Looking to break the ice and get your antiques community chatting? This or That posts make it easy to spark quick, friendly debates without pressure. Use these ready-made templates to liven up your feed and invite everyone to share their favorites.
Plan your content calendar and auto-post to Skool, Circle, or Mighty Networks
This or That content taps into our natural desire to compare and choose, making participation effortless and fun. By offering simple choices about antiques, you lower the barrier to entry, encouraging even shy or new members to join the conversation. This format works especially well for antiques communities because it celebrates diverse tastes, sparks nostalgia, and uncovers unique stories behind members' preferences.
Lighthearted prompts build a sense of belonging and allow members to showcase their interests without feeling judged. Quick answers mean more people join in, creating a snowball effect of engagement that benefits the entire group.
Victorian chair or Art Deco lamp? Which would you add to your home?
💡 Example: "Victorian chair or Art Deco lamp? Which would you add to your home?"
Porcelain figurines or antique clocks? Pick your favorite!
💡 Example: "Porcelain figurines or antique clocks? Pick your favorite!"
Would you rather browse a flea market or a high-end antique shop?
💡 Example: "Would you rather browse a flea market or a high-end antique shop?"
Silver spoons or vintage glassware? Which do you collect?
💡 Example: "Silver spoons or vintage glassware? Which do you collect?"
Old books or vintage postcards? Which would you display?
💡 Example: "Old books or vintage postcards? Which would you display?"
Would you keep a family heirloom or sell it to a collector?
💡 Example: "Would you keep a family heirloom or sell it to a collector?"
Classic typewriter or rotary phone? Which would you use as decor?
💡 Example: "Classic typewriter or rotary phone? Which would you use as decor?"
Antique maps or vintage travel posters? Which sparks your wanderlust?
💡 Example: "Antique maps or vintage travel posters? Which sparks your wanderlust?"
Would you rather restore furniture or collect as-is?
💡 Example: "Would you rather restore furniture or collect as-is?"
Mismatched china or matching set? Which would you set your table with?
💡 Example: "Mismatched china or matching set? Which would you set your table with?"
Antique jewelry or vintage watches? Which would you wear?
💡 Example: "Antique jewelry or vintage watches? Which would you wear?"
Would you rather visit an estate sale or a local auction?
💡 Example: "Would you rather visit an estate sale or a local auction?"
Oil painting or vintage photograph? Which would hang on your wall?
💡 Example: "Oil painting or vintage photograph? Which would hang on your wall?"
Would you choose a mid-century modern piece or a baroque classic?
💡 Example: "Would you choose a mid-century modern piece or a baroque classic?"
Antique toys or vintage games? Which would you rather find in your attic?
💡 Example: "Antique toys or vintage games? Which would you rather find in your attic?"
Would you rather own a gramophone or a jukebox?
💡 Example: "Would you rather own a gramophone or a jukebox?"
Gilded mirror or carved wooden frame? Which catches your eye?
💡 Example: "Gilded mirror or carved wooden frame? Which catches your eye?"
Would you rather display a vintage sign or an old advertisement poster?
💡 Example: "Would you rather display a vintage sign or an old advertisement poster?"
Pressed flower art or embroidered sampler? Which would you hang at home?
💡 Example: "Pressed flower art or embroidered sampler? Which would you hang at home?"
Would you rather discover a rare coin or a rare stamp?
💡 Example: "Would you rather discover a rare coin or a rare stamp?"
Antique globe or vintage atlas? Which would you choose for your shelf?
💡 Example: "Antique globe or vintage atlas? Which would you choose for your shelf?"
Would you rather restore a classic car or a horse-drawn carriage?
💡 Example: "Would you rather restore a classic car or a horse-drawn carriage?"
Tiffany lamp or Victorian chandelier? Which lights up your style?
💡 Example: "Tiffany lamp or Victorian chandelier? Which lights up your style?"
Would you rather hunt for antiques solo or with friends?
💡 Example: "Would you rather hunt for antiques solo or with friends?"
Cast iron cookware or copper pots? Which would you use in your kitchen?
💡 Example: "Cast iron cookware or copper pots? Which would you use in your kitchen?"
Would you rather inherit a trunk full of love letters or old photographs?
💡 Example: "Would you rather inherit a trunk full of love letters or old photographs?"
Antique sewing machine or vintage camera? Which would you display?
💡 Example: "Antique sewing machine or vintage camera? Which would you display?"
Would you restore a painting yourself or take it to a professional?
💡 Example: "Would you restore a painting yourself or take it to a professional?"
Old trunk or vintage suitcase? Which would you travel with?
💡 Example: "Old trunk or vintage suitcase? Which would you travel with?"
Would you rather decorate with antiques or keep things modern?
💡 Example: "Would you rather decorate with antiques or keep things modern?"
Antique desk or roll-top secretary? Which would you use for work?
💡 Example: "Antique desk or roll-top secretary? Which would you use for work?"
Would you rather find a rare book or a signed painting at a sale?
💡 Example: "Would you rather find a rare book or a signed painting at a sale?"
Lace tablecloth or hand-embroidered napkins? Which adds charm to your table?
💡 Example: "Lace tablecloth or hand-embroidered napkins? Which adds charm to your table?"
Would you rather tour a historic mansion or a preserved farmhouse?
💡 Example: "Would you rather tour a historic mansion or a preserved farmhouse?"
Antique pocket watch or vintage brooch? Which would you pass down?
💡 Example: "Antique pocket watch or vintage brooch? Which would you pass down?"
Would you rather display antique globes or vintage maps on your wall?
💡 Example: "Would you rather display antique globes or vintage maps on your wall?"
Patterned teacups or plain white china? Which do you prefer?
💡 Example: "Patterned teacups or plain white china? Which do you prefer?"
Would you rather discover a family letter or a personal diary from the past?
💡 Example: "Would you rather discover a family letter or a personal diary from the past?"
Antique perfume bottle or old apothecary jar? Which do you like more?
💡 Example: "Antique perfume bottle or old apothecary jar? Which do you like more?"
Would you rather have a room of antique furniture or vintage art?
💡 Example: "Would you rather have a room of antique furniture or vintage art?"
Vintage hatbox or old suitcase? Which storage piece appeals to you?
💡 Example: "Vintage hatbox or old suitcase? Which storage piece appeals to you?"
Would you rather collect antique keys or vintage locks?
💡 Example: "Would you rather collect antique keys or vintage locks?"
To use these templates, simply copy and paste your chosen prompt into your community platform. Encourage members to comment with their pick and share why they chose it. Rotate between different themes—decor, collections, eras—to keep things fresh and appeal to a wider audience. Mix in visual elements, like photos or polls, to add extra engagement. Adjust the frequency based on your community's activity, and always jump in to reply and keep the conversation going.
For all platforms, keep prompts short and mobile-friendly. Use images for visual interest when supported. On forums, add a poll for easy voting. On social media, invite responses in comments or stories. Stay consistent with posting to create anticipation and routine.
For antiques communities, mixing both restoration techniques and object type comparisons keeps content fresh and appeals to both collectors and restorers. Restoration technique matchups encourage discussion among hands-on members, while object type comparisons engage collectors and those interested in decor history.
Antiques enthusiasts often have passionate opinions about preservation versus restoration. Set clear guidelines encouraging respectful debate, and consider adding educational context to your post (e.g., explaining the historical significance of patina) to keep the conversation informative rather than divisive.
Both have high engagement potential, but era-based prompts invite historical discussion and storytelling, while material-based questions attract those with technical knowledge. Rotate between both to appeal to the diverse interests within antiques communities.
Phrase your questions to focus on general preferences or experiences, such as 'Do you rely more on hallmarks or provenance papers when evaluating authenticity?' Remind members not to share personal documents or serial numbers in public comments.
Using regional or specialized terms can spark curiosity and learning, but always provide brief explanations or images within the post to make it inclusive. This both educates newer members and keeps long-time collectors engaged.
Plan your prompts around the calendar, using seasonally-relevant antiques as This or That options. This taps into collecting habits that peak around holidays and encourages members to share related stories or photos, boosting community participation at key times.
Skool · Circle · Mighty Networks