Running out of fresh ways to spark conversations in your barber community? This or That posts make it easy to connect with members and get everyone sharing their quick picks. Use these fun prompts to engage your audience without extra effort.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That content works because it lowers the barrier to participation. Members can reply with a single word, emoji, or short sentence, making it perfect for both active contributors and quieter members. The playful nature of contrasting options encourages spontaneous engagement and keeps conversations lighthearted.
For barber communities, these prompts let members share preferences on styles, tools, and trends while bonding over shared experiences. They also help create a welcoming environment where everyone feels comfortable chiming in. Frequent use of this format keeps your feed active and brings out unique insights from your community.
Fade or taper - which do you prefer for your next cut?
💡 Example: "Fade or taper - which do you prefer for your next cut? I am team fade!"
Beard balm or beard oil - what is your go-to?
💡 Example: "Beard balm or beard oil - what is your go-to? I use oil daily!"
Classic straight razor or modern electric trimmer?
💡 Example: "Classic straight razor or modern electric trimmer? I like the straight razor."
Hot towel shave or dry shave - which feels better?
💡 Example: "Hot towel shave or dry shave - which feels better? Hot towel all the way!"
Short back and sides or long and textured top?
💡 Example: "Short back and sides or long and textured top? I prefer short back and sides."
Pomade or matte clay for styling?
💡 Example: "Pomade or matte clay for styling? Matte clay for me."
Book online or walk-in appointments?
💡 Example: "Book online or walk-in appointments? I always book online."
Barber cape or towel for your cut?
💡 Example: "Barber cape or towel for your cut? Cape for sure."
Buzz cut or crew cut - which would you choose?
💡 Example: "Buzz cut or crew cut - which would you choose? Crew cut for me."
Mustache or full beard - which suits you best?
💡 Example: "Mustache or full beard - which suits you best? I am a full beard guy."
Coffee at the barbershop or tea while you wait?
💡 Example: "Coffee at the barbershop or tea while you wait? Coffee every time."
Old-school barbershop or modern minimalist vibe?
💡 Example: "Old-school barbershop or modern minimalist vibe? Old-school for me."
Clean shave or stubble look?
💡 Example: "Clean shave or stubble look? Stubble all the way."
Blow-dry or air-dry after a cut?
💡 Example: "Blow-dry or air-dry after a cut? I always air-dry."
Lined-up edges or natural finish?
💡 Example: "Lined-up edges or natural finish? Lined-up for me."
Classic comb-over or trendy crop cut?
💡 Example: "Classic comb-over or trendy crop cut? Crop cut is my pick."
Beard trim at the shop or DIY at home?
💡 Example: "Beard trim at the shop or DIY at home? I trust my barber."
Classic barbershop pole or no pole outside?
💡 Example: "Classic barbershop pole or no pole outside? Always love the pole."
Fresh cut in the morning or afternoon appointment?
💡 Example: "Fresh cut in the morning or afternoon appointment? Morning always."
Loud music or chill vibes at the barbershop?
💡 Example: "Loud music or chill vibes at the barbershop? Chill vibes for sure."
Big beard or clean shave for summer?
💡 Example: "Big beard or clean shave for summer? Clean shave for me."
Wet look or natural finish for your hair?
💡 Example: "Wet look or natural finish for your hair? Natural finish for sure."
Barber chair with a headrest or without?
💡 Example: "Barber chair with a headrest or without? Love the headrest."
Shampoo at the shop or skip it?
💡 Example: "Shampoo at the shop or skip it? I never skip it."
Barbershop talk or quiet cut?
💡 Example: "Barbershop talk or quiet cut? I love a good chat."
Hair wash before or after the cut?
💡 Example: "Hair wash before or after the cut? Always before for me."
Short beard or long beard for fall?
💡 Example: "Short beard or long beard for fall? I go long in fall."
Classic scissors or clippers for your cut?
💡 Example: "Classic scissors or clippers for your cut? Clippers for me."
Barbershop playlist: hip hop or jazz?
💡 Example: "Barbershop playlist: hip hop or jazz? Jazz sets the mood."
Barber apron or classic vest as work gear?
💡 Example: "Barber apron or classic vest as work gear? I like the apron."
Sharp part or messy part in your hair?
💡 Example: "Sharp part or messy part in your hair? Messy part for me."
Trim eyebrows at the shop or leave them natural?
💡 Example: "Trim eyebrows at the shop or leave them natural? I get them trimmed."
Weekly cut or monthly cut routine?
💡 Example: "Weekly cut or monthly cut routine? I go once a month."
Textured crop or slicked back look?
💡 Example: "Textured crop or slicked back look? I choose textured crop."
Barber shop selfie: post or pass?
💡 Example: "Barber shop selfie: post or pass? I usually pass."
Round brush or flat brush for styling?
💡 Example: "Round brush or flat brush for styling? Flat brush is easier."
Undercut or mullet comeback?
💡 Example: "Undercut or mullet comeback? Undercut looks cleaner."
Barbershop banter or focused silence?
💡 Example: "Barbershop banter or focused silence? Banter is the best part."
Celebrate a fresh cut with a photo or just enjoy it?
💡 Example: "Celebrate a fresh cut with a photo or just enjoy it? Just enjoy it."
Edge-up or natural neckline?
💡 Example: "Edge-up or natural neckline? Edge-up for me."
More important: sharp scissors or clean clippers?
💡 Example: "More important: sharp scissors or clean clippers? Clean clippers!"
Go-to: classic cut or try something new?
💡 Example: "Go-to: classic cut or try something new? I always try something new."
Choose a This or That template from below and post it as a regular discussion topic or story. Encourage quick replies by sharing your own answer or tagging a few members to start. Mix up your posts by focusing on different themes like haircuts, beard care, or products. Rotate prompts weekly or during slow periods to keep engagement steady. Track which topics get the most responses and tailor future prompts to your community's interests.
For all platforms, use clear visuals if possible to highlight your This or That choices. On social media, pair your question with images or polls for faster responses. In forums or group chats, keep the prompt at the top for visibility. On all platforms, interact with every reply to keep the conversation flowing.
Highlighting well-known barbering techniques such as skin fades and taper fades sparks conversation among both professionals and clients. Use your This or That templates to showcase high-quality images or videos of each style and ask community members to vote for their favorite or share which technique they prefer using or receiving. This not only engages your audience but also educates newer barbers about trending techniques.
Absolutely. Many barbers and clients have strong preferences about tools, and posts comparing classics like straight razors to modern electric trimmers can generate lively debate. Use your templates to spotlight benefits, challenges, or maintenance tips for each tool, encouraging members to share their personal experiences or recommendations for different client needs.
Beard versus clean-shaven debates are timeless in barbering circles. Use your templates to feature before-and-after transformations or celebrity inspirations for each style. Ask members about grooming preferences, care routines, or which look they find more challenging to achieve for clients. This drives both engagement and shared expertise.
Focus your This or That templates on trending client requests and popular cuts. Use visuals and ask members which style is more requested in their shops, or which they find more satisfying to execute. Invite discussion around cutting techniques, styling products used, or challenges specific to each cut, making the content highly relevant to working barbers.
Yes, comparing education routes is a hot topic among barbers. Use your templates to pose questions about the benefits and drawbacks of apprenticeships versus formal barber school training. Encourage members to share their paths, advice for newcomers, or tips for excelling in each setting. This fosters mentorship and informed decision-making in your community.
Shears-versus-clippers debates are common in barbering, especially when it comes to specific hair textures or styles. Use your This or That templates to set the scene—present a hair type or desired outcome, and ask members which tool they reach for and why. Encourage the sharing of techniques, tool brands, or even mistakes to avoid, making the discussion both practical and relatable.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks