Finding it hard to spark lively conversations in your beauty community? Would You Rather questions offer a fun, creative way to get members chatting, sharing, and connecting over their favorite beauty topics. With these ready-to-use templates, you will never run out of imaginative prompts to keep your group buzzing.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
Would You Rather questions invite members to step into playful scenarios, making beauty conversations more interactive and memorable. By offering two imaginative choices, these prompts lower the barrier to participation, encouraging even quieter members to join in with quick and easy responses.
Psychologically, hypothetical choices tap into curiosity and self-expression. Members love sharing their preferences and the reasoning behind their picks, which deepens community bonds and reveals unique perspectives. This format is approachable and fun, making it highly effective for boosting engagement and sparking deeper discussions in beauty-focused groups.
Would you rather never wear mascara again or never use lipstick again? Tell us why.
💡 Example: "I would rather never wear mascara again because I love how lipstick brightens my face!"
Would you rather have flawless skin forever or perfect hair every day?
💡 Example: "Perfect hair every day would make my mornings so much easier."
Would you rather do your skincare routine twice a day or skip it for a week?
💡 Example: "I would rather do it twice a day. My skin needs the love!"
Would you rather try a bold blue eyeshadow or neon green eyeliner? Drop your pick!
💡 Example: "Blue eyeshadow! It is more my style."
Would you rather use only drugstore products or only luxury brands for a year?
💡 Example: "I would pick drugstore products. There are so many good ones!"
Would you rather always have to contour or never use foundation again?
💡 Example: "Never use foundation! I can live with just contour."
Would you rather get a facial every week or a professional blowout every week?
💡 Example: "Facials all the way. My skin would thank me!"
Would you rather only wear matte lipstick or only glossy lipstick forever?
💡 Example: "Glossy lipstick is my go-to look!"
Would you rather have naturally long lashes or perfectly shaped brows?
💡 Example: "Perfect brows make such a difference for me."
Would you rather always have to do a 10-step skincare routine or only be allowed 3 products?
💡 Example: "Only 3 products! I like to keep it simple."
Would you rather dye your hair a wild color or cut it super short?
💡 Example: "Wild color for sure, I have always wanted purple hair!"
Would you rather have glowing skin or voluminous hair for life?
💡 Example: "Glowing skin is my top priority."
Would you rather be a makeup artist or a skincare expert? Share your dream!
💡 Example: "Makeup artist! I love being creative with colors."
Would you rather only use sheet masks or only use clay masks?
💡 Example: "Sheet masks are so relaxing after a long day."
Would you rather have perfect winged eyeliner every time or flawless foundation?
💡 Example: "Perfect eyeliner would save me so much time!"
Would you rather try a new hairstyle every week or a new makeup look?
💡 Example: "New makeup looks keep things interesting."
Would you rather always have to wear bold lipstick or no makeup at all?
💡 Example: "Bold lipstick! It is my signature."
Would you rather own every eyeshadow palette or every lipstick shade?
💡 Example: "All the lipstick shades! I love to switch it up."
Would you rather do a daily face mask or a weekly hair mask? Tell us your pick.
💡 Example: "Weekly hair mask - my hair needs the hydration."
Would you rather always have to go out with wet hair or no makeup?
💡 Example: "No makeup - I am comfortable in my own skin."
Would you rather have a never-ending supply of dry shampoo or makeup wipes?
💡 Example: "Dry shampoo is a lifesaver for busy mornings."
Would you rather get your nails done for free forever or always have perfect brows?
💡 Example: "Free nails for life would be amazing."
Would you rather have shimmer or matte eyeshadow for every look?
💡 Example: "Matte eyeshadow is versatile for any occasion."
Would you rather always have to use a bold blush or skip blush forever?
💡 Example: "Bold blush! It adds life to my face."
Would you rather shop only in-store or only online for beauty products?
💡 Example: "Online shopping is so much more convenient for me."
Would you rather have a signature fragrance or switch scents every season?
💡 Example: "I love having a signature scent."
Would you rather use only one brand for all your products or mix and match?
💡 Example: "Mix and match lets me try the best of everything."
Would you rather have to remove your makeup without remover or style your hair without tools?
💡 Example: "No remover would be tough, but I would try!"
Would you rather follow the latest trends or stick to classic beauty looks?
💡 Example: "I prefer classic looks, they never go out of style."
Would you rather be known for amazing makeup skills or flawless skin?
💡 Example: "Flawless skin is always in!"
Would you rather have to apply false lashes daily or never use eyeliner again?
💡 Example: "I would skip eyeliner. False lashes are fun!"
Would you rather try a viral TikTok beauty hack or stick to your trusted routine?
💡 Example: "Trying new hacks keeps beauty fun for me."
Would you rather never use highlighter or never use bronzer again?
💡 Example: "I would give up bronzer, I love a good glow."
Would you rather have your favorite celebrity's makeup artist or hairstylist for a day?
💡 Example: "A makeup artist would be a dream come true!"
Would you rather do a full face of makeup in 5 minutes or have unlimited time?
💡 Example: "Unlimited time lets me perfect every detail."
Would you rather only use your fingers or only brushes to apply makeup?
💡 Example: "Brushes give me a flawless finish."
Would you rather have to skip moisturizer or sunscreen for a month?
💡 Example: "I could never skip sunscreen!"
Would you rather have perfect teeth or perfect skin?
💡 Example: "Perfect skin all the way."
Would you rather splurge on skincare or makeup? Share your top pick.
💡 Example: "I invest most in skincare for lasting results."
Would you rather always have to wear red lipstick or black nail polish?
💡 Example: "Red lipstick is a classic for any occasion."
Would you rather only wear updos or only loose hair forever?
💡 Example: "Loose hair is my comfort zone."
Would you rather have the perfect cat eye or the perfect red lip every time?
💡 Example: "Perfect red lip! Makes a statement every time."
To use these templates, simply copy and paste a question into your community platform of choice, then invite members to respond with their pick and reasoning. Rotate through different themes like skincare, makeup, and hair to keep conversations fresh. Encourage members to tag friends or reply to others, and consider pinning your favorite threads to highlight top responses.
Since these templates are designed for all platforms, adapt your approach to suit each space. On Instagram, pair questions with striking visuals or Stories stickers. In Facebook or Discord groups, pin popular threads and prompt follow-up discussions. For platforms like Twitter, keep questions concise and use polls for easy participation.
Focus on formulating Would You Rather questions that compare popular or controversial beauty ingredients. For example, 'Would you rather use a serum with niacinamide or one with hyaluronic acid for a month?' This approach encourages members to share their personal experiences, ingredient preferences, and skincare routines—key topics in beauty communities.
Tailor your questions to reflect common beauty routines and dilemmas, such as, 'Would you rather never use sheet masks again or never use clay masks again?' This resonates with beauty lovers, sparks debate on product efficacy, and helps members share their favorite brands or tips.
Pose Would You Rather scenarios based on specific application techniques, like 'Would you rather do your foundation with a beauty blender or a brush for the rest of your life?' Such questions invite members to discuss technique pros and cons, recommend tools, and share application hacks unique to makeup communities.
Yes! Craft questions that highlight real-life beauty decisions, such as 'Would you rather spend $500 on professional facials or buy a high-end at-home LED skincare device?' These scenarios reflect the investment choices beauty lovers face and can spark conversations about value, results, and personal experiences.
When creating haircare-related Would You Rather questions, use terminology and scenarios that apply to a range of hair types, such as, 'Would you rather never use heat styling tools or never use leave-in conditioner again?' This ensures all members—whether curly, coily, straight, or wavy-haired—see themselves in the conversation.
Absolutely! Seasonal beauty dilemmas make great Would You Rather topics, for instance: 'Would you rather never use SPF in summer or never use heavy moisturizer in winter?' These questions tap into timely concerns, encourage product recommendations, and keep engagement high throughout the year.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks