💡 Example: "Short day trip or long weekend adventure? Vote in the comments!"
Sun hat or baseball cap on board?
💡 Example: "Sun hat or baseball cap on board? Baseball cap for me."
Bare feet or boating shoes?
💡 Example: "Bare feet or boating shoes? Shoes for safety."
Bring the dog or leave pets at home?
💡 Example: "Bring the dog or leave pets at home? Share your pet pics if you can!"
Towing a tube or wakeboarding?
💡 Example: "Towing a tube or wakeboarding? I love wakeboarding."
Saltwater or freshwater boating?
💡 Example: "Saltwater or freshwater boating? Freshwater for me."
Pack sandwiches or fire up the grill?
💡 Example: "Pack sandwiches or fire up the grill? Sandwiches are easy!"
Sunny skies or gentle rain on the water?
💡 Example: "Sunny skies or gentle rain on the water? Which would you pick?"
Shorts or swim trunks while boating?
💡 Example: "Shorts or swim trunks while boating? Swim trunks always."
Maps app or paper charts?
💡 Example: "Maps app or paper charts? Maps app is so handy."
Fishing rod or camera as your must-have?
💡 Example: "Fishing rod or camera as your must-have? Camera every time."
Quiet cove or busy marina?
💡 Example: "Quiet cove or busy marina? Which do you prefer and why?"
Polarized sunglasses or regular shades?
💡 Example: "Polarized sunglasses or regular shades? Polarized all the way."
Daytime boating or night cruising?
💡 Example: "Daytime boating or night cruising? Tell us your favorite time!"
Bring kids onboard or adults only?
💡 Example: "Bring kids onboard or adults only? Kids make it more fun!"
Classic anchor or modern electric anchor?
💡 Example: "Classic anchor or modern electric anchor? I trust the classic."
Boat shoes or flip flops?
💡 Example: "Boat shoes or flip flops? Flip flops for comfort."
Quick swim or sunbathe on deck?
💡 Example: "Quick swim or sunbathe on deck? What is your go-to?"
Binoculars or drone for sightseeing?
💡 Example: "Binoculars or drone for sightseeing? Drone is so cool!"
Classic nautical stripes or bold colors for boat decor?
💡 Example: "Classic nautical stripes or bold colors for boat decor? Stripes for me."
Ice-cold lemonade or hot coffee on board?
💡 Example: "Ice-cold lemonade or hot coffee on board? What is your pick?"
Reading a book or chatting with friends during downtime?
💡 Example: "Reading a book or chatting with friends during downtime? I love to read."
Bluetooth speakers or nature sounds?
💡 Example: "Bluetooth speakers or nature sounds? Nature sounds for me."
Fishing sunrise or sunset?
💡 Example: "Fishing sunrise or sunset? Vote for your favorite!"
Plan every detail or go with the flow?
💡 Example: "Plan every detail or go with the flow? I like to plan ahead."
Favorite spot - local river or faraway bay?
💡 Example: "Favorite spot - local river or faraway bay? Share your pick!"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your chosen prompt into a post or story on your preferred platform. You can encourage members to reply in the comments, use poll features, or even share their answers in a chat thread. Rotate through different This or That topics to keep content fresh, and invite members to suggest their own pairings. For higher engagement, occasionally ask members to explain their choices or share a photo that matches their pick.
On all platforms, keep text concise and options clear. Use emojis to highlight choices if your platform supports them. On forums, pin This or That threads for ongoing engagement. On social media, try using poll or story features for quick responses. Encourage replies and tag active members to jumpstart participation. Rotate themes to match seasons or boating events.
Both are excellent themes for This or That posts, as they spark conversation among boaters with varying experiences and preferences. Choosing between destinations or boat types depends on your community’s interests: if your members often discuss travel and exploration, destinations are ideal; if they’re passionate about gear and vessel performance, focus on boat types. Mix both themes over time to appeal to a wider range of members and keep engagement fresh.
Safety is a core concern for all boaters, so crafting This or That posts about safety gear or protocols can drive valuable dialogue. For example, ask: 'Would you rather always wear a life jacket or rely on throwable flotation devices?' When posting, briefly explain each option’s pros and cons and encourage members to share their real-life experiences. This not only educates but also fosters a culture of safety within your community.
Absolutely. Maintenance is a recurring topic among boaters, often leading to strong opinions and advice sharing. A post such as 'DIY winterization or hire a pro?' invites experienced members to offer tips and newcomers to ask questions. These posts are especially relevant in seasonal climates and can raise awareness about essential maintenance tasks.
Boating communities often include both tech-savvy members and traditionalists. Posts comparing analog vs. digital navigation, chartplotters vs. paper maps, or classic outboards vs. electric motors can prompt meaningful and respectful discussions. Set ground rules for polite debate, and consider highlighting the strengths of each approach or sharing polling results to keep interactions positive.
Yes, regional differences are deeply relevant in the boating world. Posts like 'Saltwater or freshwater: which do you prefer?' can lead to detailed conversations about maintenance challenges (e.g., corrosion), local regulations, wildlife encounters, and favorite activities. Participants can share advice and experiences unique to their area, fostering a sense of expertise and belonging.
Blending interests can unify a mixed boating community. Try posts such as 'Sailing or motor cruising for a weekend getaway?' or 'Do you prefer trimming sails or throttling up an engine?' These questions acknowledge the unique skills and joys of each group. Encourage members to share reasons for their preferences, stories from both perspectives, and even tips for trying the other style of boating.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks